User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > Improper Pass Blocking - LG Pulls and Leaves Middle Open - BUG FILED #269
Page:
 
blitzboy
offline
Link
 
in these pass plays, the LG continually pulls to block the outside LB and leaves a gaping hole in the middle for the RE to come straight in.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1388928&pbp_id=2605385
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1388928&pbp_id=2605460
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1388928&pbp_id=2605490
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1388928&pbp_id=2607026
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1388928&pbp_id=2607086
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1388928&pbp_id=2608862
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1388928&pbp_id=2609825
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1388928&pbp_id=2610807


along the same lines, the FB decides to help the double-teamed RE rather than pick up the blitzing RO
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1388928&pbp_id=2610807


Edited by Lensar on Oct 10, 2010 16:34:49
Edited by NiborRis on Oct 6, 2010 10:44:00 (To be filed)
Edited by Catch22 on Sep 30, 2010 00:17:57
Edited by robponce on Sep 28, 2010 17:31:13 (Bug, Second Verification)
Edited by NiborRis on Sep 28, 2010 11:48:29 (Bug, first verification)
 
Torg
offline
Link
 
looking at the second replay it looks like the OL is locking on pre snap to their guy. On the snap the LT tries to get the RE who has inside position and should be an obvious block for the LG. The LG however looks to be trying to jump out and get the blitzer which may not exactly be a bug but it is horrible logic. Blocking should be assigned from teh inside out presnap with a vision check for seeing blitzers.. in play 2 either LT and LG should double team the RE or the LT should drop his double team if the FS blitzes and he sees it.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
I'm gonna go ahead and call this likely a bug.

Lots of replays showing a custom alignment placing a DE over the OG or right between the OT and OG. Instead of stepping back and taking the DE, the OG tries to pull and pick up a blitzing LB or S. The OG should stay in for the DE and let the OT handle the blitz imo.

Likely a bug
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Not sure I agree. Most of those are just a slow ass OL player (<20 speed) getting beat. Go ahead and get verification and let the QA guys decide though.

This play for example is most definitely not a bug:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1388928&pbp_id=2605385

Either is this one:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1388928&pbp_id=2605490
Edited by Catch22 on Sep 24, 2010 10:31:48
 
3kk0
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
Not sure I agree. Most of those are just a slow ass OL player (<20 speed) getting beat. Go ahead and get verification and let the QA guys decide though.

This play for example is most definitely not a bug:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1388928&pbp_id=2605385

Either is this one:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1388928&pbp_id=2605490


But for that to be true, that means the LG was assigned to block the FS (Inside blocker blocks outside rusher)
and the LT was assigned to block the DE (outside blocker blocks inside rusher)

I would think this blocking assignment is incorrect

If the argument is that the LG and LT originally were to pick up the DE, but then the LG sees the blitzer, but the LT doesn't, it's still flawed logic for the LG to turn loose the DE if the LT is not in position yet to block him
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Sending to QA per Catch.
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
hmmmm i'm not sure this is a bug. The LOT is trying to pick up the block and failing miserably at it. That said....doesn't make too much sense to me that the LOT goes in and LG goes out. It's been well documented but it does not appear that pass blocking logic in this game works from the inside out (like most people think it should).
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
Not sure I agree. Most of those are just a slow ass OL player (<20 speed) getting beat. Go ahead and get verification and let the QA guys decide though.

This play for example is most definitely not a bug:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1388928&pbp_id=2605385

Either is this one:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1388928&pbp_id=2605490


are you sure that it couldn't be something with bort's new "inside-out blocking change" ?

regardless if it is a bug or not, it does look rather silly that the LOT and LG basically switch spots. i'd like to give it a verification, but i'll wait for more QAs to weigh in
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
Some of these look like the RE is just breaking the block of the LG, pushing him aside and then progressing on. However, a few of these seem pretty clear that's not what's happening:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1388928&pbp_id=2609825

The LOT is very clearly trying to pick up the RDE, while the LG is going after the outside threat.
Not only that, but if you look closely at the RG and ROT, you'll see the same thing - ROT is trying to pick up the LDE, and can't, and the LG is (slowly) walking over to the LOLB (who is also too slow to get there before the RDE does).

I'm pretty sure that's what's going on in all of these cases, which means it's happening consistently. I would prefer if we had an example from another team to rule out build issues, but I don't think any build should make this mistake every single time. I suspect the coding is seeing a 3 down line set, and the C/RG/LG make a determination on who gets the NT, which in this case is the C. Then the RG/LG decide they have "no one" inside the DEs to block, and the tackles decide they have the DEs. This is the flaw, the Gs should realize that not only is there no one inside the DEs to block, but that the DEs are lined up inside the OTs and thus the Gs should pick those up, freeing the OTs for any outside threats. The OTs can then decide to either double the DE or notice the blitzers and pick them up. Probably the OT should drop back even without noticing a blitzer until in pocket position, then double the DE if still not seeing a blitzer.

Bug, first verification.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
now that i think about it, how would the LOT know that he shouldn't block the blitzer instead of the RDE? What if, in your replay, the FS was up farther near the LBs and blitzed, and the ROLB, who blitzed, moved back into coverage instead? then, you'd have the LOT blocking the ROLB and the RG trying to slide out and block the RDE.

basically, are we asking to have our cake, and eat it too? should there be a slight bonus to speed on linemen when they spot a blitz and it is required that they move to pick it up?
 
robponce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiborRis
Some of these look like the RE is just breaking the block of the LG, pushing him aside and then progressing on. However, a few of these seem pretty clear that's not what's happening:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1388928&pbp_id=2609825

The LOT is very clearly trying to pick up the RDE, while the LG is going after the outside threat.
Not only that, but if you look closely at the RG and ROT, you'll see the same thing - ROT is trying to pick up the LDE, and can't, and the LG is (slowly) walking over to the LOLB (who is also too slow to get there before the RDE does).

I'm pretty sure that's what's going on in all of these cases, which means it's happening consistently. I would prefer if we had an example from another team to rule out build issues, but I don't think any build should make this mistake every single time. I suspect the coding is seeing a 3 down line set, and the C/RG/LG make a determination on who gets the NT, which in this case is the C. Then the RG/LG decide they have "no one" inside the DEs to block, and the tackles decide they have the DEs. This is the flaw, the Gs should realize that not only is there no one inside the DEs to block, but that the DEs are lined up inside the OTs and thus the Gs should pick those up, freeing the OTs for any outside threats. The OTs can then decide to either double the DE or notice the blitzers and pick them up. Probably the OT should drop back even without noticing a blitzer until in pocket position, then double the DE if still not seeing a blitzer.

Bug, first verification.


This is the reason I'm confirming this as well.

The RG/LG should slide out. Maybe a progression is in order for inside out blocking? Moving on with 2nd verification.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
i don't agree with your decision to move this on, rob. did you even read my post?
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RMiller517
now that i think about it, how would the LOT know that he shouldn't block the blitzer instead of the RDE? What if, in your replay, the FS was up farther near the LBs and blitzed, and the ROLB, who blitzed, moved back into coverage instead? then, you'd have the LOT blocking the ROLB and the RG trying to slide out and block the RDE.

basically, are we asking to have our cake, and eat it too? should there be a slight bonus to speed on linemen when they spot a blitz and it is required that they move to pick it up?


If the FS was closer to the line, and was blitzing, and the ROLB is not blitzing, I'd prefer to see variable behavior.

In the "everyone on the Oline spots all the blitzes" case:
The C would say "I'm on the NT".
Then the LG would see the FS is blitzing inside the RDE, and say "I'm blocking the FS"
Finally the LOT would say "I've got the RDE".
Now, the LOT in this case probably isn't built fast enough to cover that ground, but that's a build issue, not a sim logic issue, so I'm okay with it.

In the "someone on the Oline misses a blitz" case:
The LG might miss the FS is blitzing and cover the RDE, while the LT sees the FS and assumes the RDE is his own responsibility. LG/LT double the RDE, FS comes free - O-line error, not sim logic error, perfect result.

The LT might miss that the FS is blitzing and think the LG is covering the RDE. In that case the LT would step back into standard "pocket" until he realized the RDE is unblocked. He'll still likely put a block on him, but would be out of position and get a less than optimal block. Worst case the RDE might fly right by before the LT can correct his action.

The LT also might miss the FS blitz AND think the ROLB is blitzing. In that case the LT would step to the ROLB and then discover the ROLB is dropping back. The RDE would fly free as the LG has the FS and the LT is likely out of position.

All these "Oline misses a blitz" cases should occur, but not any one case every time. I think that's the problem here - the LG and LT are consistently, in my opinion, making the exact wrong choice - and a choice that should NEVER be made under the blocking scheme. That's a bug.

Since we've got some disagreement on this, though, I'll ping Catch to take a look as well.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
I'd like some examples of this behavior happening with OL with more speed - I'm still not convinced this is a bug. Is this happening at the Pro and WL level? If so, get some links so I can look at them and we'll make a determination from there.
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
This exploded on the WL scene yesterday.

The additional twist in the WL case was that they added an extra outside blitzer out wide. With the OT diving down into the line to take the DE, and the G trying like hell to get outside to hit the first outside LB blitzer, the second LB blitzer has a clean, straight line to the QB.

So Cal crushed D9 with it:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1416597

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1416597&pbp_id=4607389
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1416597&pbp_id=4607421

EDIT: These aren't bugged, they're picked up correctly. Not sure what the differences are; probably some slight positioning differences?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1416597&pbp_id=4608402
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1416597&pbp_id=4608465

If the LOT was staying on his side of the G, and blocking the RILB, then the ROLB would have a longer path to get around and it would buy the QB a few more ticks, making this more reasonable. There are more blitzers on that side than there are blockers - the C has to take the NT, and that leaves the LG and LOT to pick up the RDE, RILB, and ROLB. It should be trouble. But, if the ROLB has to go up and around the LOT/RILB interaction, it'll take longer. Also, that gives any HB/FB that may be back there time to pick up a blitz (today they just get beat).
Edited by NiborRis on Sep 30, 2010 10:03:51
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.