User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > FILED BUGS > Misleading description on surge? - BUG FILED #263
Page:
 
TheRawDog
offline
Link
 
Surge seems to indicait that it will fire every time the rb hits the line untouched. This does not seem to work that way. I could be missunderstanding when a touch occurs. The plays i've watched where it doesn't go off could be the result of a blocked nose tackle sticking a finger out.

If that is not the case and it may or may not fire than you should put 'Increase the chance of the skill working.' under additional levels like you have for first step.
Edited by NiborRis on Sep 28, 2010 08:54:57 (bug, second verification)
Edited by kuaggie on Sep 26, 2010 23:54:55
Edited by Asdlfef on Sep 26, 2010 17:51:33 (I don't think it's a bug, but 1 yes and 1 no means it goes to QA.)
Edited by VolBrian on Sep 22, 2010 20:04:45 (Fixed typo)
Edited by VolBrian on Sep 22, 2010 20:04:33 (Needs description correction)
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
This isn't a bug. SA's are not intended to fire every play. None of the other descriptions indicate that they would for the other VA's, just the part about "increased levels causing increased chances" might be confusing to some.

Not likely a bug and it's also a duplicate: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4220736

Perhaps a suggestion might be in order if the description confuses some, but I've never expected any VA to fire every play tbh.
Edited by VolBrian on Sep 21, 2010 13:57:20
 
peeti
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
This isn't a bug. SA's are not intended to fire every play. None of the other descriptions indicate that they would for the other VA's, just the part about "increased levels causing increased chances" might be confusing to some.

Not likely a bug and it's also a duplicate: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4220736

Perhaps a suggestion might be in order if the description confuses some, but I've never expected any SA to fire every play tbh.


Quick Cut for example does, tho...And I actully thought surge does fire every time he isnt touched
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Yeah, you're right. As does First Step. I should have said some or most VA's, especially on HB's.

Surge is more like Stiff Arm, Lower Shoulder, Big Hit, Monster Sack, etc as opposed to First Step, Line General, Change Direction, Return Specialist, etc.
Edited by VolBrian on Sep 22, 2010 11:58:33
 
Galkuris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Yeah, you're right. As does First Step. I should have said some or most VA's, especially on HB's.

Surge is more like Stiff Arm, Lower Shoulder, Big Hit, Monster Sack, etc as opposed to First Step, Line General, Change Direction, Return Specialist, etc.


That is not what the description says. If this is the case then it needs to have the wording changed. Right now what it says is that it fires every time he hits the hole

"The Surge skill gives the player a burst of acceleration when he hits the line of scrimmage untouched on inside runs."

It does not say may give, can give, sometimes gives...it says gives...meaning every time.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Sure, but:


Lower Shoulder: "The player puts his shoulder down and attempts to barrel through defenders. This gives him a bonus to breaking tackles."

Stiff Arm: "The player puts his off-arm out and pushes the defender away from him. This can help him avoid a tackle."

Spin is the same way, Juke is the same way. They all could be implied that they are supposed to fire every time, but we know that they are not. I could send this up, but it will just come back as a suggestion to rewrite the SA descriptions if anything.
 
Worker 3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Yeah, you're right. As does First Step. I should have said some or most VA's, especially on HB's.
.

fwiw, first step doesnt fire every play.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Sure, but:


Lower Shoulder: "The player puts his shoulder down and attempts to barrel through defenders. This gives him a bonus to breaking tackles."

Stiff Arm: "The player puts his off-arm out and pushes the defender away from him. This can help him avoid a tackle."

Spin is the same way, Juke is the same way. They all could be implied that they are supposed to fire every time, but we know that they are not. I could send this up, but it will just come back as a suggestion to rewrite the SA descriptions if anything.


No, you have to read the additional levels part.

On Stiff Arm it says additional levels increases the chance of the skill working.....
On Power Through it says additional levels increases the chance of the skill working...
On Spin it says it increases the chance of spinning successfully....

etc, etc. That is how you can tell which SAs have a chance to activate, versus being always on.

While something like Quick Cut says: The angle at which the player can cut increases, while the speed lost in making the cut increases.

So under additional levels for Surge, all it says is that it increases the acceleration boost, which would indicate that it always comes on when you go through the line untouched on inside runs.

First Step is obvious too. Under additional levels, it states that each level increases the chance of the skill working, etc.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Ok ok. I'll change it to likely. I guess I see how it could be expected to fire constantly, I've just never expected it to. I guess a description rewrite might be in order just to avoid this confusion.

Likely a bug
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
 
stud_hb
offline
Link
 
I thought Catch confirmed when Surge was added that it did fire every time you went through the line untouched. That is why I invested in it. Obviously I can't find the link now...
 
Asdlfef
offline
Link
 
I don't agree with VB here, but I will send it to QA for further determination.
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
I believe that a) it doesn't fire every time, and b) the description implies it does

first verification
 
Stray Doug
offline
Link
 
Pretty sure there was a thread where I got responses from Catch and Bort on this... I believe a Q&A thread. Addressed SAs like Surge and LTS, and whether they are "active" all the time. For example, IIRC, LTS is active all the time, but you only "see it" in the PBP when it is the difference maker between a tackle and a missed tackle.

edit: found it... http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4006348

Although, reading the response again now... it's still ambiguous. "Lower the shoulder can activate and still not break a tackle..." can be interpreted either way (activates all the time, but can do so and not break a tackle... or... "can" activate as in sometimes it does, sometimes it doesn't). The response to surge implies that it triggers every single time you reach line untouched (consistent with description)... just a question of duration. Note that whether or not the "surge" icon appears on the screen is a separate issue... my sense is that for whatever reason it doesn't show up every time the skill activates.
Edited by Stray Doug on Sep 27, 2010 08:26:33
Edited by Stray Doug on Sep 27, 2010 08:22:32
Edited by Stray Doug on Sep 27, 2010 08:22:09
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie
I believe that a) it doesn't fire every time, and b) the description implies it does

first verification


I agree. It's possible that higher levels of Surge does not actually increase the rate of fire, but if it's just a % chance to be used and doesn't increase with levels, that would be unique and the description should say so.

Probably the underlying question is more suited for a Q&A with Bort - is Surge supposed to fire every time or is it an increasing chance - but whatever the answer the SA description should be updated.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.