It's like giving a guy a steak dinner, then a few years later telling him he didn't eat it. Everyone knows he won the Heisman. Vince won't claim it if they try to give it to him. It just makes the committee look stupid. They need to go back through all of the winners and determine if they were all legit. I bet there are some skeletons in those closets.
Yeah they have never pulled a Heisman before. It is kind of lame to place all the blame on the young athlete when he is being led around by the nose from his agent and especially the boosters who are typically the ones at fault in these type of situations.
Originally posted by TKAlex Deserved to be taken away he broke rules the school shouldnt pay for his actions he should be fined or jailed for lying to committes like clemens
Yeah! Because it's not like the school was found to be guilty of habitually breaking the rules to the point that people had to resign and they lost scholarships and shit. It's all Reggie. He went and stole some money out of those people's pockets.
This is about like the situation where college kids get caught taking stuff from agents and the 22 yr old kid gets in trouble, not the full grown professional who told him this is the way it's done. This time they actually punished the people who initiated and habitually broke the rules, though.
The money and time he has donated to the New Orleans area, after Katrina, far out ways his parents taking money from an agent. Reggie is a Saint in my mind for that.
Also if you don't think your fav. college team has the same shit going on you are dumb. Its happens everywhere. Doesn't make it ok and Reggie is rightly paying for his mistake.
He was poor man. You get out in LA and start having KK get nasty on the regular and have empty testing rooms made available to you....I don't blame him at all....It does not fit the standard set by the Trust, but I don't blame RB for getting his paper.
Originally posted by BOAFMA BALZICH He was poor man. You get out in LA and start having KK get nasty on the regular and have empty testing rooms made available to you....I don't blame him at all....It does not fit the standard set by the Trust, but I don't blame RB for getting his paper.
I like to think I would take the moral high ground here. But growing up dirt poor myself, I understand the temptation and would probably make the wrong decision at that young age, especially if I was not around someone who I could turn to for advice.RB's parents let him down, the university him down, his coach let him down.
Originally posted by Tomhusker It's like giving a guy a steak dinner, then a few years later telling him he didn't eat it. [Nah, more like Olympic gold medalists that win gold but have to give it up because their paper work wasn't legal. They're still the best, just not "technically the best." Steak dinner = Heisman - not!
Everyone knows he won the Heisman. [Yes, but winning it and deserving it because you met their criteria are two different things.]
Vince won't claim it if they try to give it to him. [True, but he is then next best "eligible" player, if he didn't do the same thing.]
It just makes the committee look stupid. They need to go back through all of the winners and determine if they were all legit. I bet there are some skeletons in those closets. [Also true and I agree, they should if they want to keep the Heisman prestige and honor that goes with it.]
Bush = overpaid, over rated and injury prone. Does not live up to his draft status. I'm sure he knew he was breaking the rules by accepting the money at the time. It's instilled in them at freshman orientation about how they can lose their scholarships. Premeditation should weigh into it. I understand the temptation for his situation, but judges don't give criminals get out of jail free cards because "all that money in the vault was just too irresistible." (They save those passes for white collar CEO crimes.)
I do give him a little credit for surrendering the trophy though...but not much. He had to get busted before he did. And now, it doesn't mean that much to him because he's used it to get where he needs to be. If this had come out before the draft, would he have any of endorsements he has now or the contract? I think he would be tainted like his trophy.