User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Player's energy gets lower while he's standing waiting on the ball - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1348694&pbp_id=12521773

When the ball hits the 35 yard line my KR appears on the screen. His energy is at 94, so he lost 6 energy thus far preparing to catch the ball. However, he's not moving now, and if you advance the frames to immediately before he catches the ball, it's down to 92, and he still hasn't moved.

I went looking for other examples, but most I could find had the KR moving still to get under the ball. Here's one where a similar thing occurred on a punt:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1348694&pbp_id=12523468

Is this normal, that players simply standing on the field lose energy?
Edited by blaslo on Aug 31, 2010 12:49:58 (reasoning in thread)
Edited by VolBrian on Aug 30, 2010 19:21:14 (Reason in thread)
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
This happens to all returners, so it is normal by that definition. It is most noticeable on Kickoffs, since the returner rarely moves to get under the ball. As to whether it SHOULD happen, I would say no, but that's just my opinion.
Edited by Plankton on Aug 30, 2010 15:22:28
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
This should really be changed.
 
minjit
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82
This should really be changed.


 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
The energy hits to a player during a play is by design. The amount prior to a return or during the catch could vary based off stamina, etc, but they are intended so not likely a bug.

Whether or not that should be changed is for the Suggestions forum or maybe the Game Changes Discussion.
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Yeah, should have known, Reality != GLB. Always forget that

FWIW, on the punt, I counted 12 ticks from the time he went to 73 to 72. So he loses 1 energy for every 12 ticks when he's standing still. Moving forward to when he starts accelerating, he loses 1 energy (70 to 69) in 8 ticks while accelerating.


BTW, how would I present this as a suggestion? Should I cite how in reality you don't get tired simply standing (I guess unless you weigh 900 pounds)? Or something else?


Here's his build as well:

Pit (Lv. 37 CB)
Ht/Wt: 5'10", 180lbs

Attributes
Physical Attributes
Strength: 29.98
Speed: 113.29 (+29)
Agility: 78.29
Jumping: 22.26
Stamina: 30.29
Vision: 39.29
Confidence: 28.98

Football Skills
Blocking: 8
Catching: 15.28
Tackling: 12
Throwing: 8
Carrying: 61.01
Kicking: 8
Punting: 8

Special Abilities
Shutdown Corner Abilities
Swat Ball: 0
Sticky Hands: 0
Superior Vision: 0
Smooth Operator: 0
Shutdown Coverage: 0

Speedster Abilities
First Step: 0
Change Direction: 0
Return Specialist: 3
Blitz: 0
Closing Speed: 0

Additional Abilities
Spin: 0
Veteran Abilities
Return Man: 5
Special Teamer: 10


So with STer he's got 33 stamina - not much when it comes to returning kicks.
Edited by TheGreatPuma on Aug 30, 2010 19:40:14
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma

BTW, how would I present this as a suggestion? Should I cite how in reality you don't get tired simply standing (I guess unless you weigh 900 pounds)? Or something else?


I made a suggestion to do an energy overhaul that included this change, but it did what most suggestions do....died a slow quiet death. If you make a new one, I will probably add another energy revision or two that I have found.
Edited by Plankton on Aug 30, 2010 19:46:46
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Remember also that the replay is a visual approximation of things. And what I mean by that is are you certain that your dot is standing completely still and not doing a thing to lose any energy? You think he may be drifting just a step or two try to judge the ball's flight and the replay can't reflect a step in one direction or another? Do you think the energy hit might be from trying to concentrate on catching the ball and seeing the coverage team flying at you at the same time?

The adrenaline rush from even fair catching a punt with 10 guys flying at you is worth a tick of energy imo.

So, if you want to present it as a suggestion, you might go and say something as simple as returners shouldn't lose any energy until they start moving with the ball, but that's not all that realistic also imo.
Edited by VolBrian on Aug 30, 2010 19:47:19
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
A tick of energy, sure. In this case, my returner took 8 points of energy before he even caught the ball.

Right now, standing still is about 50% the energy hit that the Returner takes while accelerating after the catch. Honestly, even if he is stepping around to judge the ball, taking a few steps here or there shouldn't have 50% the hit that accelerating from a stop causes. Unless of course you want to argue the reverse and perhaps the acceleration energy hit should be worse.

 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
I see your point. Part of the problem in this case also is we can't necessarily see where he is originally lined up when the ball is kicked. Is he on the goal line and moves up 15 yards? Is he in the right spot from start to finish?

I do think that some energy should be used prior to catch and go and that's the way it's designed and working so no bug there, but how much is entirely up for debate I suppose.
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
I never thought this was a bug. However, it seemed silly to post something so ridiculously obviously a problem in suggestions. I guess what I'd like to know is your opinion that standing maybe taking a step or two here or there should be 50% of the energy hit that attempting to accelerate to full speed is? Irrespective of the bug status?

Honestly, there needs to be some sort of middle ground provided for things like this that - perhaps not really bugs in the strict way this game defines them - are so ass-backwards that they require something other than a suggestion. Honestly, I shouldn't have to make a suggestion that energy consumption should be nil while your player is standing still. It's simply common sense.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
I guess what I'd like to know is your opinion that standing maybe taking a step or two here or there should be 50% of the energy hit that attempting to accelerate to full speed is?


Presuming that he didn't move at all prior to coming into the screen for the catch? In other words, he was standing in the same spot-ish the entire play from kick to catch? With that presumption, than no, I don't think they should use up that much energy by any means. A couple 2-3 points maybe depending on their stamina level, but not half the acceleration amount. We don't know what's happening off screen though. In my game today, my KR caught one at the backline of the endzone for a touchback. I didn't think to check his energy, but I'm sure he used some getting back there to make that catch.

Originally posted by TheGreatPuma

Honestly, there needs to be some sort of middle ground provided for things like this that - perhaps not really bugs in the strict way this game defines them - are so ass-backwards that they require something other than a suggestion.


Probably, but I wouldn't want to mod that.

My job here is simply determining with the help of my team what is likely or not a bug and moving it along in the system. Logical changes that aren't bugs but needed according to some users are in a gray area I would prefer not to touch tbh.
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
another one of the classic working as intended, but not working intelligently situations things like this are always told to make a suggestion...where they go to die since no one seems to read it anymore.
 
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Probably, but I wouldn't want to mod that.

My job here is simply determining with the help of my team what is likely or not a bug and moving it along in the system. Logical changes that aren't bugs but needed according to some users are in a gray area I would prefer not to touch tbh.


odd... bugs in most worlds of development are defined exactly as the following:

A bug is the common term used to describe an error, flaw, mistake, failure, or fault in a computer program or system that produces an incorrect or unexpected or illogical result.

This is not a gray area here at all.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by toobad4u_00
odd... bugs in most worlds of development are defined exactly as the following:

A bug is the common term used to describe an error, flaw, mistake, failure, or fault in a computer program or system that produces an incorrect or unexpected or illogical result.

This is not a gray area here at all.


Not here, in Bugs. But in a system where people can suggest things that they think are illogical results, but others may not, like this very case in point, it's a very gray area.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.