User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Offical Thread for Promotion System Changes (Enforcing Level Caps Etc)
Page:
 
Link
 
As we all know, level caps need to be enforced because it's getting ridiculous.

The Suggestions:

I know I'm not the only one who is frustrated by this, so let's see this get lots of support and hopefully get fixed. I'm also willing to edit in any additional points anyone may have, so feel free to add!!

Originally posted by Chysil
the root of the problem is that you promote a certain level of caps irregardless of what your player's levels are. If you are in a 14 cap league, and you are all level 14 at the start, if you don't make the playoffs you are promoted 1 cap (level 18), even though if you boost, all your players will be level 22. That's just crazy to me.

We have elite, competitive and regular leagues now. Why are we still promoting a # of caps based on how well you did?

Why not simply have a team promote into the lowest cap that they fit into. If your highest level player is level 30 than you go to a 32 cap league etc. You still have day 41 to cut people off your roster if you have a few guys that are higher level and would pull you into another cap.

then based on where you finished last season (conf champs vs playoff teams vs bottom of the barrel etc etc) you are placed in whichever league style fits your team (elite, competitive or regular)

it doesn't seem that hard to me...


Originally posted by MarBro456
I had a suggestion that was totaly different than, "Someone is cheating... enforce the rules.....................but it was locked due to this one being endorsed. But..... here was mine:

The current system allows for some leagues to have teams that can be 10+ levels higher than other teams in the league. While some think it is intentional, it isn't always. Some teams have no care about winning in the lower leagues and don't game plan, they just concentrate on building their dots, having losing seasons, and promoting once or not at all. After a few seasons, it leads to a big disadvantage and even not gameplanning they are still too powerful to beat.

System I propose:

Each season when teams move up, put them in the league where their levels fit. Let the promotion be where they go from there, depending on how they did the previous season....... ie...... regular, competitive, or elite..... top playoff teams go to elite, next tier (lower playoff teams and the ones just missing), go to competitive, the teams that do really bad, go to regular.......

From that point, all teams still start where they can be competitive...... Gameplanning, boosting etc. can determine how their season plays out. Also by the point when the teams want to get serious, they'll be at a level where they can truly test their mettle against others.



Originally posted by Mightyhalo
If they could keep teams created around the same time together longer it sure would help. That way teams that are trying to game the caps by avoiding promotions, or teams that just don't try the first couple of seasons won't find themselves in such favorable position after 2 throwaway seasons.

Take 2 teams for example. Both teams start as level 4 teams in a level 4 cap. One team game plans and tries to win, while the other team either doesn't try at all because they are a farm team, or because they are going to game the caps.

The team that tries and makes the playoffs 2 seasons in a row moves from a level 4 cap to a 26 cap after 2 seasons with level 22ish players.

The game capping team that goes out of their way to avoid playoffs misses the playoffs 2 seasons in a row moves from a level 4 cap to an 18 cap with level 22ish players.

Team 1 that is trying ends up playing the majority of their games against older players with a level advantage throughout most of their career.

Team 2 that game caps for 2 seasons gets to play with a level advantage throughout most of their career.

if teams were placed factoring in ave create date and assigning a season number for each team it get rid of some of this BS we are facing with the current promotion system that rewards tanking for a couple of seasons.
Edited by Dustin. on Sep 28, 2010 19:01:20
Edited by Dustin. on Sep 16, 2010 21:14:16
Edited by Dustin. on Sep 12, 2010 13:41:18
Edited by Dustin69 on Aug 19, 2010 23:08:08
Edited by Dustin69 on Jul 25, 2010 21:55:50
 
Myd
offline
Link
 
I doubt we'll see change but you're right.

+1
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
we really need an official changes to promotion systems thread...

so I think I'll make this one it

edit: I would add to the OP, that with the 3 tiers of leagues at each cap, we really don't need to only promote poorly performing teams 1 cap level anymore. Stick them in the regular leagues and they should compete just fine.
Just like we don't need to be promoting people a cap ahead of where they should be. Like a level 30 cap team makes the playoffs, but has all players level 34 or under, they should promote to level 42 cap only if they ask to be, otherwise they should be placed in the 34 cap etc. This mainly happens when you make the playoffs back to back to back, and then end up in an elite league, outleveled.

having the loophole that allows teams to exploit the level caps is what made this problem, and there is no need for the loophole now that we have tiered leagues. Let's remove it, and cut the problem off at the root.
Edited by Chysil on Jul 25, 2010 17:21:51
 
Clarka3
offline
Link
 
i agree completely. make the level caps hard caps. if the team fails enough to stay behind, fine- but make them cut all players over the level cap.

As a manager of a team that I inquired about sticking back into cap 22 for this season (since all but one of our players were level 22, and the 1 player was level 23 by about 100 XP). We were told we could do so but we had to cut the level 23 player. Which sounds fine, but then you see teams that exploit the system and end up with more than one guy way over the cap level and it's just not fun, nor fair that we'd have to cut that guy to stay behind while exploiters get away with it.


make the damn caps hard and be done with it..
 
MarBro456
Diamond Cutter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chysil
we really need an official changes to promotion systems thread...

so I think I'll make this one it

edit: I would add to the OP, that with the 3 tiers of leagues at each cap, we really don't need to only promote poorly performing teams 1 cap level anymore. Stick them in the regular leagues and they should compete just fine.
Just like we don't need to be promoting people a cap ahead of where they should be. Like a level 30 cap team makes the playoffs, but has all players level 34 or under, they should promote to level 42 cap only if they ask to be, otherwise they should be placed in the 34 cap etc. This mainly happens when you make the playoffs back to back to back, and then end up in an elite league, outleveled.

having the loophole that allows teams to exploit the level caps is what made this problem, and there is no need for the loophole now that we have tiered leagues. Let's remove it, and cut the problem off at the root.


I like this Chysil. I think all teams should promote to the level league that they fit in......... The promotion so to say should be whether you go to regular, competitive, or elite. Let the season's performance determine which of these types you promote to when you go to the appropriate level.

 
timmahhh
offline
Link
 
lets make a list of all the teams who are above their cap, and the person that started this can edit their first post and keep a list of them way to stick it to the man lol.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=4185
lvl 24 in 18

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=4315
lvl 25 now, but havnt boosted. they were 25 at end of last season. also a couple of 26's in there
 
Link
 
Thanks for the support guys.
Also added in the other teams
 
JHIK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Clarka3
i agree completely. make the level caps hard caps. if the team fails enough to stay behind, fine- but make them cut all players over the level cap.

As a manager of a team that I inquired about sticking back into cap 22 for this season (since all but one of our players were level 22, and the 1 player was level 23 by about 100 XP). We were told we could do so but we had to cut the level 23 player. Which sounds fine, but then you see teams that exploit the system and end up with more than one guy way over the cap level and it's just not fun, nor fair that we'd have to cut that guy to stay behind while exploiters get away with it.


make the damn caps hard and be done with it..


that would be my solution as well, this team, http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1036 Cap 30
fits the mold, but I think only having 3-4 players over the value of the cap can make a difference depending on where they are positioned.
 
Link
 
Bump
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Even better, use effective levels.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Even better, use effective levels.


I don't think this should be implemented.
 
Battleking69
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dustin69
I don't think this should be implemented.


agree. I just feel the whole league should work like pee wee. If you're not lv 1 on day 1 you cant play. Same goes for lv 22cap, if your not lv22 on day 1 you cant play. I know pee wee doesnt work that way, but you know what i mean
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dr. E
Below are two rules in minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.


1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.

 
azrolator
offline
Link
 
It really sucks to play with a lot of the same guys for 2 seasons straight, and bond, to have to ditch them cause they aren't even high enough level to resign when you make the playoffs two seasons in a row and end up outmatched b 9-12 levels in a competitive league to boot. I would love to see this fixed. The promotion rules now are just giving teams a good reason to throw all their games for 2 seasons which makes it easy for first time owners/co-ords to hit the playoffs twice, putting them in a rotten position.
 
Brewster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chysil
Originally posted by Dr. E

Below are two rules in minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.


1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.



+ 1
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.