User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Moretti
offline
Link
 
How bad does your team suck that with an average player level of 25 you are in a cap 18 league?

You weren't even good enough for a cap 22 league? That's pathetic.

Just curious, did you try to do anything to get moved into a level appropriate league? Or do you have no problems with exploiting the system becuase that's just how it worked out?
 
Seric
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4167080&page=1

Perhaps you should have gone through this thread instead of making a thread about something that is already well discussed.
 
Moretti
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Seric
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4167080&page=1

Perhaps you should have gone through this thread instead of making a thread about something that is already well discussed.


I don't agree with ya on that one. I think this topic is worthy of its own thread. That thread was intended for something else.

This is a call out thread for douchebaggery.
 
Steelernutt68
offline
Link
 
to me its a slap in the face to have a BS loop hole to where a team can blow off a season just to be way outleveling everyone else. a team should have to start the season out just like everyone else under the cap. i agree it needs its own thread, its a demotivator in my opinion to see bort and catch allowing this type of stuff. they should have thier own league where teams outlevel people but have thrown seasons to get demoted league.
 
Moretti
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Steelernutt68
to me its a slap in the face to have a BS loop hole to where a team can blow off a season just to be way outleveling everyone else. a team should have to start the season out just like everyone else under the cap. i agree it needs its own thread, its a demotivator in my opinion to see bort and catch allowing this type of stuff. they should have thier own league where teams out level people but have thrown seasons to get demoted league.


its even more blatant in casual leagues because the game planning is restricted to the basic tactics. Basically its just the best built players will win and i doubt it would matter much if their builds were shitty when they out level the median by 10 and some teams by 14.

At level 25 these players have 4 sets of Equipment upgrades and VAs compared to my team that currently has only two EQ upgrades and no shot at VAs this season.

Last season there was a team that was full of level 22 players in a cap 18 league. Same outrage happened. The owner of that team came and said the typical its not his fault bla bla bla. Guess who won that season? And they were level 22, not 25.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4029619



 
Seric
offline
Link
 
So basically you're assuming they did it to game the system. That's the exact problem with the majority or people. They assume things with no true proof but their own opinions. If they gamed the system, it would easily be proven.

I have been in this exact situation but it was in a cap 26 with lvl 30-31 players. We missed the playoffs by a single game, so instead of moving up 2 like we wanted to by making the playoffs, we moved up 1. The same thing happened to me the season before but it was more like 2 games but that time I sent a request to support to have them move me to a cap 22 instead of a cap 18.

Shit happens and not everyone is involved in that does it on purpose. Oh yeah, we lost the league finals last season.
 
Moretti
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Seric
So basically you're assuming they did it to game the system. That's the exact problem with the majority or people. They assume things with no true proof but their own opinions. If they gamed the system, it would easily be proven.

I have been in this exact situation but it was in a cap 26 with lvl 30-31 players. We missed the playoffs by a single game, so instead of moving up 2 like we wanted to by making the playoffs, we moved up 1. The same thing happened to me the season before but it was more like 2 games but that time I sent a request to support to have them move me to a cap 22 instead of a cap 18.

Shit happens and not everyone is involved in that does it on purpose. Oh yeah, we lost the league finals last season.


If your talking to me, then no . If you look over their games from last season they were all pretty competitive. No blow outs. In fact the majority of teams they played are all in at least cap level 22 leagues. Even many teams that they beat soundly. A few of their losses were very close. In fact they didn't even have a loosing record last season.

Of the few teams that I noticed they beat that are also in cap level 18 leagues, their players are all around level 17 and 18.

The issue here is that regardless of whether or not this team barely misses the playoffs last season, they are already way past the 18 cap level. At a minimum they should be in a cap 22 league with people complaining their that they should be in a cap 25.

And the problem is that teams that get put in these situations do nothing about it. Its cowardly. Their are cpu teams in higher level leagues that they could have requested to switch with. Ive seen it before, and Ive been part of teams that have done it in the past.

Instead Seric, this complete lack of fair play will now occur, that as Steelernutt68 put it, is a slap in the face.


So I pose my question again. Was anything done to try to move this team up to an appropriate level? Or does that team not give a shit becuase they want to win a cheap trophy?
 
Seric
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Moretti
Originally posted by Seric

So basically you're assuming they did it to game the system. That's the exact problem with the majority or people. They assume things with no true proof but their own opinions. If they gamed the system, it would easily be proven.

I have been in this exact situation but it was in a cap 26 with lvl 30-31 players. We missed the playoffs by a single game, so instead of moving up 2 like we wanted to by making the playoffs, we moved up 1. The same thing happened to me the season before but it was more like 2 games but that time I sent a request to support to have them move me to a cap 22 instead of a cap 18.

Shit happens and not everyone is involved in that does it on purpose. Oh yeah, we lost the league finals last season.


If your talking to me, then no . If you look over their games from last season they were all pretty competitive. No blow outs. In fact the majority of teams they played are all in at least cap level 22 leagues. Even many teams that they beat soundly. A few of their losses were very close. In fact they didn't even have a loosing record last season.

Of the few teams that I noticed they beat that are also in cap level 18 leagues, their players are all around level 17 and 18.

The issue here is that regardless of whether or not this team barely misses the playoffs last season, they are already way past the 18 cap level. At a minimum they should be in a cap 22 league with people complaining their that they should be in a cap 25.

And the problem is that teams that get put in these situations do nothing about it. Its cowardly. Their are cpu teams in higher level leagues that they could have requested to switch with. Ive seen it before, and Ive been part of teams that have done it in the past.

Instead Seric, this complete lack of fair play will now occur, that as Steelernutt68 put it, is a slap in the face.


So I pose my question again. Was anything done to try to move this team up to an appropriate level? Or does that team not give a shit becuase they want to win a cheap trophy?


Yet again a lot of assumptions. Where is your evidence that they did this purposely? If they did it purposely, it's a different story. Funny thing is they are not even in our conference. So what, so they win gold in a cap 18 league. Anyone who truly looks into it will see how they won it and call them out on it.

Frankly there has yet to be a single season go by where there was ever a league that was fair. After 17 seasons, it's something you should expect. I do but the difference between you and me, is I don't care about things that are out of my control and don't make a huge deal about it. Why? Simply because bitching and moaning now fixes nothing and changes nothing.

 
Moretti
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Seric
Yet again a lot of assumptions. Where is your evidence that they did this purposely? If they did it purposely, it's a different story. Funny thing is they are not even in our conference. So what, so they win gold in a cap 18 league. Anyone who truly looks into it will see how they won it and call them out on it.

Frankly there has yet to be a single season go by where there was ever a league that was fair. After 17 seasons, it's something you should expect. I do but the difference between you and me, is I don't care about things that are out of my control and don't make a huge deal about it. Why? Simply because bitching and moaning now fixes nothing and changes nothing.



You seem to be arguing a point that Im not debating as well as stating presumed assumptions that to which i have not made.

Lets go over the facts of the case.

1-We are in a league that restricts the signing of players over level 18. This should result in the highest level teams being 18 to start the season (with three possible boosts as well)

2-One teams roster currently yields a majority of players who are level 25. This is unknown to whether these players are 25 with three remaining boosts left, or have utilized their 3 boosts already. An educated guess would be that the level 25 players have already utilized their boots during preseason.

3-Teams within casual leagues that are inferior levels on average have a much more difficult time competing with higher leveled teams due to the lack of advanced tactics which could per say even the playing field with superior game planning and tactics.

4-The Median Level of teams within this league is approximately 15 representing a 10 level or 40% difference between TSS and the median level.

Now I dont believe their is any debate as to whether or not TSS belongs in this league. Its clear that by the level disparity that they should at least be within a level 22 league.

Seric your comment about their never being a league that was fair is sad and needs to be fixed. After 17 seasons its not something you should expect, its something that should be fixed. Nothing personal to you, but your comments about basically not caring about it becuase your afraid to stand up for something is weak. Where would the world be without people like Gandhi, Nelson Mandela, or Martin Luther King Jr? Obviously this is just a silly game and I am in no way comparing this argument to the great things they did but the premise is still the same.


The problem here is that the system they have setup is flawed. Just becuase a team misses out on a playoff spot doesn't mean that they should stick around the next season and have little competition.

So where does that leave us? Well admins dont want to help becuase they think that they are only minor issues and are abiding by the flawed rules. Unfortunately you can most likely consider this season a wash as this one would be an odds makers dream.

One thing that does work is that if the owner of the team has any respective for himself/herself as well as for other owners and players within the league they can request to be moved up to appropriate level.

Unfortunately that doesn't seem to happen. Since the owner of TSS hasn't responded i have no way to know for sure whether he tried to get his team moved to an appropriate level.

Seric you might be satisfied with this bullshit,but Im not..
 
Steelernutt68
offline
Link
 
Sugar Kapaa
said on another post that he didnt know why he stayed down at an 18 cap on another thread. he said his team tactics were set on autopilot. his team went 8-8 on autopilot and had a whole bunch of games that were very close. all that in an 18 capped league. it is complete BS that they stayed down. not mad at them, more mad at whoever allowed it to happen. i know, if i have a problem tell support. well i already did and nothings gonna happen. but, on that note nothing ever will if everyone stays quiet about it. if you guys have a problem message support and have them pass the word to catch and bort. i did already acouple times.
 
Seric
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Moretti
Originally posted by Seric

Yet again a lot of assumptions. Where is your evidence that they did this purposely? If they did it purposely, it's a different story. Funny thing is they are not even in our conference. So what, so they win gold in a cap 18 league. Anyone who truly looks into it will see how they won it and call them out on it.

Frankly there has yet to be a single season go by where there was ever a league that was fair. After 17 seasons, it's something you should expect. I do but the difference between you and me, is I don't care about things that are out of my control and don't make a huge deal about it. Why? Simply because bitching and moaning now fixes nothing and changes nothing.



You seem to be arguing a point that Im not debating as well as stating presumed assumptions that to which i have not made.

Lets go over the facts of the case.

1-We are in a league that restricts the signing of players over level 18. This should result in the highest level teams being 18 to start the season (with three possible boosts as well)

The key words in this statement is signing of players. They didn't sign these players, they were already on the team. Clearly stated in the FAQ for Team Promotion/Demotion.

Originally posted by http://goallineblitz.com/demotion_faq.html

There are players over the level cap on a team in my league. Is this allowed?

Yes. The level cap is simply a signing cap. Players already on the team are not penalized. Teams who are naturally promoted through the above outlined promotion system will not be forced to remove any players.


2-One teams roster currently yields a majority of players who are level 25. This is unknown to whether these players are 25 with three remaining boosts left, or have utilized their 3 boosts already. An educated guess would be that the level 25 players have already utilized their boots during preseason.

Yeah they probably used their boosts already as most teams do this in order to take advantage of VAs. Which does give them an advantage beyond levels alone. But crying about it in the forums isn't going to fix anything. Every season there are threads about this. Every season nothing is done. So why continue to post these threads if they haven't done anything in the past? You think your thread is special and going to actually do anything?

3-Teams within casual leagues that are inferior levels on average have a much more difficult time competing with higher leveled teams due to the lack of advanced tactics which could per say even the playing field with superior game planning and tactics.

Can't really argue this one as it's the truth

4-The Median Level of teams within this league is approximately 15 representing a 10 level or 40% difference between TSS and the median level.

Goes back to my response to your second point

Now I dont believe their is any debate as to whether or not TSS belongs in this league. Its clear that by the level disparity that they should at least be within a level 22 league.

Yes I agree they should be in a cap 22 at least, but keep in mind only so many teams can get into a cap 22 league. May boil down to they didn't make the cut. As I said earlier, I sent a request in 2 seasons back to be moved into a cap 22 league and got approved but that doesn't mean everyone does.

Seric your comment about their never being a league that was fair is sad and needs to be fixed. After 17 seasons its not something you should expect, its something that should be fixed. Nothing personal to you, but your comments about basically not caring about it becuase your afraid to stand up for something is weak. Where would the world be without people like Gandhi, Nelson Mandela, or Martin Luther King Jr? Obviously this is just a silly game and I am in no way comparing this argument to the great things they did but the premise is still the same.

If you're not comparing it to them, why bring it up? They fought for something that actually effected lives of thousands of REAL people. You're fighting for something that effects a bunch of computer simulated dots. I'm not afraid to stand up for anything, hence my comments to you. If I was afraid to stand up for things, do you think I would have a Purple Heart? Next time you may want to pick your words better. There is a difference between crying in the forums and doing something properly. Steelernutt68 said it perfectly, send messages to support. Or sit down and think of a logical way of improving it and posting it in the Suggestions forum. Believe me, if it's logical and makes sense, you will get plenty of support.

The problem here is that the system they have setup is flawed. Just becuase a team misses out on a playoff spot doesn't mean that they should stick around the next season and have little competition.

They didn't stick around, they moved up from a Cap 14 league.

So where does that leave us? Well admins dont want to help becuase they think that they are only minor issues and are abiding by the flawed rules. Unfortunately you can most likely consider this season a wash as this one would be an odds makers dream.

The issues isn't that they don't want to help. The issue is everyone wants to cry and whine but no one wants to come up with a good way of fixing it. As I said earlier, stop crying and come up with a way of fixing it. Create a Private Forum dedicated to it and I am sure you'll get plenty of people willing to help you.

One thing that does work is that if the owner of the team has any respective for himself/herself as well as for other owners and players within the league they can request to be moved up to appropriate level.

Who are you to act like they need to respect you and respond to you? You think you're something special? You think anyone else in here is something special? Ever think of sending the owner a message and talking to him? Probably not. It's amazing what happens if you actually take the time to actually speak to someone. But no you want to come in here and cry like it's actually going to fix anything.

Unfortunately that doesn't seem to happen. Since the owner of TSS hasn't responded i have no way to know for sure whether he tried to get his team moved to an appropriate level.

No way for sure? Why because you want him to respond in here instead just sending him a message and talking to him there?

Seric you might be satisfied with this bullshit,but Im not..


My responses are in bold.
 
Steelernutt68
offline
Link
 
i thought it was only the 11th and 12th place teams that got demoted and everyone else got bumped atleast 1 cap level? last season they were 8-8 and in a 18 capped league. they should of atleast got bumped 1 cap level and that would be 22 cap. if they went 1-15 or up to 3-13 then it would be somewhat understandable. but 8-8 isnt even a losing record and that is just wrong.
i understand that they werent technically demoted, but its pretty much the same thing.
 
Steelernutt68
offline
Link
 
What is Promotion and Demotion?
At the end of every season, teams from every league can move up or down in levels, in order to find more suitable competition.


Pro/AAA/AA Leagues
How does promotion and demotion work in the Pro, AAA, and AA leagues?
The two teams reaching the championship game will always be promoted to the next tier up. The two teams who finished 15th and 16th in each conference will be demoted to a lower league.
What about teams that have been sold or requested demotion in Pro/AAA/AA? Will they be replaced by lower tier teams moving up?
Yes, all CPU teams will be removed from the league and replaced by teams moving up from lower tiers.


Minor Leagues
How does promotion and demotion work in the Minor Leagues?
The minor leagues are set up in a level capped system, which is designed to grow with the normal level progression of players. There is no forced demotion in the minor leagues.

- All teams who make the playoffs are promoted up by 2 level caps.
- The two teams who made the championship game may request to move up 3 level caps by selecting the option via their team's "edit profile" page.
- The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
- The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap
.
There are players over the level cap on a team in my league. Is this allowed?
Yes. The level cap is simply a signing cap. Players already on the team are not penalized. Teams who are naturally promoted through the above outlined promotion system will not be forced to remove any players.
I don't think I can manage if I move up two tiers. Can I request only a single tier promotion or to remain at the same tier?
Possibly, if your entire roster's levels are under the next level cap. The general rules are as follows:

- If you finished 12-4 or better or made it to the 3rd round of the playoffs, you are going to move up two levels. This preempts all the below. it does not matter if you have all your players below the cap, you are not eligible for an exception.
- If you made the playoffs and did not make it past the 2nd round and were 11-5 or worse, you can request to move up one level if all of your players are below the cap.
- If you didn't make the playoffs and everyone is below the cap, you can remain at the same level. However, choosing to do this will result in having your team's cash and stadium reset to the tier you are staying at, unless you are a 15th/16th place team.
- Some exceptions will be made - for example if you only made the playoffs because 8 teams in your league were CPU (this means CPU not lower level owned human teams), then we will evaluate that and you could possibly remain at the same level if all of your players are below the cap.
- Requests for single tier promotion may still be denied if we deem your team to be unsuited to the tier you are requesting based on effective level.
How do I request a demotion?
After day 32 of each season, an option to request demotion will become available to the team owner on the team's profile page. Owners should use this form to request demotion, instead of requesting it via Support.
What is required to request a demotion?
Your team roster must have players who all fit under the level you are requesting. For instance, if you want to demote to level cap 18, all players on the team must be at or under level 18. Keep in mind that you cannot boost past your level cap during the offseason, so riding the level cap line on your demotion may make you miss out on some boosts!
If I request demotion for my team, do I lose anything?
Yes. All teams who request demotion will have their stadium, team cash, and fan support reset based on the tier they are demoting to. The starting stadium and cash values are listed below:

- AA - Fan Support 40/20/10, no stadium/cash reset

- Lv 46 - Stadium: All 100 Level, Both 200 sidelines; Cash: 16,000,000; Fan Support: 30/10/0

- Lv 42 - Stadium: All 100 Level, Both 200 sidelines; Cash: 14,000,000; Fan Support: 30/10/0

- Lv 38 - Stadium: All 100 Level, Both 200 sidelines; Cash: 12,000,000; Fan Support: 30/10/0

- Lv 34 - Stadium: All 100 Level, Both 200 sidelines; Cash: 10,000,000; Fan Support: 30/10/0

- Lv 30 - Stadium: All 100 Level, 200 level home sideline; Cash: 8,000,000; Fan Support: 30/10/0

- Lv 26 - Stadium: All 100 Level except right endzone; Cash: 6,000,000; Fan Support: 30/10/0

- Lv 22 - Stadium: Three 100 level corners; Cash: 4,000,000; Fan Support: 30/10/0

- Lv 18 - Stadium: One 100 level corner; Cash: 2,000,000; Fan Support: 30/10/0

- Lv 14 - Stadium: No Additional Sections; Cash: 1,500,000; Fan Support: 30/10/0

- Lv 4 - Stadium: No Additional Sections; Cash: 1,500,000; Fan Support: 30/10/0


Does "requesting demotion" include requesting to stay at the same level cap tier?
Yes, unless you were a non-playoff team fitting under the rules listed above.
Do I lose anything if I only go up one tier, instead of 2?
No. As long as you are moving up, you do not lose anything.
I don't want to lose my stadium and money. What's to stop me or anyone else from hanging out in higher tier leagues?
Failing to field a competitive team for too long will end up costing a team in cash, fan support, and stadium sections:

- Media revenue at higher tiers is not awarded to uncompetitive teams.
- Fan Support can decrease below the normal minimum 30/10/0 threshold. Ticket sales at these levels will be extremely difficult. Once fan support reaches 0/0/0, no tickets will be sold.
- The stadium will lose one section per season (at the end of the season) until the stadium is at the default value for that level. The order in which sections are lost begins at the 300 level, goes to the 200 level, and then the 100 level (minus the normal 100 level sidelines) with the section that has the most seats at that level being the one that would be lost first.
- No stadium construction or expansion is allowed until the team meets league minimums.

How do I know if I meet the league minimums for a competitive team? What do I need to make sure I do?
Teams are required to field at least 30 human players and the level of those players must be at least at 30% less than the league's median player level (which is shown by the recommended levels listed on the league page). This should be easy to meet for any team that is trying, and the league minimum level requirements should guide in you in meeting that minimum. If your team misses these guidelines on game day, the owner will receive an alert. Stadium deterioration is determined by meeting these minimums for the final 3 weeks of the season.

Do the above rules apply to casual leagues as well?
Yes.

Do the above rules apply to pee wee leagues?
No.
 
Steelernutt68
offline
Link
 
reason i cut and pasted that is cause they were 8-8 and at 8-8 they shouldnt of been 1 of the 2 last place teams in which they should of been bumped to atleast a cap 22 league.
i might be wrong and maybe they were last place at 8-8 i just cant seem to find that info.
does anyone know what place they finished in last season?
 
TStone
offline
Link
 
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.