User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > Incorrect Scouting Results - RESOLVED BUG #202
Sciz
offline
Link
 
I'm scouting for my team's championship game coming up. While scouting, I noticed one play that gave my opponents a 27 yard loss the one time it was called. I checked this out, and here is the only Pro Set pass in the 3rd quarter on first down. It is not a 27 yard loss.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1254697&pbp_id=9633842
http://i30.tinypic.com/wmcwm9.jpg
Edited by Lensar on Dec 7, 2010 11:50:43
Edited by Lensar on Jul 12, 2010 16:36:38
Edited by MC_Hammer on Jul 10, 2010 18:13:40 (agree with Nibor's and robponce's assessment.)
Edited by robponce on Jul 10, 2010 14:56:06 (First Verification)
Edited by Hokiemon on Jul 10, 2010 09:06:44 (scouting issues)
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
I've also seen that happen because of interceptions.
 
Sciz
offline
Link
 
That was my original guess, but this was incomplete, so I don't know ¯\(°.o)/¯
 
Djmr
offline
Link
 
Scouting has been buggy for a long time - http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3789027

Its just something very hard to pinpoint where the bug is.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Djmr
Scouting has been buggy for a long time - http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3789027

Its just something very hard to pinpoint where the bug is.


Well, I'll go ahead and mark this likely a bug so it can get through and y'all can decide what you would like to do with it. I would close it as a duplicate if it was an active issue, but since it's archived........
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
Not to step on the CS Mod toes, but I'm going to be gone later and I have a thought on what caused this. I think there are two different code bugs here.

#1 - look at the punt play before. There is no "return 0 yds" in the pbp - this seems to happen whenever the returner misses the punt but then goes to pick it up off the ground. You can see that in the pbp occasionally and of course it's most likely to happen in Pee Wee. This causes the yardage calculation to still be in play for the next play rather than the punt play.

#2 - incompleted passes don't expressly set the yardage calc to 0 yards gained. Normally this is okay as it will just be 0 if nothing's done, but in combination with #1 you'll get stale data. If the play after the punt is a run or a completed pass, the yardage calc works fine (verified by finding examples) but not if it's an incomplete pass. It's not detected in the pbp because incomplete pass doesn't write yardage lost/gained into the pbp as it's assumed 0 yds but the scouting tool picks it up.

Note:
Punt from 47
Play is on 26.5
26.5 + 27 yds = 53.5 or the OPP 47. So within rounding to the nearest half yard the yardage adds up.
Now, I don't have a second example of this, but if people wanted to scan some Pee Wee games for a situation where you get a punt play that has neither "return X yds", "fair catch", or "downed" in the pbp, and then the following first down is an incomplete pass, we could check the scouting report and see if the scouting picks this up again.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Owww, my toes.
 
Hokiemon
offline
Link
 
Moved to QA
 
Djmr
offline
Link
 
Does it for fair catch too:
http://www.goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1208487&pbp_id=977592
http://img27.imageshack.us/img27/6162/playyardsafterfaircatch.jpg

Which leaves me wondering how much it affects
 
robponce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiborRis
Not to step on the CS Mod toes, but I'm going to be gone later and I have a thought on what caused this. I think there are two different code bugs here.

#1 - look at the punt play before. There is no "return 0 yds" in the pbp - this seems to happen whenever the returner misses the punt but then goes to pick it up off the ground. You can see that in the pbp occasionally and of course it's most likely to happen in Pee Wee. This causes the yardage calculation to still be in play for the next play rather than the punt play.

#2 - incompleted passes don't expressly set the yardage calc to 0 yards gained. Normally this is okay as it will just be 0 if nothing's done, but in combination with #1 you'll get stale data. If the play after the punt is a run or a completed pass, the yardage calc works fine (verified by finding examples) but not if it's an incomplete pass. It's not detected in the pbp because incomplete pass doesn't write yardage lost/gained into the pbp as it's assumed 0 yds but the scouting tool picks it up.

Note:
Punt from 47
Play is on 26.5
26.5 + 27 yds = 53.5 or the OPP 47. So within rounding to the nearest half yard the yardage adds up.
Now, I don't have a second example of this, but if people wanted to scan some Pee Wee games for a situation where you get a punt play that has neither "return X yds", "fair catch", or "downed" in the pbp, and then the following first down is an incomplete pass, we could check the scouting report and see if the scouting picks this up again.


Good catch Nibor. I'm going to go ahead and give this the first verification. Looks like the tool is picking up yardage from one play and then trying to make up for it on the next play by realizing where it last had the ball (where it landed on the punt) and adjusting it to where it is now (LOS after the incomplete).
 
MC_Hammer
offline
Link
 
agreed Rob, second verification.
 
Lensar
offline
Link
 

Filed as Bug 202.
 
HouseRules
offline
Link
 
Fix will be uploaded at the next data push.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.