ST's MVP is the biggest joke. You should be complaining about the formula because it sucks cawk and whether or not it is "working as intended" it is broken.
Red Thunderleg finished 5th in the ST MVP race despite being one of the worst punters in the league. The ONLY meaningful stat for a punter (at least recognized by GLB) is Avg P Yards... Red finished 21st out of 32 in this category. The only reason he makes top 5 is because he was on a shitty team that punted a lot and therefore has way more punts than most players and as a result has a lot more total Punt Yards.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/stats.pl?season=16&league_id=1&conference_id=0&stat=kicking&sort=punt_yards/punts&playoffs=0&stat_type=adjustedUnfortunately... the Bug Mods will tell you this is not a Bug (because Bort's stupid ass thinks total punt yards, and maybe total punts, is meaningful stat to distinguish a MVP punter and therefore considers the formula "working as intended"). They will then direct you to start a thread in the Suggestions forum to join the other 1000+ threads suggesting the MVP formula gets fixed.
With all that in mind... do you really care about the .gif for "winning" the ST MVP? Your player is still in the running for the MVP equipment endorsement (top 3) which is the only thing that really matters about winning an MVP.
In the end, the MVP system is broken. There are many other aspects of the game that should be fixed first... especially when they have a decent band aid on the situation (top 3 equipment endorsement lottery).