User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Sim is not grabbing my inputs in correct order - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
Grr8WhiteHype
offline
Link
 
I've been OCing and DCing a long time so I know what I am doing. I have double and triple checked both times this has happened so I know I didn't select something incorrectly.

In this most recent game I had an input for a tagged rusher when the opponent is in Pro Set. It is set to go from my goalline to their goalline, downs 1-4 and any yardage to go for the first down. Yet it didn't fire and three times they got a huge run because of it. It directly resulted in my team's loss.

Instead the sim used a tactic much further down in my tactics. All the other inputs were used in the correct order but this one didn't fire. I'm sick of it. I know what I am doing and as I said I double and triple checked. It is a mistake in the sim plain and simple (will get owner to give any mod access so they can look for themselves).

I'll be perfectly honest I am on my last string for this game. With all the changes being made but yet the passing game still be near impossible to do except at high levels or when you have a perfect team and all the mistakes like the one I experienced in this past game ... I am really close to being done wasting my time on this game. I've spent more money than i should have and I'm not seeing the return.

The sim is broke ... fix it.
Edited by Hokiemon on Jul 18, 2010 11:13:21 (if it arises with the OP again PM kuaggie)
Edited by VolBrian on Jul 13, 2010 14:18:32 (Issue waiting to be replicated by pure accident. not likely a bug)
Edited by kuaggie on Jul 6, 2010 21:08:33
Edited by VolBrian on Jun 30, 2010 19:01:41 (Sent To QA. Title shortened)
Edited by P@nda on Jun 30, 2010 03:25:14 (1st Verification - LIKELY A BUG (Tagged QB treated as untagged QB 4/5 times))
 
Grr8WhiteHype
offline
Link
 
Sorry if it comes off harsh. I'm a bit pissed off right now since it was a game we really need to win. If a mod wants to take a look I will get the owner to give you access. The team is the Le Thor Devil Bats ...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=6177
 
P@nda
Radioactive
offline
Link
 
I will take a look at the outputs in your AI, but first please link the plays in question.

Also, it is pretty much impossible to be sure that the settings that we take a look at are exactly the same as the settings that ran in the game.
 
Grr8WhiteHype
offline
Link
 
I have PMed the owner asking him to send you a GM offer.

I have looked through the whole game and have discovered more of the same problem. I didn't notice the first time because that was wrongly called did a decent job of stopping him so it didn't really hurt us.

Here is the order of my DAI inputs.

1. "4th DN Weak I Powerback"
2. "4th DN I Form Powerback"
3. "QB Pro Set" (one that should have fired that I mention int he original post)
4. "QB Singleback"
5. "QB Strong I"
6. "QB I"
7. "QB Stop 2 WR (rusher)"
8. "QB Stop 3 WR (rusher)"

No. 7 and 8 were the original plays I created many seasons ago and two seasons ago I added the more specific ones above it but kept the originals as a fall back. None of them are what fired in the 3rd quarter against pro set QB runs that cost us the game.

Each of the QB formation specific inputs are the exact same with just the formation changed. Some formations fired correctly some didn't in this game. Most games they all fire correctly and considering I haven't touched the inputs in two seasons I know I didn't mistakenly change something.


Here are the plays ...

1. Team in Strong I with QB tagged as "rusher" on the field but my custom play didn't get used but instead my custom play for "3rd/4th DN and 4+" which is all the way down at No. 45 out of 48 total inputs and set for "I (any variation)." The input at No. 5 from the top should fire instead of the input at No. 45.

2nd Qt 14:28 3rd and 14.5 yards (result 2.5 yd gain)

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1231391&pbp_id=12738314

2. Team in I Form with QB tagged as "rusher" on the field. The correct play fired this time. The situation is the exact same. It was 3rd down and more than 4 yards (same as example No. 1) and the opponent was in an I variation. Why does the No. 45 input fire one time but not the other?

2nd Qt 4:00 3rd and 6 (result 4 yd loss)

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1231391&pbp_id=12739077

3. Team in Pro Set with QB tagged as "rusher" on the field. The QB Pro Set listed in No. 3 in my DAI didn't fire. Some other custom play of mine did that I have yet to find exactly which one it was.

3rd Qt 11:39 2nd and 7.5 (result 60 yd TD)

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1231391&pbp_id=12740288

4.
Team in Pro Set with QB tagged as "rusher" on the field. The QB Pro Set listed No. 3 in my DAI didn't fire. Some other custom play did that is the same as play 3 but still need to figure out exactly which it was.

3rd Qt 3:30 2nd and 6 (result 50.5 yd TD)

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1231391&pbp_id=12742873

5. Team in Strong I with QB tagged as "rusher" on the field. The QB Strong I listed No. 5 in my DAI didn't fire. Not sure what did. Some other custom play for sure based on where the safeties are. Will find it and edit post once I figure it out.

4th Qt 7:50 2nd and 7 (result 45.5 yd gain, caught at the 4 yd line)

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1231391&pbp_id=12746076





Those are the 5 QB runs from the game with 4 not having the right play used. Like I said before I have had these plays and inputs in place for multiple seasons now I don't mess with the DAI inputs or outputs in more. All my adjustments are made by just altering the custom plays to suit my opponent. So all of a sudden they start firing wrong when I haven't even opened my "Defense AI" tab in over a season?
 
P@nda
Radioactive
offline
Link
 
From test the above 5 plays these were the results:


Play 1:

When I tested the AI for this play the only output that came up was #5. However when I tested the output with untagged QB the only output was:

Matching Input
Input Named: 3rd/4th & 4+ I-Form

Possible Outputs
100% Quarter I Form 3rd DN (Custom: Quarter I Form 3rd DN Stop)

Which was called.

Play 2:

Definitely called according to your AI

Play 3:

When I tested this play the output should have came out correctly. When tested with untagged QB there was:

Matching Input
There are no matching inputs to this situation.

That might explain the mystery defensive call.

Play 4:

Tested exactly the same as play 3. Basic tactics used in this situation.

Play 5:

When tested with untagged QB this is what cam up:

Matching Input
Input Named: 2nd & 0-7 Strong I

Possible Outputs
100% 3-4 2nd-Long (Custom: 3-4 I-From 2nd-Long) Which was called in this instance.

I apologize. I do not have very much experience with testing AI, but it does appear that your Defense treated 4/5 plays exactly like you had an untagged QB playing against you. What is concerning is that it appears on one of the plays that the defense reacted like there was a tagged QB on the field.

This is not a matter of the sim grabbing your inputs in order. Testing shows that there is only one possible output in each scenario when your Defense runs as planned, and in 2/5 cases there were zero outputs for the situation as called by the offense. Those situations might need to be addressed either way.

Marking as Likely a Bug because the AI was applied in one situation like there was a tagged QB and in four situations like there was not a tagged QB.

 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Grr8WhiteHype


My DAI is broke ... fix it.


 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
As P@nda has done the testing on this and marked it likely a bug, I'll send it over to QA.
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
give me access, i'll look at it.
 
Grr8WhiteHype
offline
Link
 
You should have a GM offer Kuaggie.

And Mightyhalo stop trolling tool.
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Grr8WhiteHype
You should have a GM offer Kuaggie.

And Mightyhalo stop trolling tool.


will check on it tommorow @ 4-5 pm pacific time. Too....ummmm......not in the right mindset right now. Sorry if this is a bit of a wait!
 
Djmr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie
will check on it tommorow @ 4-5 pm pacific time. Too....ummmm......not in the right mindset right now. Sorry if this is a bit of a wait!


No worries, I can wait
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
Specifically, per P@nda's update, I'd like to know what the tester says would be called with an untagged QB - is it possible the play call could come up on an untagged QB?

I'm concerned that the QB wasn't considered tagged in time for the game. Do we know when the scouting tag was applied? I think I've seen people have issues where the tag was applied too close to game time and the game already pulled the AI data, including tagging info. If it's possible that play 2 could have been called even with an untagged QB, then I think that the AI considered the QB untagged for the purposes of the game.
 
Grr8WhiteHype
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiborRis
Specifically, per P@nda's update, I'd like to know what the tester says would be called with an untagged QB - is it possible the play call could come up on an untagged QB?

I'm concerned that the QB wasn't considered tagged in time for the game. Do we know when the scouting tag was applied? I think I've seen people have issues where the tag was applied too close to game time and the game already pulled the AI data, including tagging info. If it's possible that play 2 could have been called even with an untagged QB, then I think that the AI considered the QB untagged for the purposes of the game.


I tagged him the day before the game so that's not an option.

Also the one time the correct play was called is a play that can only be used for a tagged a QB. It's a play specifically made for stopping a rushing QB. That's why this is 100% a bug. We know the sim saw the QB has a tagged player 1 time but the other four times it didn't and called a defensive as if there were no tags.

And I mean tags. My defense is based on tagging. I tag every RB on the other team either as "power" or "speedy." I then have a play for every formation to stop either the RB that is in tagged as power or the RB in tagged as speedy. In the QB runs those RB's were in but the play called were my fall back plays in case a team uses an out of position player and those plays use no tags.

Basically my AI in order is ...

1. QB specific plays
2. RB tagged plays
3. Fall back plays in case of trickery by other team

In four out of five of the QB runs the sim saw no one as tagged which is impossible since the QB in was tagged and the RB was tagged. The way my sim is set is if the tagged QB is in the QB specific plays are used, if he is out the RB tagged plays are used and if some how none of them are in (5 WR set or trickery) my fall back plays trigger. Two out of the four times I had a play in my fall back but it didn't really matter. The other two times a random play was selected.

 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
have to give me the option to....scout?

i can't check the tags
 
Grr8WhiteHype
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie
have to give me the option to....scout?o_O

i can't check the tags


Sent owner a PM.

Also I went back to look and there is definitely a tagging bug on this team. All my tags for the game are gone. No one on the team is tagged yet in the game plays were called that could only be called if the RB or QB was tagged a certain way. We also played them last year and I remember clearly only having to do the QB tag this year because the RB's were tagged from the season before.

So somehow the tags are disappearing and looks like they work some of the time during games but not all the time as you can see in the games that custom plays that have to have a tagged player to trigger are called.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.