User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Eldonko
offline
Link
 
How does this work? I have a guy competing for defensive MVP but is in second place. Stats are as follows:

First place player: 25 tackles, 25 sacks, 2 FF
My guy: 98 tackles, 65 sacks, 16 FF

How is the #1 guy even in the top 10?
 
Vandigo
offline
Link
 
Are those raw stats or blowout adjusted?
 
amace
offline
Link
 
uses blowout adjusted sacks, team success, and probably some other thigns.
 
Eldonko
offline
Link
 
those are raw stats.

Lets look again at blowout adjusted and team record:

First place player: 46 tackles, 18 sacks, 2 FF, team record 3-8
My guy: 35 tackles, 23 sacks, 5 FF, team record 10-1

I dont get the blowout adjustment. We are in the same league playing the same teams. Just because my team kills opponents instead of losing my players stats are worth less?

Look at the difference in the players
1) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1650494
2) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1471271
Edited by Eldonko on Jun 24, 2010 09:18:06
 
Hagalaz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eldonko
How does this work? I have a guy competing for defensive MVP but is in second place. Stats are as follows:

First place player: 25 tackles, 25 sacks, 2 FF
My guy: 98 tackles, 65 sacks, 16 FF

How is the #1 guy even in the top 10?


How important is he to his team's performance?
 
Eldonko
offline
Link
 
3-8 record vs my 10-1 record. #1 guy does not seem to be helping THAT much. I suppose he is 1 of 11 real players on a CPU team though so compared to the team he is good. Does that warrant MVP?
Edited by Eldonko on Jun 24, 2010 09:24:28
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by http://goallineblitz.com/fame_faq.html

How are MVP rankings calculated?
They are based on a variety of calculations involving player statistics. Overall stats, contribution to the team's output, and comparison to other players at the same position are all taken into account to arrive at a final ranking.
 
Eldonko
offline
Link
 
Ok thanks for that, could you comment on the two players in question please? Why is it that players on a competitive team are put at such a disadvantage vs human players on a poor CPU team?

With the current system for awarding MVP the best bet is to put a good player on a CPU team is it not? Then they have a large "contribution to the team's output" and blowout penalty is much less because the CPU team will lose instead of win 255-0. Pretty stupid if you ask me when a player with 25 tackles, 25 sacks, 2 FF beats a player with 98 tackles, 65 sacks, 16 FF due to being on a CPU team.

That's like awarding MVP to Steven Jackson instead of Peyton Manning because the Rams suck and he is the best of the worst.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
It's just a flaw in the system. The MVP system is recognized to not be perfect.
 
Eldonko
offline
Link
 
Should I be reporting this in the bug forum or something?

Really all that has to be done is add criteria that the team has to be successful for "contribution to the team's output" bonus to kick in. That would equal out blowout penalty, especially in a league like mine which is full of CPU teams..
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
No, it's not a bug and doesn't belong in that forum. The formula works as it is coded.
 
naraic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eldonko
Should I be reporting this in the bug forum or something?

Really all that has to be done is add criteria that the team has to be successful for "contribution to the team's output" bonus to kick in. That would equal out blowout penalty, especially in a league like mine which is full of CPU teams..


Its easier to pad stats with a good supporting cast.

Lets say your guy is RDE and you have a quality D-line that absorbs the effort of the entire O-line. The LT and LG have to focus on blocking the DT, the C and RG have to block the NT, the RT and TE block the LDE and your RDE has an unopposed route to get the sack.

The #1 guy is a quality performer on a poor team that achieves his stats through individual effort. Lets say he is a NT that has to break blocks from the C, RG, and LG.

Obviously his stats will be worth more as an individual performance.

Its not perfect and could improved but it works.



 
Eldonko
offline
Link
 
Mat McBriar - Is there a place to give feedback to the devs?

naraic - Maybe so but how can you determine what is individual effort and what is a team effort? I mean compare the builds and judge which will be the better individual performer. Or put my player on that CPU team and the other DE on my team and see what happens.

Any non-cpu player on a cpu team is going to be a quality performer (compared to the rest of the team) no matter what the build, just because CPU players are terrible. Plus they wont lose 90% of their stats from blowout penalties. That is my whole point, now all you have to do is throw a star player on a CPU team and MVP is in the bag. I just think MVP should be awarded based on player skill not based on the type of team a player is on.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eldonko
Mat McBriar - Is there a place to give feedback to the devs?


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread_list.pl?forum_id=2 - The suggestions forum is what you are looking for.
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread_list.pl?forum_id=2 - The suggestions forum is what you are looking for.

Save your breath, though. New threads complaining about MVP races pop up several times a day, and never have an impact - Bort claims to be happy with the current formula.

When you get down to it, there's no computer formula that can calculate who the MVP is - if there was one, the NFL would be using it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.