User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > FGs in 20-29 yard range are bugged - RESOLVED BUG #174
Page:
 
Zickzack
offline
Link
 
As the bug mods decided to dismiss the previous thread here are a few more numbers that should back up my claim that FGs in the 20-29 range are clearly not woorking as they should. I went through the numbers for all kickers from WL and all Pro leagues including Casual for all regular season games from season 15 and 16 up to this morning. Overall these were more than 10000 FGs attempted at the highest level the game has to offer, so the numbers should be fairly representative.

FGs Made/Attempted - Percentage
Overall: 8697/10537 - 82.54%
10-19: 280/289 - 96.89%
20-29: 1697/1977 - 85.84%
30-39: 2339/2509 - 93.22%
40-49: 3277/3458 - 94.77%
50+: 1104/2304 - 47.92%

It is pretty apparent that short FGs in the 20-29 yard range have a far worse success rate than those of the two next higher ranges, and that is not even accounting for players having invested in Automatic, which should increase the success rate at shorter ranges, as well as extending the range that should be considered "short" according to the description.

There is simply no way that FGs in that range should be converted at a rate almost 10% lower than longer FGs. Either something is wrong with those short FGs in general, or at worst Automatic is seriously bugged and actually detrimental to short range attempts.
Edited by lhouse on Jul 27, 2010 06:55:09 (RESOLVED)
Edited by lhouse on Jun 18, 2010 13:56:55 (Fix Uploaded)
Edited by Deadpool55 on Jun 8, 2010 17:18:17 (Bug filed.)
Edited by kuaggie on Jun 8, 2010 12:33:56
Edited by STG on Jun 8, 2010 07:45:13 (Giving the timing of the above mentioned Change, and when the Kicking seemed to take a dip it can't be coincidence)
 
doobas
™
offline
Link
 
Taking these results, it does indeed look like the FGs in the 20-29 range are bugged.

doobas™
 
Frog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by doobas
Taking these results, it does indeed look like the FGs in the 20-29 range are bugged.

doobas™


I agree. Moving to QA
 
STG
offline
Link
 
I agree there is a noticeable drop. I didn't see anything touch the Kicking in the Changelogs other than this:

May 27, 2010
- Fix bug giving kickers extra attempts that they didn't actually try for in game stats

Maybe something was fubared during this process??

Other QA Thoughts?
 
Djmr
offline
Link
 
Gotta agree with the numbers, we'll need to know why there have been so many misses around that range though (it might not be relevant to automatic)
 
STG
offline
Link
 
Giving the timing of the above mentioned Change, and when the Kicking seemed to take a dip it can't be coincidence. I am willing to determine that this may be a BUG - FIRST VERIFICATION
 
Djmr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by STG
May 27, 2010
- Fix bug giving kickers extra attempts that they didn't actually try for in game stats


That bug was very rare, I don't believe that had anything to do with it.
 
Zickzack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by STG
I agree there is a noticeable drop. I didn't see anything touch the Kicking in the Changelogs other than this:

May 27, 2010
- Fix bug giving kickers extra attempts that they didn't actually try for in game stats

Maybe something was fubared during this process??

Other QA Thoughts?


The numbers include last season, I reckon it might always have been an issue already that just was not picked up on. If you don't look at very large numbers it might easily be dismissed as just a "thing that happens", that's what happened the first time I brought it up
 
STG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Djmr
That bug was very rare, I don't believe that had anything to do with it.


Ya for sure a possibility, but maybe in the fixing of this bug, something to do with short range was tweaked (Intentionally or otherwise)

it's the only change I could find regarding kickers in the time frame of the end of Season 15 and the start of Season 16
Edited by STG on Jun 8, 2010 07:49:33
 
STG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zickzack
The numbers include last season, I reckon it might always have been an issue already that just was not picked up on. If you don't look at very large numbers it might easily be dismissed as just a "thing that happens", that's what happened the first time I brought it up


Good point. I'll comb over older Changelogs for the sake of reference...
 
doobas
™
offline
Link
 
Good to know this is getting looked at. Will be interested to find out the cause.

doobas™
 
STG
offline
Link
 
Zickzack , what is the time scope of your numbers?

Also maybe this change is the cause?

March 29, 2010
- Reduce kick velocity baseline
 
Zickzack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by STG
Zickzack , what is the time scope of your numbers?

Also maybe this change is the cause?

March 29, 2010
- Reduce kick velocity baseline


All of season 15 and 16 for all Pro leagues including Casual and WL.

I just ran the numbers for WL and WEPL for season 14 and they look far more like what you'd expect:
Overall: 1874/2046 - 91.59%
10-19: 61/64 - 95.31%
20-29: 355/369 - 96.21%
30-39: 491/509 - 96.46%
40-49: 637/653 - 97.55%
50+: 330/451 - 73.17%

Smaller sample size of course, but to me it looks as if the change might have come between seasons 14 and 15.
 
STG
offline
Link
 
Great you beat me to it, thanks

So the (possible) change(s) occurred somewhere End of Season 14 - Beginning Season 16
 
STG
offline
Link
 
So in the suspected time frame, only two reported changes to kicking occurred:

March 29, 2010
- Reduce kick velocity baseline
May 27, 2010
- Fix bug giving kickers extra attempts that they didn't actually try for in game stats


And None of this has taken into account all of the Confidence/Morale related changes that have occurred in the last 3-4 months...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.