User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > Blocking Logic needs reworking on SI Sweep- RESOLVED BUG #171
Page:
 
rjssob
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Seriously, all the changes and this can not be resolved? The inconsistency in blocking is about the most frustrating thing in the game:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1203125&pbp_id=2758709

How can the game be coded to have a TE and FB just ignore the plays biggest threat?
Edited by Lensar on Dec 7, 2010 11:45:52
Edited by Catch22 on Nov 14, 2010 07:17:25
Edited by lhouse on Jun 7, 2010 12:03:10 (Bug Filed)
Edited by kuaggie on Jun 7, 2010 10:19:21
Edited by Catch22 on Jun 7, 2010 09:28:35
 
blaslo
offline
Link
 
I think that there are a lot of possibilities here other than a bug. The left outside linebacker might have a fantastic disguise blitz that successfully fired, or even more probable, just a failed vision check by the fullback and tight end. Even in the NFL, there's going to be a blown play every now and again, a missed assignment. Wouldn't seem realistic to me if the defender was picked up every single time. Now, if you have more examples showing that in this play the blockers ALWAYS met the man come free, then there might be an issue, but right now I'm thinking it's probably not a bug
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blaslo
I think that there are a lot of possibilities here other than a bug. The left outside linebacker might have a fantastic disguise blitz that successfully fired, or even more probable, just a failed vision check by the fullback and tight end. Even in the NFL, there's going to be a blown play every now and again, a missed assignment. Wouldn't seem realistic to me if the defender was picked up every single time. Now, if you have more examples showing that in this play the blockers ALWAYS met the man come free, then there might be an issue, but right now I'm thinking it's probably not a bug


i'm out of my realm of the bugs forum, but i see this ALOT. I think the logic might be off. Will look for examples later. Besides that TE's logic doesn't make any sense. against that defensive formation you should always be sealing off the edge....which would be the LB, no?
 
Asdlfef
offline
Link
 
I would like to see more instances of this to confirm or deny whether or not this is a bug.
 
blaslo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie
i'm out of my realm of the bugs forum, but i see this ALOT. I think the logic might be off. Will look for examples later. Besides that TE's logic doesn't make any sense. against that defensive formation you should always be sealing off the edge....which would be the LB, no?


true, there might be an issue with the overall logic. It's just the way that the linebacker hesitates before attacking in this specific example that makes me think there's no issue with this replay. It almost seems like the blockers start moving onto their next target because they don't see the linebacker as a threat. It's like when watching a game and you see a defender fall down, sometimes the blockers run right by him, that he gets up and makes the tackle. I think that more specific examples wouldn't hurt
 
rjssob
HOOD
offline
Link
 
There is an obvious defect in the pathing on certain blocking plays and I have been down the road of supplying examples and I am done with that. I would love to see someone, whether it be a tester or a bugs mod says something to the effect of:

We are going to execute a test where we have the following scenario:

Strong I Pitch Right vs 4-3 COV0
Strong I Pitch Right vs 4-3 COV1
Strong I Pitch Right vs 4-3 COV2
Strong I Pitch Right vs 4-3 COV3

Blitzes:
Strong I Pitch Right vs 4-3 COV2 LOLB Blitz
Strong I Pitch Right vs 4-3 COV2 MLB and LOLB Blitz
Strong I Pitch Right vs 4-3 COV1 - ROLB/SS Blitz

You can add some basic defensive plays from 4-3, 4-4 and 3-4 and for every condition you will have an expected result as to where the TE should block, etc...

No offense, but I am not a tester and not a bug mod, so why is it that I need to supply the data for a test to be run? I could never understand how potential bugs are just dismissed with the company line of Needs More Data! You have a test environment, let's fire it up....
 
Gazeruth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rjssob
There is an obvious defect in the pathing on certain blocking plays and I have been down the road of supplying examples and I am done with that. I would love to see someone, whether it be a tester or a bugs mod says something to the effect of:

We are going to execute a test where we have the following scenario:

Strong I Pitch Right vs 4-3 COV0
Strong I Pitch Right vs 4-3 COV1
Strong I Pitch Right vs 4-3 COV2
Strong I Pitch Right vs 4-3 COV3

Blitzes:
Strong I Pitch Right vs 4-3 COV2 LOLB Blitz
Strong I Pitch Right vs 4-3 COV2 MLB and LOLB Blitz
Strong I Pitch Right vs 4-3 COV1 - ROLB/SS Blitz

You can add some basic defensive plays from 4-3, 4-4 and 3-4 and for every condition you will have an expected result as to where the TE should block, etc...

No offense, but I am not a tester and not a bug mod, so why is it that I need to supply the data for a test to be run? I could never understand how potential bugs are just dismissed with the company line of Needs More Data! You have a test environment, let's fire it up....


Unfortunately we don't have the time or resources to test every bug that comes in. I understand you're frustration as it does seem like an error in logic, however we do need to get some more information about these potential bugs before we can confirm them as bugs and file them as such.

We can't just try and test each of these situations unless we have some more examples of it happening. The best thing I can suggest is that you try to re-create the problems that you're having, and hopefully others who do browse these bugs forums can help out if they experience similar issues.

This one-time occurrance isn't enough evidence to pass this along, however if you could give us another example of it happening (I'm guessing your team will run this play a few more times) then we can certainly proceed further with it.
 
Gazeruth
offline
Link
 
From flicking through their scrimmage games I found these:

TE appears to head straight outside and not downfield for LOLB
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1203131&pbp_id=1276708
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1203131&pbp_id=1278191

FB doesn't "look inside" for the LOLB, just heads straight out
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1203134&pbp_id=535587
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1203131&pbp_id=1279541

Neither FB nor TE "look inside" for LOLB
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1203128&pbp_id=2002701

Not sure if these can help either way - but both seem to show slight problems with blocking
 
rjssob
HOOD
offline
Link
 
There is an entire thread dedicated to blocking in this forum already with multiple examples that this can be added too. This wasn't just a saw it once type play and then we saying stop the games! I fully understand the process behind it and also the fact that everything can not be looked at ASAP, but to me blocking and tackling would be the fundamental things that need to work correctly. I think the initial thread is under OL Blocking...Thanks for checking.
Edited by rjssob on Jun 2, 2010 18:14:53
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
alright the play was SI pitch....here are some recent plays from WL teams:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1211589&pbp_id=2464951
TE blocks SS downfield, LOLB is pinched in, no problem

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1211587&pbp_id=1000486
TE blocks SS downfield, LOLB is pinched in, no problem

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1211587&pbp_id=1002541
TE run towards MLB? LOLB is uncovered and in perfect position to make play. whoops

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1211597&pbp_id=2484488
looks like the TE is trying to block the SS

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1211600&pbp_id=1729945
TE picks up LOLB! but only after completing the pull to the outside first

look at this one, it looks like a prime example of our problem
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1211600&pbp_id=1732082
TE picks up LOLB again, but again only after completing the pull to the outside first....the LOLB nearly breaks up the play and it doesn't look like he's blitzing

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1211600&pbp_id=1733073
picked up perfectly, but at a second look the TE is going for the DE who is lined up way outside

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1211600&pbp_id=1733073
again picked up but it looks like the TE is look at the LILB first which is the only reason i think he doesn't pull

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1211608&pbp_id=1719109
picks it up but only after completing the pull

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1211608&pbp_id=1720525
more of the same

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1211608&pbp_id=1727409
......................?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1211608&pbp_id=1729509
TE blocking an end that's pulled out wide





After looking at all these plays it appears that there is in my opinion a possible exploit. I'm not sure of the EXACT location but it appears that the blocking TE does not take the LOLB (which SHOULD be his guy 9/10 on this play) into consideration until AFTER he has completed his pull. I don't believe this is a failed vision check as the only times the TE blocked the LOLB is when his actions appeared to be affected by either the SS, the MLB/ILB or a DE pulled way outside. I'd like to see some tests run where the line, MLB and company are taken out of the equation and see how the TE reacts to a blitzing LOLB to the outside....for some reason i don't think there's even a chance he'll pick him up....at least not immediately like he should.

If i were to suggest a fix, it would be to have the TE focus more on the area where a LOLB would USUALLY be, than pulling so far out to the flat before checking any blitzers. As it is right now, that pull seems to be creating a small hole/weakness that could be exploited by a really shrewd DC.
Edited by kuaggie on Jun 2, 2010 18:20:29
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rjssob
There is an entire thread dedicated to blocking in this forum already with multiple examples, so please don't think this is a holy crap this play didn't work stop the game type post. I fully understand the process behind it and also the fact that everything can not be looked at ASAP, but to me blocking and tackling would be the fundamental things that need to work correctly. I think the initial thread is under OL Blocking...Thanks for checking.


looks like the problems come when facing the 3-4. the blocking TE sees no immediate threat on the line so he pulls out, leaving a LOLB wide open to come blitzing through.
 
rjssob
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Good samples! Thanks for checking this out...
 
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blaslo
true, there might be an issue with the overall logic. It's just the way that the linebacker hesitates before attacking in this specific example that makes me think there's no issue with this replay. It almost seems like the blockers start moving onto their next target because they don't see the linebacker as a threat. It's like when watching a game and you see a defender fall down, sometimes the blockers run right by him, that he gets up and makes the tackle. I think that more specific examples wouldn't hurt


wrong... hesitation on the linebackers part here should mean his butt is on the ground before he moves.. it is a run play he should be sealed by the TE, further even if the TE misses the assignment the fullbacks responsibility when leading is to ALWAYS not sometimes but always pick up first threat...... in this case if the TE screws up the FB should be cleaning house a bit....
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by toobad4u_00
wrong... hesitation on the linebackers part here should mean his butt is on the ground before he moves.. it is a run play he should be sealed by the TE, further even if the TE misses the assignment the fullbacks responsibility when leading is to ALWAYS not sometimes but always pick up first threat...... in this case if the TE screws up the FB should be cleaning house a bit....


well the issue we're trying to determine is NOT if that guy is supposed to be blocked or not (he IS). The question is if it's a function of failed vision checks or if that's just bad pathing & logic that can never be overcome.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1203397&pbp_id=2736567
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1203397&pbp_id=2731103

HERE you go.

More SI Sweep failure.
Edited by Bukowski on Jun 3, 2010 05:11:17
Edited by Bukowski on Jun 3, 2010 05:11:02
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.