User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > Please fix punt away pursue pathing logic! - DUPLICATE BUG #161
The Avenger
Hulk Smash
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1200012&pbp_id=1771141

Honestly, how many more examples do we need of this where the entire punt team except SE1 and SE2 run a STRAIGHT line ahead when the play is well, well over to one side on an angled punt! We almost gave up a TD and have before because there was only 1 available tackler in the area while the other 7-8 are completely off their rocker down field heading for the endzone instead!

Regular season is starting soon, please fix....
Edited by lhouse on Jun 18, 2010 14:01:05 (Duplicate Bug)
Edited by lhouse on Jun 3, 2010 17:41:22 (Bug Filed)
Edited by kuaggie on Jun 3, 2010 15:14:48 (needs to be filed)
Edited by Djmr on Jun 3, 2010 14:12:28 (I believe its a bug - full reason below)
Edited by Hokiemon on Jun 3, 2010 14:09:09 (NEEDS QA DETERMINATION)
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Agreed, it does need to be fixed. That is horrible logic.
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
how well they do it should be a function of vision.....but still. they should go in the general right direction to the ball....
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Gonna reclassify this as likely a bug pending another CS opinion of it. I also agree that the coverage team should at least follow the ball to some degree.
 
Hokiemon
offline
Link
 
Agreed the punt coverage logic is bad

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1265426&pbp_id=2928429

Moved to BUG - NEEDS QA DETERMINATION
Edited by Hokiemon on Jun 3, 2010 14:09:22
 
Djmr
offline
Link
 
First verification

Why I think its a bug:
- Players should run in direction to the ball, its common sense to in football
- It gives returners a better angle to run with the ball, awarding them with greater yards (not much, but still unfair)
- Even though Bort initially programmed ST to run this way for simplicity (I guess, or for fixing a problem), this shouldn't mean that this problem should continue.

Suggestions to solve the problem:
1. Vision check to see where the ball is. It should determine how fast players react to where the ball is, not to depend on if they see it or not (so eventually even players with low vision will react).
2. Change in direction to where player thinks ball will end up (depending on successful vision check of above, similar to returner movement)
3. Punt team should know the general direction of where the punt is going to go before the play - so they head towards that direction first.
Edited by Djmr on Jun 3, 2010 14:28:23
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
I think STs originally worked this way because punts were always straight ahead, and keeping the interior folks in their lanes was a better approach than letting them all bundle up together as they run to the returner, allowing one move to just cruise around all of them.

However, with coffin corner punts, and punts that don't quite make the corner but get picked up and ran back instead, we have a new problem. I think when punts are off-center is when new logic should be used.

What is needed is some thoughts on what the new logic should look like - we don't want the same problem of all the pursuit players ending up on the same line towards the returner, but we also don't want 90% of the team running straight downfield when the ball isn't even on their half of the field.

 
Djmr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiborRis
What is needed is some thoughts on what the new logic should look like - we don't want the same problem of all the pursuit players ending up on the same line towards the returner, but we also don't want 90% of the team running straight downfield when the ball isn't even on their half of the field.


I guess you didnt see my edit in time then?

Thats something we need to do before taking this to Bort IMO, an agreement on that.
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Second verification:

Why I think it's a bug:

-the middle guys run straight forward regardless of where the ball is going leaving the sideline wide open.
-this is old code that was functional only when there was one kind of punt (straight forward)


The two gunners appear to move appropriately (they seem to be chasing the PR at all times) while the middle guys appear to be hardcoded until the PR catches the ball. I would suggest:

-Based on where the punter is punting it (straight forward, vs. coffin corner) have two different punt plays. The straight forward punt would be unchanged, the coffin corner would hard code a diagonal movement in the general direction of the punt (to keep people in their lanes), and once the PR catches the ball, actual pursuit begins.
 
Deadpool55
offline
Link
 
locked per mod, bug #161.
 
HouseRules
offline
Link
 
This is being tracked as #164, currently in test. This thread will be closed as duplicate.

Use this thread to continue this discussion:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4076088
Edited by lhouse on Jun 18, 2010 14:00:37
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.