User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > change auto promotion
Page:
 
Clarka3
offline
Link
 
i like the idea in principle to keep rivalries going, but it really screws a ton of teams. case in point, the Malton Zombies ( http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=318). Started the season off with an average level of 10 or so in a cap 18 league (because we were level 1's in a cap 14 the season before but didn't finish last to allow us to stay at the same level).

We perform well enough to be the 3rd seed in the playoffs due to gameplanning to beat stronger teams. We end up getting knocked out by the 2nd seed in the 2nd round. Now, our reward is an auto jump to cap 26 while all of our players are finally 18-17 and under? Where's the sense in that? It takes the fun out of the game for agents that are stuck in a perpetually higher cap than they should be.

I've also seen and been a part of teams that have intentionally thrown an entire season to avoid the bigger cap jumps. It takes away from the competitive nature of the game. I think the owner choice of cap needs to come back.
Edited by Clarka3 on May 12, 2010 17:02:49
 
NoSkillz
offline
Link
 

It's set up like that to suck as much money from your wallet as they can.

 
temujin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NoSkillz

It's set up like that to suck as much money from your wallet as they can.



 
Clarka3
offline
Link
 
yeah, i can see that, but in the meantime it's not fun for our team and our non-boosting agents because we're never getting an even shake unless we play a team that got screwed in promotions like us.

i'd just rather see the promotion system go back to the way it was where owners were given a choice on cap so long as their players were at or under the cap level.
 
LostPeon
offline
Link
 
There's simply too many teams to be able to cater to every person's situation and wants.

Having a clearly defined promotion scheme and sticking to it is in the best interest of the game and helps to keep things simpler and more clear cut.
 
Clarka3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LostPeon
There's simply too many teams to be able to cater to every person's situation and wants.

Having a clearly defined promotion scheme and sticking to it is in the best interest of the game and helps to keep things simpler and more clear cut.


fair enough. THere's got to be a way for teams to "catch up" to the cap level, though. Some teams, like ours, start under leveled and manage promotion after promotion because either other teams are trying to lose or our game plans surprise people. The cap promotion would work if teams started at the correct level for that cap.

 
NoSkillz
offline
Link
 
I would rather the playing fields be more level myself. I wont be spening any flex to boost till the game is more about football and less about the sucking someones wallet dry.

Make the game fun and I will spend my money on it again. If not I just recyle the 35000 flex I have without you getting another penny.

 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
You will have to try and battle for last place next season or at be a non-playoff team for 2 seasons or so by throwing games.

A team like yours played a bunch of those type of teams and you probably didn't even know it. Some teams throw 2 or even 3 seasons so they can maintain a level advantage through the capped leagues.

It sucks, but that's the nature of this game.

I wish they would just get rid of caps and place teams by effective level to eliminate the cap exploiting that is ruining the game and competition.
Edited by Mightyhalo on May 13, 2010 06:48:13
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
Not sure what the suggestion is but since your case is a less common scenario from most your best bet would be to send in a message to support, stating the points as you have and suggest that you move up to cap 22. Just make sure you don't have any players over that cap when you ask.

However with that said- you did make the playoffs and in fact took 3rd place in a league not completely filled with CPU teams. You were able to field a team that was competitive in a league you were outleveled in before. You should probably move up to 26 and see if you are competitive there. Perhaps you will surprise yourself and be able to make the playoffs again. Just because your players are not the same level as everyone else and you don't walk away with gold doesn't mean you are in the wrong league. You game planned and beat higher level teams. Sounds like you should enjoy the competition (you beat the 6th place team 90-6 and only lost by 3 points to the 2nd place team, thats pretty good) and it will eventually even out for you.

If you get beat out of the playoffs next season, you'll move up 1 jump, and will then be in a league closer to your level and you can stomp all over weak teams.
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
Simple enough fix imo. Take levels out of the game. Give everybody "x" amount of SPs when player is created and thats all they get except for training and vet points gained after 5 seasons. No more under leveled teams being forced into higher level leagues.

Its been a problem since I can remember. It will always be a problem in games like this when levels are involved. This is basically a pvp mmo and those with the highest levels usually win, just like any other mmo.

There will never be any real true balance to any game when levels are involved.
 
Clarka3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
Not sure what the suggestion is but since your case is a less common scenario from most your best bet would be to send in a message to support, stating the points as you have and suggest that you move up to cap 22. Just make sure you don't have any players over that cap when you ask.

However with that said- you did make the playoffs and in fact took 3rd place in a league not completely filled with CPU teams. You were able to field a team that was competitive in a league you were outleveled in before. You should probably move up to 26 and see if you are competitive there. Perhaps you will surprise yourself and be able to make the playoffs again. Just because your players are not the same level as everyone else and you don't walk away with gold doesn't mean you are in the wrong league. You game planned and beat higher level teams. Sounds like you should enjoy the competition (you beat the 6th place team 90-6 and only lost by 3 points to the 2nd place team, thats pretty good) and it will eventually even out for you.

If you get beat out of the playoffs next season, you'll move up 1 jump, and will then be in a league closer to your level and you can stomp all over weak teams.



we don't mind a challenge, but for once it'd be nice to be on even footing with our opponents, yanno? And since we care and try, the teams that are throwing games (and hurting the competitive fun and nature of the game imo) are going to miss promotions while we get shoved into them.

The current system rewards teams that plan to lose.


Edited by Clarka3 on May 13, 2010 11:04:00
 
amace
offline
Link
 
This is sounding much harder than it actually is.

Obviously you can't make it fully based on the owners choices, it won't always work out. But do it similar to how you sell teams.

Owner gets his first choice, second choice and third if necessary. It doesn't matter how you did, all that matters is the level of your players. If you win the league, but don't have a player over level 14, you should still be eligible for 14 cap if you want. You don't see the NFL shipping the pats off to some super league just because they wona bunch of times.

If they have players over level 14, then their choices are either 18 or 22 cap. They should not be forced to move up unless they do not qualify for the lowest cap.

lets take another example:

I have a player on a cap 46 team. My player started as level 38 on that team, is 44 now. they made the playoffs, so will advance two caps. that happens to be AA. We have three players over 46, we shoudl be given the option to stay in 46 if we want as long as those three players are cut. The league was terrible, and most games were blowouts, but thats due to bad competition, not because we were a powerhouse team. Like I said, the team was full of level 35-40 players at the beginning of the season.

Say you are in 22 cap.

If you finish 9th, by rule you move up. However, in some minor leagues, a team full of level 18s could finish 9th in that league. They should not be forced to cap 26 where they have next to no chance to compete, they shoudl be allowed to stay in 22, as long as they don't have any players over 22.


To summarize, the changes that need to be done are:

Allow the selection of leagues, but you may not have players over the cap (gets rid of high leveled players 'grandfathered' into low leagues)
Give a top 3 choice for leagues, so if you want 18, but its full, then you go to 22, but not 26
Since this is done after day 41, players can't save their boosts then boost 6 levels between day 41 and day 1 to get an early head start


It shouldn't be this difficult, but it somehow is.
 
Clarka3
offline
Link
 
well, i mean, if it really is just about the money to encourage teams to boost, it alienates the nonboosting players. As much of the discussion that's going on in favor of not alienating the nonboosters, this practice really does just that. There's no way we can compete legitimately for a title, but there's always a chance we'll make the playoffs because every other team is scrambling to NOT win so they don't get promoted. it's not fun when we waltz into the playoffs with no realistic chance of competing for a trophy.
 
notthegint
offline
Link
 
Change to a horizontal promotion system. Just like elite minors now.

Everyone promotes to the appropriate level cap and slides toward or away from elite leagues.

+ No getting promoted out of your depth
+ You play the same teams most of the way up (provided they're about as good as you are)
+ Makes it easy to subtract lower tier leagues as they become filled with CPU teams if people gut
 
Clarka3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by notthegint
Change to a horizontal promotion system. Just like elite minors now.

Everyone promotes to the appropriate level cap and slides toward or away from elite leagues.

+ No getting promoted out of your depth
+ You play the same teams most of the way up (provided they're about as good as you are)
+ Makes it easy to subtract lower tier leagues as they become filled with CPU teams if people gut


i like this. it keeps up rivalries for teams that are of equal level
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.