User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Passing Game Discussion
Page:
 
Rlurie
offline
Link
 
[Jed edited out the mod stuff at the beginning, will send a PM about that]

1) When QB's decide they're not going to throw the ball and instead attempt to rush, ALL of the defenders know this and react to it, EVEN when the QB hasn't crossed the line of scrimmage. WHAT IS THAT?
-http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1141795&pbp_id=11335694
(That is just one example from our last game, there are many more...notice the RO linebacker coming back to the QB because he knows the QB is trying to rush even though the QB can still throw it since he hasn't crossed the LOS.
-http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1141715&pbp_id=4664606
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1141826&pbp_id=3841429
(That one is great, ALL of the LB's run to the QB knowing he is going to run even though he should have the option to still be able to pass.
-http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1141826&pbp_id=3851738

2) QB's seem to be able to move much faster when dropping back to throw as compared to them attempting to rush.
-http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1141795&pbp_id=11335694
(same example as above because I'm lazy right now in finding another but he drops back fairly quickly but then once he attempts to rush the ball he moves like a snail.)
-http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1141715&pbp_id=4664606
-http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1141715&pbp_id=4667818

3) FB's never seem to take a good path on outside rushes.
-http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1141795&pbp_id=11330288

4) If a DT and/or NT aren't lined up directly against the Center, the Center will never run down field to block someone, instead the Center will just kind of stand there and do nothing. Run up field and block the MLB?
-http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1141795&pbp_id=11330347
-http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1141795&pbp_id=11330368
-http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1141795&pbp_id=11335965

5) Pass Interference ever? CB's want to play aggressive and have 0 cushion, maybe a pass interference call once in awhile??

6) Can we please have a setting for our QB's to not just throw one way? What QB always lobs the ball or always bullets the ball? Can we have the option for throwing style on certain plays?

7) Can we also have the option to throw to open man or route distance on certain plays? Having one way to throw all game really makes having different stragies difficult.

8) The ability to have WR1 and WR2 rotate positions for certain plays. If I want a certain WR to play the WR2 position on one play but maybe play the slot or WR3 another, why can't I do that?

9) Can we please be able to flip an offensive play or defensive play? I can't have the Nickel 3-3-5 with the nickel corner playing either side? Can I maybe just once flip an offensive play? (Just press R2)

10) I can set my AI to spike the ball during 2 min drill but I can't control my players to favor the sidelines or play hurry up. Maybe somehow have a setting where the dots can try to run out of bounds during a hurry up offense? Dots rush to the line quicker to get off the next snap?
Edited by Jed on Apr 28, 2010 09:07:55 (un"hooking" title, editing out mod stuff to be taken to PMs)
 
Link
 
They Holy must be Cow serious. It is dotball, after all.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
tl;dr.
 
tuba_samurai
offline
Link
 
Divide your suggestions up so that the like ones are together and then repost so that it isn't a compilation thread.

You can PM it to a suggestions mod beforehand and they will let you know if it's good to go. Sorry I didn't catch that before I sent you to suggestions.
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
Well you do have a huge pile of different crap to talk about, any thread on all 10 topics is going to be cluttered as fuck.

1) Is a known limitation with the sim right now. The AI logic of how to move the defense if the QB was able to keep his throwing option open while threatening to run hasn't been figured out, so right now all it would do is screw defenses. It should be a project to be worked on, though, but until the defensive pathing is figured out it needs to remain as-is.

2) Pretty sure that's a build issue. QBs dropping back to pass don't have to find a path, they just are going to a spot - thus they don't change directions or anything. However, once they run, they've typically got amazing vision and crap for agility and speed, so they keep finding new paths but can't make the cuts. Tactics changes can help this, as can adding more agility/speed to your QB.

3) FB pathing is a current topic in bugs, isn't it?

4) Thought that was supposed to be fixed. I suspect in your case it's a build issue (not enough vision) but you could probably post a thread in bugs and get some feedback - either other people will not be having the problem, or it's still broken in the logic.

5) Adding pass interference means we have to rebalance the passing game all over again, so it's not trivial. What should trigger it? It's not like there's a logic in the AI right now that says "Hit the WR before the ball gets there and make it harder to catch the ball" that could be flagged as a penalty or something. Needs a lot more fleshing out before it's meaningful.

6, 7) Already tons of suggestions on making sliders per-play instead of per player. FWIW, QBs automatically adjust throw style to the play, they just shift to the direction of your slider from there.

8) Not until the D can man up CBs per WR, which....I think Bort said is coming with scouting tool improvements, eventually? Reply hazy, ask again later.

9) Short answer - no. Long answer - explain why it would be interesting if the offense could flip and the defense could flip in response. Most answers as to why this should be in are "because you can do it in real life" (but it won't change anything on the dotfield, just make dots run left instead of right or whatever), or because someone's trying to be exploitive against the D, which isn't going to fly. If you can make a good case of why it would add depth and not be just broken or pointless, someone will listen.

10) Dots already "hurry up" to the line. "Run out of bounds" is a damn tricky AI - people are going to be pissed they didn't go for the TD etc. Don't think the pathing AI could be worked out well enough to everyone's satisfaction, honestly, but if someone works it out, I bet Bort would add it in.
 
Rlurie
offline
Link
 
Thanks for the response...I'm not saying everything I would like added NEEDS to be added but I would like to atleast know that they're being discussed and are maybe "in the works"

I have no idea how the technology of this game works but I just assume the things I mentioned could be done if Bort wanted them.
 
Redrover
offline
Link
 
4) I always thought this was because everyone initially has a 3 yard cone where they look to block someone, which grows over time with vision. I never liked this because it means that LBs more than 3 yards off the line at the snap of the ball will usually be ignored and the center (in this case) will decide to double the NT instead of doing the obvious thing.

 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Redrover
4) I always thought this was because everyone initially has a 3 yard cone where they look to block someone, which grows over time with vision. I never liked this because it means that LBs more than 3 yards off the line at the snap of the ball will usually be ignored and the center (in this case) will decide to double the NT instead of doing the obvious thing.



There was this update in the changelog:
Originally posted by Changelog
March 3, 2010
- Allow C to switch to lead block downfield like G's can when he has no one to block


which means they're supposed to be able to just lead block like they were a FB or something if there's no one in front of them.
 
Link
 
The passing game needs help? Really? Just get more pump fake for your QB and chuck it long.
 
Link
 
more jumping imo
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1182085&pbp_id=12056074

Good example of the LG moving upfield; don't have one handy of a C doing it. I think the C is the first dot to pick a blocker on the line, though, so *usually* he'll have someone to block. It's only in weird cases where the dline was split really wide and the C used to just sit there and do nothing, instead of double up.
Anyways, vision checks are involved too, the C and the G can both screw up and think they're the only one going to block a guy and double-team when they shouldn't; also if the G is getting beat the C will go over to help out, so there's a lot going on that will keep a C inside. But at least he shouldn't be sitting there watching the RB go by anymore.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rlurie
= I can't have the Nickel 3-3-5 with the nickel corner playing either side?


you can kinda rig it to do this.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
i personally dont think we need to complicate the AI anymore by having certain pass settings for each play...not only that but it takes away that choice for the player himself imo. Half the time it doesn't even feel like the player is on the setting you choose anyways.
 
razor9
offline
Link
 
2) I'll bet the scrambling thing has to do with the QB's proximity to other players. Just like when you see some dots running down field and just because a defender is in the area of a blocker, he will seem to engage the blocker when he could easily have chased down the runner.

Since the dots have no arms, their little circle probably gets a radius around it that virtually extend the dot and plug up all the running lanes. Too many post game buffets for those fat linemen.
 
Link
 
Short simple answer: This game is designed and tested for lvl 70 dots and not the elite minors.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.