User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Southeast Asia AAA Leagues > Southeast Asia AAA #1 > Unbiased Power Rankings for week 2
Page:
 
frenchtoast
offline
Link
 
1.Neo Armstrong Cyclone Jet Armstrong Cannon
2.Bandar Lampung Pigskin Pirates
3.Manila Warlords
4.Tongduchon Cowboys
5.Springfield Atoms(T)
5.South Austin Bats(T)
7.Manila Tropics
8.Utopia Cobras
9.Montana Mercenaries
10.Pa Dong Dragons

Honorable Mention:
11.Awendaw Toadfish
12.Fukushima Samurai
13.Portland Dirty Penguins

Again, these are completely unbiased and based off of a formula that used points for, points against, current streak(even if you have one going from last season), and opponents record.

Please do not groan about these rankings, there is nothing i can do about it, i did not pick them.
 
joe
46 Defense
offline
Link
 
good work. dont agree total but really cool. So this is like what the BSC uses. I see why some are up in arms about the rankings.

thnks
frenchtoast
 
frenchtoast
offline
Link
 
I'll post point totals for after next game...
 
durakbane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by frenchtoast
I'll post point totals for after next game...


Your username makes me hungry.
 
darkflashfox
offline
Link
 
No offense, but I don't see how winning streak plays into power at all. Wins-Losses should be more accurate.
 
SmilinMatt
offline
Link
 
\o/ Honorable Mention
 
amo368
offline
Link
 
The formula will be a little off for the first few weeks until all teams have more stats to even out. I say after the 3rd game these rankings should be pretty good.

Good work French Toast!
Last edited Jun 14, 2008 17:58:48
 
Link
 
No way the Tropics and the Atoms are better than the Dragons and the Cobras.
 
stanley839
offline
Link
 
What kinda formula you guys use? Anybody mind posting it? It'd be cool to do something like this with other conferences.

Edit: BRB, making french toast.
Last edited Jun 14, 2008 20:15:00
 
frenchtoast
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by darkflashfox
No offense, but I don't see how winning streak plays into power at all. Wins-Losses should be more accurate.


Why wouldnt winning streak play a role? If someone is on a 38 game winning streak, and there arnt even 38 games in a season, they are pretty good.
 
James1985
offline
Link
 
I don't see how win/loss has anythink to do with "Power Rankings"

If a team losses to a #3 team but is still better than Number 4,5,6 he should still be ranked higher than 4,5,6.

Just saying. Because Pa Dong should not be 10th.

Other than our bad chemistry I think we are the best in Alpha hands down.
Last edited Jun 14, 2008 21:04:11
 
Link
 
Originally posted by darkflashfox
No offense, but I don't see how winning streak plays into power at all. Wins-Losses should be more accurate.


Well winning streak is taking care of the loses because if they are winning then they arent losing. So it would be the same. If we used losses then they still wouldnt be hurt. use this same formula in my league.
 
darkflashfox
offline
Link
 
Maybe, but this winning streak could be inflated by weaking competition, and since your Win-Loss forumla doesn't go all the way back to season 1, this skews the streak data.

If you had a team in SE A and it won 15 games in a row, before moving up to SE Pro via switch, your ranking system would make SE A team the preseason favorites, taking into account winning streak alone, even though the SE A pro teams, which lost matches because of tougher competition, are stronger.

In addition, there are teams who are gutted and lose the first 6 games, and then win the last x, but still miss the playoffs. According to your formula, the win streak would rank them higher than a team that just lost the final game of the season.

Honestly, if this were a thing based on pure numbers, the formula should use:

Avg starter level
Avg backup level
PA
PF
Opponents Winning % (although this stat would mean nothing in the last game, as ll team s play other teams at least once)
Winning %

None of the current BCS formulas uses winning streak. Win/Loss is instead factored, as only results from 1 season should matter. IF you argue that the past season matters, level should fix that, and you can use PA/PF from last year, even though that too is skewed by weaker competition.







 
darkflashfox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James1985
I don't see how win/loss has anythink to do with "Power Rankings"

If a team losses to a #3 team but is still better than Number 4,5,6 he should still be ranked higher than 4,5,6.

Just saying. Because Pa Dong should not be 10th.

Other than our bad chemistry I think we are the best in Alpha hands down.


Well, you do realize that this current ranking system still would rank another person lower, because a loss ranking of one, kills a winning streak, and would rank the team lower than a 4-5-6 that would have a higher winning streak...

Originally posted by mightymouse8335

Well winning streak is taking care of the loses because if they are winning then they arent losing. So it would be the same. If we used losses then they still wouldnt be hurt. use this same formula in my league.


True, but the difference is that this winning streak skews the data in favor of the teams that have moved up and are still winning. This whas an issue last year, as the Warriors were ranked #1, even though the Hot Mama's had a higher avg level, and other factors.

 
frenchtoast
offline
Link
 
Higher avg levels mean nothing in this game. The teams that have the better players dont always win. I think our formula is pretty solid. If you think your team deserves a higher rank, then too bad. Tell that to the spreadsheet i made.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.