User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Timeouts - When it is proper to call a timeout?
Page:
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
If you guys think you can improve the logic, go for it. It wouldn't be the first time we've changed the logic on them.


Going to open this up to the general community for some help. I ask that everyone remain as objective as possible. We're not looking for what you would do but rather what the average football coach would do (okay maybe not average, since clock management is not usually a strong suit ). You get the point.

I'll try to check in as much as I can, but most of my time spent on this will be this weekend as it looks like I'm going to be snowed in.

What specifically am I looking for?
- Nothing in terms of the suggestions department of hurry up modes, give power in the AI, etc. The goal of this thread is purely to update the current logic.
- Conditionals. Stipulations are obviously score, field position, time left in the half, etc. Don't need anything complex. Something along the lines of:
     IF
          On offense
          Score differential = -3 to 0
          Formation = Field Goal
          Clock = Running
          Time = 3 seconds
     THEN
          Call timeout


Also note that we need to cover every situation. No gaps or forgotten place to where a timeout would be appropriate.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
^5 for dyslexia in the thread title as well
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
I don't know what the hell you're trying to say.

If you are down by 2 or less and inside field goal range you should never call a timeout unless to stop the clock with 40 seconds or less remaining to kick a game winner.

Lets start with that
Edited by David Stern on Feb 24, 2010 15:11:32
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
I don't know what the hell you're trying to say.


I'll try and simplify it for you since it's a difficult concept.

1. The man known as Bort has given us the green light to fix the logic surrounding timeouts.

2. I've created this suggestion thread for users to help out with the project of developing the logic.

3. Everything substantial here will be relayed to the test server thread I have up and likewise through to the final proposal for Bort's eyes.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
If you are down by 2 or less and inside field goal range you should never call a timeout unless to stop the clock with 40 seconds or less remaining to kick a game winner.


Also, this is terrible logic, since if you are inside FG range, you are going to want the clock to trim down as low as possible (w/ 3 seconds being the optimal target). From what I'm reading from you, if I had the ball on the OPP 20, and I'm down by 2, you want me to call a timeout at 40 seconds as opposed to let it run down as far as possible.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Also, this is terrible logic, since if you are inside FG range, you are going to want the clock to trim down as low as possible (w/ 3 seconds being the optimal target). From what I'm reading from you, if I had the ball on the OPP 20, and I'm down by 2, you want me to call a timeout at 40 seconds as opposed to let it run down as far as possible.


I don't want the sim to think you can run a play with 40 seconds left I just want it to recognize how much time is left, and then kick a field goal as late as possible.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Also note that we need to cover every situation. No gaps or forgotten place to where a timeout would be appropriate.


Thanks Mat. Here we go. I appreciate you bringing this to Bort, and Bort being willing to take a look at it.
IMO timeout usage has been a glaring problem in the game for a long time. Extremely frustrating to the game's hard-working coordinators. (Even the lazy ones, really.)

All conditions below should result in a timeout.
All conditions assume the clock is running.

2nd Quarter, Offense, Time <= 45
Down = 1-2
Spot = Own 35 to Opp 10
Form = Offense*
TOL = 2+
2nd Quarter, Offense, Time <= 45
Down = 3
Spot = Own 35 to Opp 10
ToGo <= 10
Form = Offense
TOL = 2+
2nd Quarter, Offense, Time <= 30
Down = 1-3
Spot = Opp 10 to Opp G
Form = Offense
TOL = 2+
2nd Quarter, Offense, Time <= 30
Down = 4
Spot = Own 35 to Opp G
Form = Offense
2nd Quarter, Offense, Time <= 5
Spot = Opp 50 To Opp G

2nd Quarter, Defense, Time <= 60
Down = 3
ToGo > 10
Spot = Opp 30 to Opp G
TOL = 2+
2nd Quarter, Defense, Time <= 30
Down = 3
ToGo > 10
Spot = Opp 30 to Opp G
2nd Quarter, Defense, Time <= 60
Down = 4
ToGo > 1
Spot = Opp 30 to Opp G
2nd Quarter, Defense, Time <= 60
Down = 4
ToGo > 5
Spot = 50 to Opp G

4th Quarter, Offense, Time <= 45
Down = 1-3
Spot = Outside FG Range
Score = -7 to -1
TOL = 2+
4th Quarter, Offense, Time <= 45
Down = 1-2
Spot = Own 35 to Opp 10
Form = Offense
Score = -7 to 0
TOL = 2+
4th Quarter, Offense, Time <= 45
Down = 3
ToGo <= 10
Spot = Own 35 to Opp 10
Form = Offense
Score = -7 to 0
TOL = 2+
4th Quarter, Offense, Time <= 30
Down = 1-3
Spot = Opp 10 to Opp G
Form = Offense
Score = -7 to -3
TOL = 2+
4th Quarter, Offense, Time <= 30
Down = 4
Form = Offense
Score = -7 to -3
4th Quarter, Offense, Time <= 20
Down = 1-3
Score = -255 to -8
TOL = 3
4th Quarter, Offense, Time <= 15
Score = -255 to -8
TOL = 2+
4th Quarter, Offense, Time <= 15
Down = 1-3
Score = -2 to 0
TOL = 2+
4th Quarter, Offense, Time <= 5
Spot = 50 to Opp G
Score = 0
4th Quarter, Offense, Time <= 5
Score < 0

4th Quarter, Defense, Time <= 120
Score < 0
4th Quarter, Defense, Time <= 60
Down = 3
ToGo > 10
Spot = Opp 30 to Opp G
Score = 0
4th Quarter, Defense, Time <= 60
Down = 4
ToGo > 1
Spot = Opp 30 to Opp G
Score = 0
TOL = 2+
4th Quarter, Defense, Time <= 60
Down = 4
ToGo > 5
Score = 0 just added 11/16/2010... forgot this line originally
Spot = 50 to Opp G
4th Quarter, Defense, Time = 5-40
Down = 4
Spot = Opponent in FG Range
Score = 0 to 2
OPP-TOL >= 1

*Form = Offense means any offense output. Run, pass, or spike; Not field goal or punt.
Edited by TrevJo on Nov 16, 2010 21:33:29
Edited by TrevJo on Feb 25, 2010 12:24:03
Edited by TrevJo on Feb 25, 2010 12:18:30
Edited by TrevJo on Feb 25, 2010 12:16:31
Edited by TrevJo on Feb 24, 2010 22:59:27
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Thanks TrevJo, I'll look at this later when I have time.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Great!
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
late in the half, or game, i would have the AI pick its play, and if the play picked is a FG, then run the clock to 3 secs b4 calling TO.

on defense, when you are down by more than say 21 pts, dont call TO.

i would not call any TO until less than 1 minute left.

if you are inside the opp's 10, do not call any TO until under 25 secs. (i think most plays run in 7-8 secs)

part of what needs to be looked at too is how it is determined how much time runs off for a play. why in 1 game does a play take 38 secs, and the next game 21 for what looks like a similar play? its hard to make guidelines for calling a TO when the length of the plays vary by such a large degree. i try to do the FG at the end of a half and still havent figured out the right time to get the FG play called. i've seen a short play eat up to 46 secs which is just insane at the end of a half. in other games, i may have run off 3 plays in that same time.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
late in the half, or game, i would have the AI pick its play, and if the play picked is a FG, then run the clock to 3 secs b4 calling TO.

if you are inside the opp's 10, do not call any TO until under 25 secs. (i think most plays run in 7-8 secs)


Please review the rules I proposed. They account for these situations. Unless I missed something, they should account for all situations.

Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
on defense, when you are down by more than say 21 pts, dont call TO.

i would not call any TO until less than 1 minute left.


I don't agree with either of these suggestions in terms of defensive timeouts.

Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
part of what needs to be looked at too is how it is determined how much time runs off for a play. why in 1 game does a play take 38 secs, and the next game 21 for what looks like a similar play? its hard to make guidelines for calling a TO when the length of the plays vary by such a large degree. i try to do the FG at the end of a half and still havent figured out the right time to get the FG play called. i've seen a short play eat up to 46 secs which is just insane at the end of a half. in other games, i may have run off 3 plays in that same time.

Please review what it is that Mat wants out of this thread. Originally posted by Mat McBriar
What specifically am I looking for?
- Nothing in terms of the suggestions department of hurry up modes, give power in the AI, etc.
- Conditionals. Stipulations are obviously score, field position, time left in the half, etc. Don't need anything complex. Something along the lines of:
Also note that we need to cover every situation. No gaps or forgotten place to where a timeout would be appropriate.
Edited by TrevJo on Mar 5, 2010 15:13:18
Edited by TrevJo on Mar 5, 2010 15:09:20
Edited by TrevJo on Mar 5, 2010 15:07:37
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo

Originally posted by Guppy, Inc

on defense, when you are down by more than say 21 pts, dont call TO.

i would not call any TO until less than 1 minute left.


I don't agree with either of these suggestions in terms of defensive timeouts.


2nd one wasnt meant for the defensive side, but i wasnt clear that the 2 ideas were standalone and separate. but the 1st one makes sense for late in the game. if you are already losing by 21, odds are that you were just out played and calling TO does nothing but give the winning team more time to score. maybe 21 is too low, but some reasonable score should be used. again this is supposed to be what the average coach would do, and 21 pts down w/o the ball and under 2 minutes, i believe the average coach throws in the towel.

Originally posted by TrevJo
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc

part of what needs to be looked at too is how it is determined how much time runs off for a play. why in 1 game does a play take 38 secs, and the next game 21 for what looks like a similar play? its hard to make guidelines for calling a TO when the length of the plays vary by such a large degree. i try to do the FG at the end of a half and still havent figured out the right time to get the FG play called. i've seen a short play eat up to 46 secs which is just insane at the end of a half. in other games, i may have run off 3 plays in that same time.

Please review what it is that Mat wants out of this thread. Originally posted by Mat McBriar

What specifically am I looking for?
- Nothing in terms of the suggestions department of hurry up modes, give power in the AI, etc.

if a play can take between 12 and 48 secs, it'll be impossible to make a set of TO rules that will work. if a play takes the 48 secs, we need to call TO early. if plays are going to take 12 secs, we need to call them later.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Any traction on a timeout system change being implemented for season 15?
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Any traction on a timeout system change being implemented for season 15?


 
Johnnyboyfo
offline
Link
 
This isnt epic?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.