User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > Scouting Messed Up - ARCHIVED #4
Page:
 
Grr8WhiteHype
offline
Link
 
So I am scouting a Pee-Wee team that I OC to see what plays have been working best. Problem is all the stats and stuff are wrong when I scout the offense. According to the scouting page I have called 135 pass plays (that is correct) and have gains on 94 (not correct). The percentage it shows is 70%. In reality my QB's have completed just 69 passes out of 130 pass attempts. That is just over 53%.

I have double and triple checked and re-run the scout multiple times but get the same thing. I only select the regular season games (Tampa Bay, Baltimore, Baghdad, Dirty Dogz and Pee Wee).
Edited by Catch22 on Jun 2, 2010 21:58:52
Edited by Sik Wit It on Mar 12, 2010 12:22:19 (needs QA - Sik)
Edited by Catch22 on Feb 24, 2010 08:20:46
Edited by Hikariu on Feb 22, 2010 10:08:01
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
The scouting tools is known to have errors. I'm suggesting that catch do a sandbox test of the tool to get these things either hashed out or explain to us what the scouting tool count exactly.
 
Eamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hikariu
The scouting tools is known to have errors. I'm suggesting that catch do a sandbox test of the tool to get these things either hashed out or explain to us what the scouting tool count exactly.


This. Either disable it or get it working IMO. I do like the Roster Scouting Page, but stopped using Offense/Defense after one or two uses.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
We need more info. What is the scouting tool incorrectly adding or not adding in. Bugs Mods need to go through and look at a game and provide some data.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
The thread Scouting Errors - QB Spike for 43 yds has been merged into this thread
 
raiderdav
offline
Link
 
Since the admins want/need more info on why scouting sucks and can't be trusted, here's another example.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=1397&m=offense&for_team_id=0
Check the box for Tranmere Spartans, click Analyze and click the QB Rush filter.

QB Spike called 4 times for 43 yards.

Greatest QB Spike play ever.
 
Gongadan
offline
Link
 
oh em eff gee, ell oh ell.

My best guess? It's building scouting data based on the play intended to be called by the AI--this team probably tried to call QB spikes when there were > 2 minutes left in whichever half it was in, so GLB forced them to substitute another play instead.

1) It should build scouting data on the play actually called, regardless of what was in the OAI
2) QB spike should count as a pass if anything, not a rush
 
raiderdav
offline
Link
 
Thanks for moving the thread - wasn't sure if separate threads would be better for specific bugs.

Originally posted by Catch22
We need more info. What is the scouting tool incorrectly adding or not adding in. Bugs Mods need to go through and look at a game and provide some data.


I don't think this approach is going to identify many of the issues since it is relying on random observations. We've identified that there are real problems with the Scouting tool. Someone needs to write a script that will allow for some bulk analysis of the scouting outputs in comparison to the Play By Play and Box Scores. I would imagine a couple of the greasemonkey scripts could be re-used for that purpose.

 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
The thread Scouting page stats don' t match game summary stats - NEEDS MORE INFO has been merged into this thread
 
fogie55
offline
Link
 
Please tell me I've made a huge mistake somewhere; I've been making plans based on things I've discovered aren't true. I've tried disabling greasemonkey, clearing the Firefox cache but still I get these odd stats that don't match up

Game summaries
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1072710
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1072711

Scout page
http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=7803&m=offense&for_team_id=7681
 
SexyNinja
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=7755&m=offense&for_team_id=0 (from their team page)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=7803&m=offense&for_team_id=0 (from your team page)

Try that, I think you have to go to their team stats, but yeah seems off a bit
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
if you want our help, please be specific. what stats are not matching up?
 
redskins2121
offline
Link
 
there have been many issues with the scouting page. Personally I don't even use it because i don't want to screw up my game planning
 
Link
 
I'm guessing they were relying on the top play calls.
General play count 19 rush calls - 45 pass calls
While in the "top play calls" only 9 runs are shown, and 34 passes. To get the full story you still need to watch all the replays, which kind of makes the scouting tool worthless Personally I wish I could just click a couple buttons and get the full story instead of wasting hours watching film of a team I'm not even on.

I stopped using this aspect of the scouting tool right when it first came out because it didn't add up.
 
Baustin
offline
Link
 
It's still doing that thing where it's counting rushes as passing gains. In the second game there were only 20/43 completions for 243 yds, but the scout tool is showing 27 gains, 42 attempts, for 323 yds. It also added 5 yds to the rushing total, but that's most likely compounded rounding errors.

At the beginning of the season it seemed as if it were working correctly, but the deeper in to the season we go, the worse it gets.

The stats being wrong on the game page a decent amount of the time don't make it easy to figure out what the exact problem is.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.