User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Make weight not such a gigantic factor in realized speed
Page:
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Funny story, when I created Valhalla I did not know that weight was a significant factor in speed. I believed Bort when he said something like "it doesn't make a big difference". When I created Ed O'brien, who led the WL in receiving yards last season and was the WL championship MVP, I totally lucked out when I rolled 183 pounds and stuck with it.

The fact is, if he weighed 15 more pounds, he would be below average. There's no way he would have all those trophies and there's even a good chance that Valhalla wouldn't have won our championship last season. That is the difference 15 pounds makes on a WR.

A 180 pound WR with 118 speed is faster than a 200 pound WR with 130 speed. You know how many SP it takes to get your final speed from 118 to 130 on a WR? Around 8-14 levels depending on build method and EQ. Should 10% of a players weight really be worth 10 levels?

WR is just the most obvious example. This affects every position where speed is important. It makes a huge difference on HBs, as well as many defensive players. It is impossible to have an elite elusive HB without him being in the 180-185 pound range, and it's even best for power HBs as well since the increased speed from less weight more than makes up for the slight decrease in broken tackles. Does it make any sense that the best weight for a power HB is the minimum weight?

In real life, weight is not that important in determining speed. For example, the past 3 world record holders in the 100M dash have a 32 pound spread. There are many players in the NFL with world class quickness who are over 225 pounds. The degree to which actual speed and weight are tied in this game is extremely unrealistic and arbitrary.
Edited by w_alloy on Feb 1, 2010 16:34:28
Edited by w_alloy on Feb 1, 2010 16:22:27
 
Ocho_CinCo
offline
Link
 
X-Factor ldo
 
mwindle
offline
Link
 
I have no personal knowledge of this. But if it's true then the OP is completely right. It should be more position by position. Wt shouldn't effect a WR SPD. Maybe there should be no effect until you get to 225 or 230 lbs or so. You are right the fastest NFL players are anywhere from the lightest up to 225-230lbs. YOu have quite a few HBs and Ss and big WRs that are the fastest guy on their team that get up around 225 lbs. Granted it's usually a 190 lb to 200 lb WR, CB, or S. But it shouldn't have much effect either way
 
maizenhops
offline
Link
 
Agree completely.
 
Outlaw Dogs
offline
Link
 
+1
 
RandomBeast
offline
Link
 
+1000 (and not just because all my dots turned out to be fat )
Edited by RandomBeast on Feb 1, 2010 17:59:16
 
SeattleNiner
NINERS
offline
Link
 
IMO weight should be a big part of acceleration, because it takes more energy to get a heavier object up to speed....but there really shouldn't be a speed limit for a heavier player.

Ideally, a really huge guy should have the potential to reach the same speed as a lighter one, but he should expend more energy in getting there, so maybe it takes 20 yards to reach his max but after that he starts to get gassed and loses speed? Would make stamina more valuable for heavier payers...
 
tordman
offline
Link
 
Lol, height and weight weren't a significant factor until people on the forums demanded it should be.

Now that it is a factor, people are whining that it is too much of a factor.

I could care less either way, but don't ask for something if you aren't ready to accept the consequences.
 
SikoraP13 DTD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SeattleNiner
IMO weight should be a big part of acceleration, because it takes more energy to get a heavier object up to speed....but there really shouldn't be a speed limit for a heavier player.

Ideally, a really huge guy should have the potential to reach the same speed as a lighter one, but he should expend more energy in getting there, so maybe it takes 20 yards to reach his max but after that he starts to get gassed and loses speed? Would make stamina more valuable for heavier payers...


this is a great idea, imo
 
GosuPho
offline
Link
 
Vroom Vroom +1
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tordman
Lol, height and weight weren't a significant factor until people on the forums demanded it should be.

Now that it is a factor, people are whining that it is too much of a factor.

I could care less either way, but don't ask for something if you aren't ready to accept the consequences.


Firstly, "people on the forums" are not a single entity, a fact which you must be forgetting when you say something as dumb as "don't ask for something if you aren't ready to accept the consequences".

And the problem is not with weight affecting acceleration/speed, as I think it should, but the fact that it currently affects it about five times as much as it should.
 
Barnzie
offline
Link
 
To a certain point weight can help speed. Perhaps the effect should be a non-linear scale increasing from 200-205lbs+.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Barnzie
To a certain point weight can help speed. Perhaps the effect should be a non-linear scale increasing from 200-205lbs+.


I agree. Although I think speed is closer to 195-200 and quickness (acceleration or direction changing over a small distance) I'd put around 175. Also weight should affect quickness more than top speed.
 
Boogie21
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
Originally posted by tordman

Lol, height and weight weren't a significant factor until people on the forums demanded it should be.

Now that it is a factor, people are whining that it is too much of a factor.

I could care less either way, but don't ask for something if you aren't ready to accept the consequences.


Firstly, "people on the forums" are not a single entity, a fact which you must be forgetting when you say something as dumb as "don't ask for something if you aren't ready to accept the consequences".

And the problem is not with weight affecting acceleration/speed, as I think it should, but the fact that it currently affects it about five times as much as it should.


+1
 
Mad LBer 41
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Boogie21
Originally posted by w_alloy

Originally posted by tordman


Lol, height and weight weren't a significant factor until people on the forums demanded it should be.

Now that it is a factor, people are whining that it is too much of a factor.

I could care less either way, but don't ask for something if you aren't ready to accept the consequences.



And the problem is not with weight affecting acceleration/speed, as I think it should, but the fact that it currently affects it about five times as much as it should.


+1

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.