Each point in strength is not worth 20+ SP past 100. The current system rewards high attribute values more than is reasonable. One way to make total SP values more comparable across positions and (much more importantly) more accurate to the performance level a player is playing at is to start partially discounting SP values once certain high caps are reached.
One way this could be accomplished is by every extra cap after 5:1 only being worth 50% extra and every cap after 10:1 being worth 25% extra. So going from 75 to 76 would raise it 5 like normal, but going from 79 to 80 (during the 6:1 cap) would raise the SP score 5.5. Going from 86 to 87 (during the 9:1 cap) would raise the score by 7 (5 + 50% of 4). Going from 100 to 101 (during the 20:1 cap) would raise the score by 10 (5 + 50% of 5 + 25% of 10).
This could also be adjusted with lower limits before attribute SP values are discounted for lower level players. For example, a low level C who went straight to the 5th cap with strength and has done nothing else so far would have a high score, but wouldn't actually be very good. Lowering the discounting limits for lower level players would help adjust for these imbalanced builds.
Obviously the details could be worked out a bit, and probably a continuous formula without the need for arbitrary steps would be best, but I think this basic idea would unquestionably add to the effectiveness of total SP numbers at accurately identifying what level a dot is actually playing at.
One way this could be accomplished is by every extra cap after 5:1 only being worth 50% extra and every cap after 10:1 being worth 25% extra. So going from 75 to 76 would raise it 5 like normal, but going from 79 to 80 (during the 6:1 cap) would raise the SP score 5.5. Going from 86 to 87 (during the 9:1 cap) would raise the score by 7 (5 + 50% of 4). Going from 100 to 101 (during the 20:1 cap) would raise the score by 10 (5 + 50% of 5 + 25% of 10).
This could also be adjusted with lower limits before attribute SP values are discounted for lower level players. For example, a low level C who went straight to the 5th cap with strength and has done nothing else so far would have a high score, but wouldn't actually be very good. Lowering the discounting limits for lower level players would help adjust for these imbalanced builds.
Obviously the details could be worked out a bit, and probably a continuous formula without the need for arbitrary steps would be best, but I think this basic idea would unquestionably add to the effectiveness of total SP numbers at accurately identifying what level a dot is actually playing at.
Edited by w_alloy on Jan 30, 2010 20:28:37
Edited by w_alloy on Jan 30, 2010 20:22:09






























