User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Easier Promotion out of the Minors and into AA.
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
As I understand it, there is a real lack of AA teams, so AA leagues are filled with CPUs. With the current minor league promotion system, this problem is only going to get worse.

As it stands, you have to win a cap 42 championship or be a cap 46 playoff team to get promoted to AA. I believe Bort is also going to move all of the Uncapped Minors into AA as well. There are 5 Uncapped Minors leagues, 5 cap 46 leagues, and 6 cap 42 leagues. That is 160 teams from Uncapped Minors, 80 from cap 46 playoff teams, and up to 12 from the cap 42 champions, so 240 - 252 teams.

There are currently ~274 CPUs in AA (yes, I went and counted them) + however many teams have been sold in the AAA/Pros + however many teams will request a demotion to the minors for a rebuild...all that need to be replaced.

Looking past this season, there will only by 80 - 92 teams moving up to AA every season with the current system in place. That is less than 3 teams per AA league.

My suggestion to fix all this is simple. Remove the logjam at cap 46 and allow non-playoff cap 46 teams, playoff 42 teams, and champion 38 teams promote into AA, just like if it were the next cap in the ladder. As of this season, that would add 70 teams from cap 46, 70 teams from cap 42, and up to 12 teams from cap 38. That is an additional 140 - 152 teams to help fill in the gaps.

Going forward, that would make it 220 - 240 teams going up every season, or ~7 teams per league. Given the rate of voluntary promotion, that seems like a much more reasonable number.

I know some cap 42 and cap 46 teams may not want to go to AA, so as a compromise, perhaps it could be an option granted. Personally, I want my team in AA as soon as possible, since our goal is the Pros, not Minor league gold. However, I understand that there are more than one way to play the game, so I can see a case for making it voluntary. However, right now, there are no choices. We just have a cap 46 logjam.
 
Link
 
I think you can just PM support. I have a buddy who did last season.
 
Link
 
Of course the problem is...the AAs would often start to look like cap 46s because there are not that many higher level guys out there I think to support all the teams that would then be AA. Just a thought I had.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MarkTaylorTSax
I think you can just PM support. I have a buddy who did last season.


That is how they had the 2 or 3 cap promotions for champion teams last season, but alot of people were unaware that PMing support was necessary or an option. Simply allowing those teams to select AA in the current system should be a simple fix that would not require alot of unnecessary Support cases.
 
spartans72
offline
Link
 
Bort did put a call out. It doesn't get any easier than clicking support and it was in one of the announcements. It doesn't need to be any easier than that.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/announcement.pl?id=263

Second paragraph.
 
CoachCoughlin
offline
Link
 
Everyone, join AA! Only two levels from the Pros!
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by spartans72
Bort did put a call out. It doesn't get any easier than clicking support and it was in one of the announcements. It doesn't need to be any easier than that.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/announcement.pl?id=263

Second paragraph.


We'll see. My solution doesn't require a "call out" every season and allows for more teams to enter AA every season and fill in the demotions, but maybe people will stop demoting so fast that we have 19 cap 14 leagues and 274 CPUs just in AA . If so, we won't need more than 80 to 90 teams to move up.

It's kind of funny. I suggested the link on the team page for 2 or 3 cap promotions on day 43 of last season ( http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3503068 ) and got about the same response to that suggestion as I am getting to this one. I guess it wasn't such a bad suggestion after all, since Bort did it. Maybe this one will do as well.
Edited by Plankton on Jan 17, 2010 22:32:09
Edited by Plankton on Jan 17, 2010 22:31:20
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
As I understand it, there is a real lack of AA teams, so AA leagues are filled with CPUs. With the current minor league promotion system, this problem is only going to get worse.

As it stands, you have to win a cap 42 championship or be a cap 46 playoff team to get promoted to AA. I believe Bort is also going to move all of the Uncapped Minors into AA as well. There are 5 Uncapped Minors leagues, 5 cap 46 leagues, and 6 cap 42 leagues. That is 160 teams from Uncapped Minors, 80 from cap 46 playoff teams, and up to 12 from the cap 42 champions, so 240 - 252 teams.

There are currently ~274 CPUs in AA (yes, I went and counted them) + however many teams have been sold in the AAA/Pros + however many teams will request a demotion to the minors for a rebuild...all that need to be replaced.

Looking past this season, there will only by 80 - 92 teams moving up to AA every season with the current system in place. That is less than 3 teams per AA league.

My suggestion to fix all this is simple. Remove the logjam at cap 46 and allow non-playoff cap 46 teams, playoff 42 teams, and champion 38 teams promote into AA, just like if it were the next cap in the ladder. As of this season, that would add 70 teams from cap 46, 70 teams from cap 42, and up to 12 teams from cap 38. That is an additional 140 - 152 teams to help fill in the gaps.

Going forward, that would make it 220 - 240 teams going up every season, or ~7 teams per league. Given the rate of voluntary promotion, that seems like a much more reasonable number.

I know some cap 42 and cap 46 teams may not want to go to AA, so as a compromise, perhaps it could be an option granted. Personally, I want my team in AA as soon as possible, since our goal is the Pros, not Minor league gold. However, I understand that there are more than one way to play the game, so I can see a case for making it voluntary. However, right now, there are no choices. We just have a cap 46 logjam.


I would go one further and say just move all the cap 42 and 46 teams up to AA, make it mandatory and non-negotiable. The original stated purpose of the cloud league was to make it easier to remove gutjobs and CPUs from the pyramid. I can understand that some teams might not want the extra promotion but for the pyramid to work it needs to have a big influx of human owned competitive teams. The only way I see that happening is to bring up enough teams to populate it each season, even if that means we contract the cloud a bit.
 
Jaxon Voom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by spartans72
Bort did put a call out. It doesn't get any easier than clicking support and it was in one of the announcements. It doesn't need to be any easier than that.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/announcement.pl?id=263

Second paragraph.


Yep, more people need to man up and take the jump to AA.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
I would go one further and say just move all the cap 42 and 46 teams up to AA, make it mandatory and non-negotiable. The original stated purpose of the cloud league was to make it easier to remove gutjobs and CPUs from the pyramid. I can understand that some teams might not want the extra promotion but for the pyramid to work it needs to have a big influx of human owned competitive teams. The only way I see that happening is to bring up enough teams to populate it each season, even if that means we contract the cloud a bit.


That would be fine with me.


I did some more math. If you assume that every season we have 6 cap 42 leagues and 6 cap 38 leagues (like we do now), then with the current system, there are ~275 teams that will be promoted to cap 46 every season. Every cap 46 league will promote 16 teams to AA, so we will add cap 46 leagues until we have at least 17 leagues. Once there are 17 cap 46 leagues, the promotion out of cap 46 will equal the promotions into cap 46. Let me repeat that....the number of cap 46 leagues will grow until there are 17 cap 46 leagues before an equilibrium is reached between promotions out and promotions in.

Why would we want 17 cap 46 leagues instead of having most of those teams in AA?
Edited by Plankton on Jan 18, 2010 08:34:29
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
As I understand it, there is a real lack of AA teams, so AA leagues are filled with CPUs. With the current minor league promotion system, this problem is only going to get worse.

As it stands, you have to win a cap 42 championship or be a cap 46 playoff team to get promoted to AA. I believe Bort is also going to move all of the Uncapped Minors into AA as well. There are 5 Uncapped Minors leagues, 5 cap 46 leagues, and 6 cap 42 leagues. That is 160 teams from Uncapped Minors, 80 from cap 46 playoff teams, and up to 12 from the cap 42 champions, so 240 - 252 teams.

There are currently ~274 CPUs in AA (yes, I went and counted them) + however many teams have been sold in the AAA/Pros + however many teams will request a demotion to the minors for a rebuild...all that need to be replaced.

Looking past this season, there will only by 80 - 92 teams moving up to AA every season with the current system in place. That is less than 3 teams per AA league.

My suggestion to fix all this is simple. Remove the logjam at cap 46 and allow non-playoff cap 46 teams, playoff 42 teams, and champion 38 teams promote into AA, just like if it were the next cap in the ladder. As of this season, that would add 70 teams from cap 46, 70 teams from cap 42, and up to 12 teams from cap 38. That is an additional 140 - 152 teams to help fill in the gaps.

Going forward, that would make it 220 - 240 teams going up every season, or ~7 teams per league. Given the rate of voluntary promotion, that seems like a much more reasonable number.

I know some cap 42 and cap 46 teams may not want to go to AA, so as a compromise, perhaps it could be an option granted. Personally, I want my team in AA as soon as possible, since our goal is the Pros, not Minor league gold. However, I understand that there are more than one way to play the game, so I can see a case for making it voluntary. However, right now, there are no choices. We just have a cap 46 logjam.


I think the uncapped minors are supposed to go away, which means all UM, all level 46, and all playoff level 42 capped teams should be heading to AA next season
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by reddogrw
I think the uncapped minors are supposed to go away, which means all UM, all level 46, and all playoff level 42 capped teams should be heading to AA next season


Go look at the playoff cap 42 teams and tell me where they are going, according to their team pages. Here, I'll save you some time. This is a 2nd place team from a cap 42 league. http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=4948 Per the link, they are going to cap 46. What you are saying, is how I thought it works, but not what appears to be in place. Thus, I am suggesting that it work that way.

Heck, just look at your co-owned cap 42 team...http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=5659.

All I can say is, when you are not in AA, but are in cap 46, don't say I didn't warn you. I am trying to get some attention to this before the teams are moved for season 14 and it is too late.
Edited by Plankton on Jan 18, 2010 17:29:17
Edited by Plankton on Jan 18, 2010 17:29:05
Edited by Plankton on Jan 18, 2010 17:28:17
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.