User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > CB decides to allow TD instead of tackling - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=923408&pbp_id=15424569

CB3, I Hate You, could of stopped the WR from scoring a TD at teh 2-4 yd line but instead turns away like he just wanted to escort the WR.
Edited by VolBrian on Jun 4, 2010 15:03:37 (Forum Cleanup)
Edited by thehazyone on Jan 6, 2010 21:06:32 (annotating BUG FILED)
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
I think that was the result of a head fake.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
That's ridiculous. Unless by "head fake" you mean "his head turned into that of Medusa, causing the defender to turn away," there's no way he should have reacted like that.
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
in that situation the CB should be aiming for the sideline and not worry about the inside cut, the inside cut and the pursuit will catch him (or he'll be able to get him)

but the problem is, dots can't think
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
That's ridiculous. Unless by "head fake" you mean "his head turned into that of Medusa, causing the defender to turn away," there's no way he should have reacted like that.


My best guess at the way a head fake or a juke works(might be either or, neither show up in the PBP), is that when it is successful it causes a vision check (probably with a penalty). If the defenders fail the vision check, they "think" the Ball Carrier is moving in another direction. This causes them to change their angle of attack to compensate, while the Ball Carrier merrily keeps going on his way.

Bort has never stated the exact mechanic behind jukes and head fakes, and probably never will.

Something happened to cause the players to change direction. It may be a bug, or it may be an intended effect of a mechanic we are not privy to. In the past Bort has looked at these kinds of things, and said that it was a juke or a fake.

 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chysil
in that situation the CB should be aiming for the sideline and not worry about the inside cut, the inside cut and the pursuit will catch him (or he'll be able to get him)

but the problem is, dots can't think


At that point you are getting into enhancements in the pursuit angle logic. There are plenty of examples of bad pursuit angles in every level of football. And I am pretty sure that if you watch enough football, you will see a Ball Carrier who is along the sidelines fake an inside move, to cause the defender to pause, then continue down the sidelines.

My point being is that I believe that it is currently working as Bort intended it to, and if that is not perfect, then he is more than willing to take suggestions on how to improve it. There is a whole forum just for that.
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
Looked like a stiff arm
 
-AB-
offline
Link
 
looked like a typical sim bug
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by TrevJo

That's ridiculous. Unless by "head fake" you mean "his head turned into that of Medusa, causing the defender to turn away," there's no way he should have reacted like that.


My best guess at the way a head fake or a juke works(might be either or, neither show up in the PBP), is that when it is successful it causes a vision check (probably with a penalty). If the defenders fail the vision check, they "think" the Ball Carrier is moving in another direction. This causes them to change their angle of attack to compensate, while the Ball Carrier merrily keeps going on his way.

Bort has never stated the exact mechanic behind jukes and head fakes, and probably never will.

Something happened to cause the players to change direction. It may be a bug, or it may be an intended effect of a mechanic we are not privy to. In the past Bort has looked at these kinds of things, and said that it was a juke or a fake.


I won't disagree with that theory on fake mechanics, and I would even agree that maybe a fake is what happened on this play, but my point is, I don't care what direction the CB thinks the WR is going, it makes no sense to move that direction. The runner is directly to his outside, so where could the runner possibly go that would make the defender think he needs to move to the inside?

I wonder if Snake is right about it being a stiff arm. But, it doesn't say stiff arm in the PBP output.
Edited by TrevJo on Jan 5, 2010 14:19:01
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by abfootball
looked like a typical sim bug


+1
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
At that point you are getting into enhancements in the pursuit angle logic. There are plenty of examples of bad pursuit angles in every level of football. And I am pretty sure that if you watch enough football, you will see a Ball Carrier who is along the sidelines fake an inside move, to cause the defender to pause, then continue down the sidelines.


However, pausing, then continuing down the sidelines, is not what the defender did in this replay. He started running inside (away from the runner) at the 4 yard line, and was still running away from him at the goal line 5 ticks later.
Edited by TrevJo on Jan 5, 2010 14:17:04
 
-AB-
offline
Link
 
OBJECTION!

Your Honor!

How can it be a head fake... When coach said always watch the runners feet not there head... So I can't get head faked if I'm not watching his head.... Fix this add a tactic to where your looking when running someone down or something like that....
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
However, pausing, then continuing down the sidelines, is not what the defender did in this replay. He started running inside (away from the runner) at the 4 yard line, and was still running away from him at the goal line 5 ticks later.


Really Really Good Fake?

Ok, now am being serious.

What I am trying to do now is use deductive reasoning.

7 defenders were going after the Ball Carrier. Out of those 7 defenders, only 1 had an angle that would cut off the WR.

So if we eliminate the 6 defenders who had no shot, we are left with a 1 on 1 match up, that the CB looses, possibly to a fake. The other 7 defenders look like they react to some degree in the same way, but most of them not as severely as the CB in question.

So the question becomes, is it a bug? Or is it a particular build? The answer is: I don't know. But without more information, more similar cases, we have nothing to build on. It just goes down as a strange occurrence.

I'll leave it open in case we can build some more examples. The more examples we get, the more likely it is that we can pin point the issue.


 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
So the question becomes, is it a bug? Or is it a particular build? The answer is: I don't know. But without more information, more similar cases, we have nothing to build on. It just goes down as a strange occurrence.


I agree that there is probably nothing that can be done with a single instance, I just hope that we can agree that it is indeed strange and not reasonable behavior.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by TrevJo

That's ridiculous. Unless by "head fake" you mean "his head turned into that of Medusa, causing the defender to turn away," there's no way he should have reacted like that.


My best guess at the way a head fake or a juke works(might be either or, neither show up in the PBP), is that when it is successful it causes a vision check (probably with a penalty). If the defenders fail the vision check, they "think" the Ball Carrier is moving in another direction. This causes them to change their angle of attack to compensate, while the Ball Carrier merrily keeps going on his way.





I could almost buy that, if the defender didn't take a sharp U-Turn. Still, might be right and it was a fake but the logic behind the defender is buggy as hell in the way he reacted. I always thought that the fakes made your dot shrink and pause for a tick or two, not change directions.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.