Currently Problem:
You've heard it a million different times from probably a million different people, but the league parity in the game is fairly poor. There's a lot of reasons, from power house teams with very good rosters and game plans that run away with things, to league littered with CPU or gut job teams leading to lots of "free wins" for a lot of teams. The promotion system also allows for some teams to exploit level caps or out level other teams giving them an unfair advantage. Something to make more games competitive, and also keep teams from getting unfair level advantages over other teams in the league.
Proposed Solution:
Keep all the same level caps, however add 1 Gold league, as well as Silver and Copper leagues to each level cap.
At level 14 (would be only silver and copper). Copper leagues would consist of all gut job teams, teams with heavy CPU, teams that have a very low average level etc (aka the games that are usually triggering the max xp mode now). All other teams would be placed in the silver leagues.
end of season (when promotions are processed) you would be placed in whatever cap fit your team best (aka the lowest cap your highest level player can fit into). Gold would consist of the conference winning teams (and good playoff teams from previous gold leagues). Silver leagues would be filled out by the rest, copper leagues would be the people that performed very poorly in silver leagues, teams that are CPU etc.
At season rollover (before you schedules are released) another round of demotions from the silver leagues to remove teams that have low scouting bars, significantly lower level averages, or significantly hurting rosters (number of players). The silver leagues would then be condensed and the highest number league removed to fill all the holes that the demotion round created.
What you get: you get competitive games throughout the season (far less blowouts), bragging rights for the good teams, no worries about level cap exploitation, and keep the teams that are going to get blown out by normal teams in a league of their own.
To prevent exploitation:
The main thing we need to worry about is teams getting into lower tiers in an attempt to get more money via playoff ticket sales etc. There are a few things you can do to prevent this.
Scaling bonus money (higher cap = higher money) given to all teams making it into a gold league. This would be to compensated them for playing in a harder league and possibly missing the playoffs when they'd easily make the playoffs in silver leagues.
Winners of gold leagues would be given a specially designed trophy, with "XX Cap Champions" to reward them as being the cream of the crop of their level.
Copper leagues would get small penalties to ticket sales (tickets sell for less) to prevent teams from trying to move to copper leagues to reap playoff ticket sales.
Fan support - Gold would gain additional fan support per win and a little more forgiving when dealing with losing fan support. Conversely copper leagues would gain fan support slower and lose fan support quicker than normal.
Additional League Structure to Promote Rivalries:
It would also be nice if you stayed in the same silver # league (as best as possible), allowing you to see a lot of familiar faces each season, build up some rivalries and have more fun. So if you were in silver #3 for 18 cap, and after the season you were moved to the 30 cap, you go to silver #3 for 30 cap (provided you are not promoted to gold or demoted to copper).
Efforts would be made to keep you in the same conference as well, in order to promote conference vs conference rivalries, and to allow you to get a much better shot at playing your in conference rivals in non scrimmage games.
Quotes and Additional Discussion:
Will be added as people post their comments.
Originally posted by PackMan97
Gold - More local/national endorsements per team (only the in-season stuff, still just one MVP that carries over to next season) (Added later: coupled with upping the amount of active enforcements per team)
Copper - No endorsements at all, no MVP either
Fan Support - significantly higher fan support floor for Gold
Ticket Sales - much easier in gold, very hard in copper
Gold - While I think more national would be nice, the 3 per team cap makes me think additional locals would be unneeded.
Copper - Like the idea, maybe just reduced, since they don't benefit the team as much as the player and don't need to really punish the players as much
Fan Support - Should have thought of this myself, adding to the main body of the suggestion
Ticket sales - I had this in mind at first, while in copper I agree, in gold I think it might be nicer to have a flat bonus, since some teams won't make the playoffs when they normally would and would loose out somewhat on the money.
Originally posted by PackMan97
How would promotion and demolition work
you would go to whatever cap your team fit into. If you were a silver conference champ, you would move up to gold (probably depending on exactly how many silver leagues there are) Gold non playoff (and possibly 7 and 8 seeds) would move down to silver.
Copper would be mainly reserved for teams that were getting beaten up in silver leagues (like maybe 14, 15, and 16th seeds in the league) as well as CPU teams etc. A formula might be devised to count how many losses by 70+ you suffered in the season, and teams with excessive (somewhere around 6 seems excessive) 70+ point losses would be moved down.
Copper teams that performed well in the copper leagues, as well as have the roster, and scouting bars to warrant moving up, would move up to silver leagues
Plus Minus Count:
On going tally of people who have given approval or disapproval (will probably tally these in bulk each day to prevent a million "edited by" messages)
+ 21
- 8 (or people that seemed undecided)
You've heard it a million different times from probably a million different people, but the league parity in the game is fairly poor. There's a lot of reasons, from power house teams with very good rosters and game plans that run away with things, to league littered with CPU or gut job teams leading to lots of "free wins" for a lot of teams. The promotion system also allows for some teams to exploit level caps or out level other teams giving them an unfair advantage. Something to make more games competitive, and also keep teams from getting unfair level advantages over other teams in the league.
Proposed Solution:
Keep all the same level caps, however add 1 Gold league, as well as Silver and Copper leagues to each level cap.
At level 14 (would be only silver and copper). Copper leagues would consist of all gut job teams, teams with heavy CPU, teams that have a very low average level etc (aka the games that are usually triggering the max xp mode now). All other teams would be placed in the silver leagues.
end of season (when promotions are processed) you would be placed in whatever cap fit your team best (aka the lowest cap your highest level player can fit into). Gold would consist of the conference winning teams (and good playoff teams from previous gold leagues). Silver leagues would be filled out by the rest, copper leagues would be the people that performed very poorly in silver leagues, teams that are CPU etc.
At season rollover (before you schedules are released) another round of demotions from the silver leagues to remove teams that have low scouting bars, significantly lower level averages, or significantly hurting rosters (number of players). The silver leagues would then be condensed and the highest number league removed to fill all the holes that the demotion round created.
What you get: you get competitive games throughout the season (far less blowouts), bragging rights for the good teams, no worries about level cap exploitation, and keep the teams that are going to get blown out by normal teams in a league of their own.
To prevent exploitation:
The main thing we need to worry about is teams getting into lower tiers in an attempt to get more money via playoff ticket sales etc. There are a few things you can do to prevent this.
Scaling bonus money (higher cap = higher money) given to all teams making it into a gold league. This would be to compensated them for playing in a harder league and possibly missing the playoffs when they'd easily make the playoffs in silver leagues.
Winners of gold leagues would be given a specially designed trophy, with "XX Cap Champions" to reward them as being the cream of the crop of their level.
Copper leagues would get small penalties to ticket sales (tickets sell for less) to prevent teams from trying to move to copper leagues to reap playoff ticket sales.
Fan support - Gold would gain additional fan support per win and a little more forgiving when dealing with losing fan support. Conversely copper leagues would gain fan support slower and lose fan support quicker than normal.
Additional League Structure to Promote Rivalries:
It would also be nice if you stayed in the same silver # league (as best as possible), allowing you to see a lot of familiar faces each season, build up some rivalries and have more fun. So if you were in silver #3 for 18 cap, and after the season you were moved to the 30 cap, you go to silver #3 for 30 cap (provided you are not promoted to gold or demoted to copper).
Efforts would be made to keep you in the same conference as well, in order to promote conference vs conference rivalries, and to allow you to get a much better shot at playing your in conference rivals in non scrimmage games.
Quotes and Additional Discussion:
Will be added as people post their comments.
Originally posted by PackMan97
Gold - More local/national endorsements per team (only the in-season stuff, still just one MVP that carries over to next season) (Added later: coupled with upping the amount of active enforcements per team)
Copper - No endorsements at all, no MVP either
Fan Support - significantly higher fan support floor for Gold
Ticket Sales - much easier in gold, very hard in copper
Gold - While I think more national would be nice, the 3 per team cap makes me think additional locals would be unneeded.
Copper - Like the idea, maybe just reduced, since they don't benefit the team as much as the player and don't need to really punish the players as much
Fan Support - Should have thought of this myself, adding to the main body of the suggestion
Ticket sales - I had this in mind at first, while in copper I agree, in gold I think it might be nicer to have a flat bonus, since some teams won't make the playoffs when they normally would and would loose out somewhat on the money.
Originally posted by PackMan97
How would promotion and demolition work
you would go to whatever cap your team fit into. If you were a silver conference champ, you would move up to gold (probably depending on exactly how many silver leagues there are) Gold non playoff (and possibly 7 and 8 seeds) would move down to silver.
Copper would be mainly reserved for teams that were getting beaten up in silver leagues (like maybe 14, 15, and 16th seeds in the league) as well as CPU teams etc. A formula might be devised to count how many losses by 70+ you suffered in the season, and teams with excessive (somewhere around 6 seems excessive) 70+ point losses would be moved down.
Copper teams that performed well in the copper leagues, as well as have the roster, and scouting bars to warrant moving up, would move up to silver leagues
Plus Minus Count:
On going tally of people who have given approval or disapproval (will probably tally these in bulk each day to prevent a million "edited by" messages)
+ 21
- 8 (or people that seemed undecided)
Edited by Chysil on Jan 7, 2010 20:59:12
Edited by Chysil on Jan 1, 2010 08:05:32
Edited by Chysil on Dec 31, 2009 10:12:57
Edited by Chysil on Dec 31, 2009 09:31:18
Edited by Chysil on Dec 31, 2009 09:28:55






























