User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Lv 46 Minor Leagues > Lv 46 Minor League #2 > Eastern rankings thru 7 games
EclipseGirl
offline
Link
 
Sticking to my new ranking format. Much more entertaining than the generic 1-32 computer generated rankings, imo

The Elite

1) Philadelphia - still #1, will remain there *UNCHALLENGED* until they play Claremont. Sorry for the confusion with earlier rankings. Quality wins against Samoan, Onterio and Maribel
2) Claremont - Definitely coasting thru this part of their schedule. 321 against Belarus? I doubt they changed their tactics, probably just logged on to check stats. Quality wins against Las Vegas and WI
3) Berlin - Looks like Samoan will be their last challenging game, can't see them beating Claremont. Quality win against Maribel
4) Samoan - Glad I called it before I looked bad. A lot of time before they play Berlin, so we should be able to evaluate if they should be #3 before that showdown. Quality wins against Maribel and Las Vegas

Second Tier

5) Las Vegas - Very entertaining game against Samoan. Not much keeping them out of the elite class, just need to be able to stop the run more effectively. Quality win against Onterio
6) WI Hilltoppers - My team. Quality win against Onterio
7) Onterio - Tough loss, but will still finish with 10 wins. Quality win against Maribel
8) Maribel - No quality wins

Keep working at it fellas

9) Montreal - will easily dominate the 10-16 slots
10) Davenport - surprisingly dominant against a comparable Southern District team. Sadly, the easy part of their schedule is almost done, and it get's brutal very soon
11) Southern District - predicting 5-11 season
12) Detroit - watch out guys, Honolulu is creeping up on you
13) Cleveland - I simply don't like Cleveland, and hope they get beat by Honolulu
14) Honolulu - totally out of the closet supporter of this team
15) Belarus - I thought they were the worst, but .......
16) Valence - earns this spot by getting trashed against Honolulu, easily the worst team in the bottom feeder group








 
Kenshinzen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
2) Claremont - Definitely coasting thru this part of their schedule. 321 against Belarus? I doubt they changed their tactics, probably just logged on to check stats. Quality wins against Las Vegas and WI


True. I have to gameplan for 6 teams that day and don't have time to set different tactics for blowouts. I have a setting when we go over a certain amount of points and that's all.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
I never really understood the "you're #1 until you lose" argument. There isn't much logic to support it, and it has screwed a good number of college teams out of their rightful rankings. Sorry, but you're only as good as you are TODAY - being great in the past doesn't mean jack shit for how good you are now!
 
Malvado
Bugs Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82
I never really understood the "you're #1 until you lose" argument. There isn't much logic to support it, and it has screwed a good number of college teams out of their rightful rankings. Sorry, but you're only as good as you are TODAY - being great in the past doesn't mean jack shit for how good you are now!


You think Philly has gotten worse since the season started? LOL. Go cry yourself to sleep because you're not #1.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malvado
You think Philly has gotten worse since the season started? LOL. Go cry yourself to sleep because you're not #1.


You really don't get it. That's not what I said at all. I guess reading isn't a prerequisite to play here!
 
EclipseGirl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82
I never really understood the "you're #1 until you lose" argument. There isn't much logic to support it, and it has screwed a good number of college teams out of their rightful rankings. Sorry, but you're only as good as you are TODAY - being great in the past doesn't mean jack shit for how good you are now!


I'd like to think there's a good bit of logic to support this specific case. Philly has played and beaten Samoan and Berlin, while Claremont played and beat Las Vegas and WI. Samoan and Berlin are better regular season teams than Las Vegas and WI. Should Claremont destroy Berlin and Samoan by a significantly larger margin than Philly did, I'll reconsider my rankings.

Additionally, considering we play a game every other day, I don't see how talking about today vs the past is relevant. The players are, in 99.9% of the cases, identical from start to finish of a season. We're not talking about real life or real football here - a loldot's performance does not degrade in the span of 5 games. The loldots don't get DUI's, argue with their spouse, make poor monetary investments or get injured. Your point is a great argument if you want to talk about the BCS but doesn't really apply here.

All that said, I'm glad to see the rankings spark some conversation!
 
EclipseGirl
offline
Link
 
Of course, all this might be moot with Las Vegas beating Berlin today. I'll post new rankings once I get the chance to look at what happened.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EclipseGirl
I'd like to think there's a good bit of logic to support this specific case. Philly has played and beaten Samoan and Berlin, while Claremont played and beat Las Vegas and WI. Samoan and Berlin are better regular season teams than Las Vegas and WI. Should Claremont destroy Berlin and Samoan by a significantly larger margin than Philly did, I'll reconsider my rankings.

Additionally, considering we play a game every other day, I don't see how talking about today vs the past is relevant. The players are, in 99.9% of the cases, identical from start to finish of a season. We're not talking about real life or real football here - a loldot's performance does not degrade in the span of 5 games. The loldots don't get DUI's, argue with their spouse, make poor monetary investments or get injured. Your point is a great argument if you want to talk about the BCS but doesn't really apply here.

All that said, I'm glad to see the rankings spark some conversation!


At least you get the argument. I was only objecting to "will remain #1 unchallenged" because if two teams are undefeated; you have to actually look at who each team is playing and how well they're beating them. It should not be an automatic "team X is #1 until they lose" unless they're just so far ahead in SOS and margin of victory that the other undefeated team could never catch up.

Also, yay for rankings threads. These keep forums alive!
 
Malvado
Bugs Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82
You really don't get it. That's not what I said at all. I guess reading isn't a prerequisite to play here!


Its funny that you say that, then go on to prove my point later in the thread.



On a side note, I do agree with you. Yay for rankings, keep up the good work.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.