User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
James1985
offline
Link
 
Who is going to do the season 3 power ranking week to week.

I think a few people should get together and do it like they do in the pros.

Lets hear it
 
Chadstroma
offline
Link
 
Maybe a thought is to have one central person collect 'power ranking' votes from a few of the veteran owners in the AAA. This way the rankings are not one man's view but rather the votes of several owners. Say 2 owners in Alpha and 2 in Zeta. Set it out where 10 points to #1 choice, 9 to #2, etc and then the central guy add them up and posts.

I can not commit to be that central guy but could easily be one of the voters.
 
James1985
offline
Link
 
yeah thats pretty much what I had in mind

2 from alpha 2 from zeta and then one central adds it all up that would be perfect that way you get 4 differt people voting I can be the central guy that part is easy just add up the points.
 
Chadstroma
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James1985
yeah thats pretty much what I had in mind

2 from alpha 2 from zeta and then one central adds it all up that would be perfect that way you get 4 differt people voting I can be the central guy that part is easy just add up the points.


That is cool with me... just dont think that I am going to stop poking fun at you here and there just because you step up here. ;-)
 
joe
46 Defense
offline
Link
 
thank is a great idea.
 
Link
 
How do you decide who gets to vote? Only 4 teams out 32 being represented doesn't seem the most encompassing system. How about one representative from one team gets to vote, w/ a time limit to turn in the votes. Like say, by midnight after each gameday. Then the person who is collecting the votes will tally the votes and post the next day.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
How do you decide who gets to vote? Only 4 teams out 32 being represented doesn't seem the most encompassing system. How about one representative from one team gets to vote, w/ a time limit to turn in the votes. Like say, by midnight after each gameday. Then the person who is collecting the votes will tally the votes and post the next day.


Sounds good to me. Also I would suggest only vote for the top 8 teams, it's easier that way.
 
Chadstroma
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
How do you decide who gets to vote? Only 4 teams out 32 being represented doesn't seem the most encompassing system. How about one representative from one team gets to vote, w/ a time limit to turn in the votes. Like say, by midnight after each gameday. Then the person who is collecting the votes will tally the votes and post the next day.


I was thinking on behalf of the guy who collects all of that. I know I would not want to do that every two days. Seems like over kill to me but again, if someone is willing to put in that effort of collecting and computing the points every two weeks from 32 teams.... I am all for it.

 
Link
 
Why don't we just make an official voting thread, and then everyone can count the results.
 
Chadstroma
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Why don't we just make an official voting thread, and then everyone can count the results.


I guess.... I know I wont count and it just seems to invite a mess. Anyone can jump in and vote and you would have to go thru 32 posts to count which would be a few pages. Then what happens if more than one person from one team votes.... so then you have more than 32 votes. Again, I am not against it... just seems like we are asking to create more work to do this than it is worth. But that is just me.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
How about this: first have one person that's going to add up the votes. After each game, each team's owner/GM can PM their votes to the person responsible for adding up. The following rules would make it easier for the person adding the votes:

1. One vote per team, each team can decide who represents the team in voting. It can be the owner, GM or a player. But each team only can have one entry.
2. Teams can't vote for themselves. If you are good, the others will vote for you.
3. On the PM sent to the vote counter, the message should be in the following format:
Team name: Name of the team that voted
#1: XXXXX
#2: XXXXX
....

4. I would recommend keeping the votes to top 10 teams or something like that. Most people don't have time to really analyze the teams at the bottom, so it probably won't be accurate. NCAA polls only have top 25, not the whole 109 or whatever number of teams they have now.

Anyhow, just my two cents.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 21:59:53
 
James1985
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
How about this: first have one person that's going to add up the votes. After each game, each team's owner/GM can PM their votes to the person responsible for adding up. The following rules would make it easier for the person adding the votes:

1. One vote per team, each team can decide who represents the team in voting. It can be the owner, GM or a player. But each team only can have one entry.
2. Teams can't vote for themselves. If you are good, the others will vote for you.
3. On the PM sent to the vote counter, the message should be in the following format:
Team name: Name of the team that voted
#1: XXXXX
#2: XXXXX
....

4. I would recommend keeping the votes to top 10 teams or something like that. Most people don't have time to really analyze the teams at the bottom, so it probably won't be accurate. NCAA polls only have top 25, not the whole 109 or whatever number of teams they have now.

Anyhow, just my two cents.



Ilike this Idea.

I will add up the votes so if this is what all the owners wanna do than yeah that will be great
 
James1985
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chadstroma
Originally posted by James1985

yeah thats pretty much what I had in mind

2 from alpha 2 from zeta and then one central adds it all up that would be perfect that way you get 4 differt people voting I can be the central guy that part is easy just add up the points.


That is cool with me... just dont think that I am going to stop poking fun at you here and there just because you step up here. ;-)


lol I know
 
James1985
offline
Link
 
Check out this thread and vote there SEA AAA owners. http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=361182
 
nutrumpet
offline
Link
 
I'm down, I write for the Kentucky Enquirer and I'd love to help out here too.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.