Originally posted by RonaldusMagnus
some libertarian/conservative thoughts there cat.
ha... but not the "natural resources should be owned by the people" one, certainly...
Originally posted by RonaldusMagnus
and whats the difference between progressives and modern day libs?
if we're speaking in terms of ideological space, i'd oversimplify them as follows:
progressives believe in the necessity of "progressive institutions" to gradually increase social justice -- such institutions can be anything from schools and jails to concepts like the separation of powers or practices like voting. as such, progressivism is almost as much of a historical viewpoint as a political one. instead of assuming that there is a single perfect human governance, the idea is that our governance gets better (and more moral) as we get better at crafting/reforming institutions. (of course, this means that progressives make a rather large conflation of 'governance' with 'institutions', which places them instantly at odds with any type of anarchist or government minimalist.)
to keep these institutions strong/viable/legitimate, progressives crusade against corruption and are always strong supporters of campaign and finance reform. while they're not afraid of large government, progressives are in no way seeking to create some sort of totalitarian/statist regime. in fact, they view such an outcome as impossible, so long as institutions are kept in check and the public remains empowered. this is one of the reasons why they agitate for more direct democracy (as opposed to republicanism and/or mass appointments) -- in their view, true political equality is the first prerequisite of social justice, so the only way to move forward is to embrace democracy and make sure everyone is educated and voting.
obviously, there are some concerns here... although more about "progressives" who misunderstand their own ideology than about progressivism itself. a broad view of what constitutes an 'institution' is all well and good, but enjoying one's right to vote is a completely different thing than moralizing compulsory education. progressives may avoid the mistake of consequentialism (i.e moralizing the result), but they in turn moralize the process, which is almost as bad. there's obviously no risk of a progressive become a fascist, but there is a tendency for progressives to think governance can solve everything (just like marketists think that the market can solve everything) -- hence the caricature of the overly eager "don quixote" progressive state... or al gore claiming he invented the internet (which he never said, but is actually true in an unthinkingly progressivist way).
liberals are a bit easier to get a handle on, considering they're essentially the mirror opposite of libertarians. technically, both follow liberalism... it's just that (modern american) liberals follow social liberalism (which values 'positive liberty') while libertarians follow classical liberalism (which values 'negative liberty'). in other words, libertarians stress "freedom from" while liberals stress "freedom to".
of course, the problem with enforcing positive liberty is that it usually encroaches on negative liberty. for example, society may have said that blacks couldn't use certain bathrooms or sit in certain seats or go to certain schools or hold certain jobs, but liberals agitated for legislation that ensured that all races had the "freedom to" do those things. did such positive liberty infringe on the negative liberties of racists and bigots? yup... just as freeing the slaves could also be termed as a state appropriation or infringement on the negative liberties of the slaveholders to buy and sell whomever they damn well pleased. so the idea (and it's the main pillar for liberals) is that collective negative liberty is actually a form of positive liberty. put differently, liberals claim that positive liberty is actually the first prerequisite of negative liberty (cf. social libertarians).
there are some obvious concerns here as well. any ideology that embraces consequentialism (i.e. the ends justify the means) is in danger of becoming both totalitarian and oppressive (nb. not the same thing). moreover, democracy itself suffers a bit of a chilling effect -- by assuming a consequentialist pose, a state thus moralizes its own policies and demonizes (and even dehumanizes) any dissent. as the state becomes less democratic and more insulated from its own citizens (or even adversarial to them), the judicial and legislative collapse into an increasingly secretive executive branch. not only does this make voting pointless, but there is a pronounced risk that the state will simply begin misinforming/manipulating its citizens for the sake of political expediency and suddenly 1984 is real. this is not to say that liberals are in any danger of becoming statists, but it's a similar ideological predicament to progressivism -- only those who fail to understand it are at risk of perverting it.
some oversimplified differences:
-- progressives typically work through the legislative branch, liberals through the judicial
-- progressives emphasize process (means>ends) and are (by definition) anti-consequentialist.. liberals emphasize results (ends>means) and sometimes veer towards consequentialism
-- if they think voting and education can save the world, they're a progressive... if they think social programs and court cases can save the world, they're a liberal
-- if they think of social justice in terms of participatory political egalitarianism and/or civic virtue, they're a progressive... if they think of social justice in chiefly economic terms, they're a liberal
and i know i've mentioned this before, but it's worth repeating -- the radicalism of the late 19th century begat the populism of the early 20th century which, during the great depression, morphed into the sort of progressivism that marked the democratic party at that time. but following ww2, liberals suddenly took center stage and many of the more culturally conservative progressives (like ronald reagan and charleton heston) declared that the democratic party had "left them". ironically, it was reagan's proto-neocon presidency that did much to kill the liberal movement and produce the radical centrism of clinton's "third way" politics and the even more radical neo-progressivism that put obama in the white house.
Originally posted by RonaldusMagnus
i think the plurality of Americans have an independent/liberty or death type streak in them. if i could live off the grid without pain and still have a modern lifestyle id do it in a second. soon as that technology truly catches up im first in line!
maybe so... but it seems that most americans still value their "modern lifestyle" more than "living off the grid". but yeah, the day may soon come when we can have our cake and eat it, too... just look at what the internet has done already.