User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > If a team wins a game by 100+ points award maximum exp.
Page:
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
There is nothing worse than blowing out a team, and having your offensive players not get enough plays to get the 100 exp per game(after 27th-28th lvl I forget which).

This basically screws offensive players out of exp, in direct proportion to how many CPU teams are in their league. Since the number varies greatly from league to league, the only thing I can think of to not have this disparity is to give max exp (100) to all the team members of a team that wins by more than 100 points.
 
Link
 
+1. There ought to be a more direct solution that this (max XP for anyone on an active roster), but I'd support this as a step in the right direction.
 
Gongadan
offline
Link
 
If a team hits cruise control at any point in the game, everyone who had a single play for that team should get max XP.
 
EchoedSilence
offline
Link
 
I agree that this needs to be addressed, but disagree wholeheartedly with giving anybody who receives a single play max exp. That's just ridiculous. Sooo many ways to exploit that.

Perhaps make it so that the number of plays needed to reach max exp is proportional to the number of plays actually ran during a blowout win (Read: Not just a game where you hit cruise control - One that you FINISH as a blow out win). IE: Having to take 50% of the snaps, or something of the sort.

That way, even if you only run 20 plays, if you have your players in for a set amount, they'll get exp proportional to that amount.
 
jkid2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EchoedSilence
I agree that this needs to be addressed, but disagree wholeheartedly with giving anybody who receives a single play max exp. That's just ridiculous. Sooo many ways to exploit that.

Perhaps make it so that the number of plays needed to reach max exp is proportional to the number of plays actually ran during a blowout win (Read: Not just a game where you hit cruise control - One that you FINISH as a blow out win). IE: Having to take 50% of the snaps, or something of the sort.

That way, even if you only run 20 plays, if you have your players in for a set amount, they'll get exp proportional to that amount.


I think everyone who plays should just get max XP because that is only fair to everyone. This would allow for more depth.
 
EchoedSilence
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jkid2
I think everyone who plays should just get max XP because that is only fair to everyone. This would allow for more depth.


The game is not about being fair. It's about progression and training.

You're saying that if someone is on the field for one play, they should get the same amount of experience (The definition of which relates directly to the progression of one's skills) as someone who is on the field for 20+ plays.

Despite the fact that it is a blow out win, that player is not going to take nearly as much off the field with him as the player that was in for much longer. Hence why a proportion system would work much better AND keep it from being exploitable. Otherwise, I'm playing all my guys for one play against the next set of horrid CPU teams I play and getting them max exp every time. In my eyes, as much as people would love it, that's an exploit of the system. Hell, in some leagues that could end up as just another way of forming a farm team by signing a large number of players and then doing this the entire season against a dead league (of which we do have some).

Also - Are we going to be looking at the same system for the team that loses? or just the team that wins?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by EchoedSilence
Originally posted by jkid2

I think everyone who plays should just get max XP because that is only fair to everyone. This would allow for more depth.


The game is not about being fair. It's about progression and training.

You're saying that if someone is on the field for one play, they should get the same amount of experience (The definition of which relates directly to the progression of one's skills) as someone who is on the field for 20+ plays.

Despite the fact that it is a blow out win, that player is not going to take nearly as much off the field with him as the player that was in for much longer. Hence why a proportion system would work much better AND keep it from being exploitable. Otherwise, I'm playing all my guys for one play against the next set of horrid CPU teams I play and getting them max exp every time. In my eyes, as much as people would love it, that's an exploit of the system. Hell, in some leagues that could end up as just another way of forming a farm team by signing a large number of players and then doing this the entire season against a dead league (of which we do have some).

Also - Are we going to be looking at the same system for the team that loses? or just the team that wins?




There's already a roster limit. Besides, what you describe isn't an "exploit". If I want to build special teams players, why should I have to get 30 0r 40 plays (at the early levels of the build) just to make progress at the same rate that a regular downs player does? Further, the backups pay just as much to create and boost their dots as the starters do--again, why should they be penalized because of a wonky game against CPUs and/or bad depth chart management by a team owner?
 
EchoedSilence
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


There's already a roster limit. Besides, what you describe isn't an "exploit". If I want to build special teams players, why should I have to get 30 0r 40 plays (at the early levels of the build) just to make progress at the same rate that a regular downs player does? Further, the backups pay just as much to create and boost their dots as the starters do--again, why should they be penalized because of a wonky game against CPUs and/or bad depth chart management by a team owner?


We're not referring to penalizing - I'm referring to players getting max exp for 1 play. Unless that play is somehow proportional to the number of plays run, the idea behind it is ridiculous. Back ups would not be penalized anymore than they would normally on their teams if we set up a reasonable system. Max exp for one play is not reasonable.

Special Teams is a whole other story that has been addressed in other topics - It is known that there needs to be a way to fix exp for them outside of the usual manner that you would use with other players due to the stamina loss. That's not what we're referring to here, and if we get to that, its something best left until the generally favored idea for how to fix this suggestion is found. You're trying to build a wall from the top down.

Now, as much as the backups pay the same, that still doesn't mean that we need to adjust the experience system to shadow that. Yes, it sucks that some players have to play back up and there are plenty of people out there that detest the thought. The fact remains though that generally there isn't much trouble getting most of the team max exp, and still wouldn't be if there were a system set up to make it so that that experience gained is proportional to the percentage of plays that you're actually there for.

We could say that you get a background base of exp from watching (IE: QBs sitting out their first year to observe, etc), but that's an entirely different tangent that I'm going to cut short right here.
Edited by EchoedSilence on Nov 20, 2009 10:43:20
 
Link
 
Originally posted by EchoedSilence
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader



There's already a roster limit. Besides, what you describe isn't an "exploit". If I want to build special teams players, why should I have to get 30 0r 40 plays (at the early levels of the build) just to make progress at the same rate that a regular downs player does? Further, the backups pay just as much to create and boost their dots as the starters do--again, why should they be penalized because of a wonky game against CPUs and/or bad depth chart management by a team owner?


We're not referring to penalizing - I'm referring to players getting max exp for 1 play. Unless that play is somehow proportional to the number of plays run, the idea behind it is ridiculous. Back ups would not be penalized anymore than they would normally on their teams if we set up a reasonable system. Max exp for one play is not reasonable.

Special Teams is a whole other story that has been addressed in other topics - It is known that there needs to be a way to fix exp for them outside of the usual manner that you would use with other players due to the stamina loss. That's not what we're referring to here, and if we get to that, its something best left until the generally favored idea for how to fix this suggestion is found. You're trying to build a wall from the top down.

Now, as much as the backups pay the same, that still doesn't mean that we need to adjust the experience system to shadow that. Yes, it sucks that some players have to play back up and there are plenty of people out there that detest the thought. The fact remains though that generally there isn't much trouble getting most of the team max exp, and still wouldn't be if there were a system set up to make it so that that experience gained is proportional to the percentage of plays that you're actually there for.

We could say that you get a background base of exp from watching (IE: QBs sitting out their first year to observe, etc), but that's an entirely different tangent that I'm going to cut short right here.



We'll simply agree to disagree then. Max experience for everyone on the roster solves a lot of issues, including special teams oriented players and encouraging backups to stay interested in dot-building and it also does away with the issue of owners "rotting" players. We all pay for our dots--there's no reason why their build's progression should be at the mercy of some team owner who may or may not be paying attention to the schedule and the depth chart.
 
EchoedSilence
offline
Link
 
Hasn't the 'Max Exp' topic been shot down before though? That's part of the reason that I'm adamantly against it, really. In theory, I can get over it, but I have seen people bring it up multiple times just to get shot down again. It would level the playing field in the long run and make it more fun, yes, but the 'higher powers' have their way of doing things.

Steer from it, and hell ensues

It's a wonder they ever gave us a suggestion forum. I suppose if it weren't for the fact that they allegedly cannot delete forums, it would have been gone in accordance to some moderator's maddened/annoyed rage long ago (There seems to be a very large increase in locked/-able topics as of late)
 
TruBucfan22
offline
Link
 
this season my Starting QB only had 1 play because the offense didn't get the ball until we were up by 40 (which is my Ai settings to give the Backups more PT) They got 1 play and was fairly pissed off by it... This is partly my fault for having the setting, but if you give players Max XP in blow outs it would not be an Exploit.O_o It would be a fix for playing shitty teams that shouldn't be in the game to begin with.

I don't understand how it is an Exploit when it would really be a fix of a problem that many teams are having.

Like Echoed Said. "Generally there isn't much trouble getting most of the team max exp."............ But it is hard when you play shitty teams. and Players shouldn't be punished just because we play 3 shitty teams every season.

I dont see how it could possibly be considered an exploit.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
I have always been in favor of just giving everyone max xp in every game. It would just solve so many problems and headaches. And for those of you who argue that it isn't realistic and that a player who plays 1 play shouldn't develop as fast as a player who plays 50, then I must ask you why give any xp at all in gutted games. An NFL or college caliber player would not gain anything out of playing pee wee teams IRL.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EchoedSilence
Hasn't the 'Max Exp' topic been shot down before though? That's part of the reason that I'm adamantly against it, really. In theory, I can get over it, but I have seen people bring it up multiple times just to get shot down again. It would level the playing field in the long run and make it more fun, yes, but the 'higher powers' have their way of doing things.

Steer from it, and hell ensues

It's a wonder they ever gave us a suggestion forum. I suppose if it weren't for the fact that they allegedly cannot delete forums, it would have been gone in accordance to some moderator's maddened/annoyed rage long ago (There seems to be a very large increase in locked/-able topics as of late)


The problem with the blow out games against Gutted/CPU teams, is that what often happens is that the Kick Returner/Punt Returner runs 90% of the kickoffs and punts back for touchdowns.

In an average game an offense gets 50-70 plays, which is plenty to ensure even your back ups get 20 plays for max exp. In a blow out game, such as the one I played today: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=883174 the entire offense only got 21 plays because 71% of our 364 points was scored by our KR/PR.

Now as an OC, I can spend an hour or so, to redo my depth chart, putting in my worst player at KR/PR, then set up an offense with a OT, at RB just so we actually have offensive plays that don't score TD's every time our starters touch the ball. However, the problem with this approach, is that a significant number of playoff positions come down to a 3 way tie, and the tiebreaker is points scored. So to neuter your team so that your players can get 20 plays in significantly lowers the score that you rack up and is essentially shooting your team in the foot.

The Max Exp proposed, is only for players who are already capped at 100 exp per game for 20 plays. I don't really have a solution for players under this level except perhaps lower the max exp that lower level players get for 40+ plays per game to a sliding scale per level. There really isn't a good reason that lower level players can get anywhere from 300 - 500 exp per game for playing 30 -50 plays per game. All this does is encourage farm teams to get players max exp by overplaying just a few players and not fielding a competitive team because of it.
 
Gongadan
offline
Link
 
The XP system generally is a source of issues. If it weren't for the way the XP system is set up, there would be no:

Rotting of players
Frustration from backup players who don't get PT
Farm teams to max XP for a few players and are otherwise uncompetitive
Blowout win issues with KR/PR that require bizarre depth charts and game plans to have a chance to get XP
SSB

But then again, fixing the XP system would require a basic change of the code (whether it's max XP per game or whatever), and we can't have that. Change is for the weak.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
How many times has this been suggested? Are we over 100 yet? Isn't this supported by over 90% of GLB?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.