Originally posted by EchoedSilence
Hasn't the 'Max Exp' topic been shot down before though? That's part of the reason that I'm adamantly against it, really. In theory, I can get over it, but I have seen people bring it up multiple times just to get shot down again. It would level the playing field in the long run and make it more fun, yes, but the 'higher powers' have their way of doing things.
Steer from it, and hell ensues 
It's a wonder they ever gave us a suggestion forum. I suppose if it weren't for the fact that they allegedly cannot delete forums, it would have been gone in accordance to some moderator's maddened/annoyed rage long ago
(There seems to be a very large increase in locked/-able topics as of late)The problem with the blow out games against Gutted/CPU teams, is that what often happens is that the Kick Returner/Punt Returner runs 90% of the kickoffs and punts back for touchdowns.
In an average game an offense gets 50-70 plays, which is plenty to ensure even your back ups get 20 plays for max exp. In a blow out game, such as the one I played today:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=883174 the entire offense only got 21 plays because 71% of our 364 points was scored by our KR/PR.
Now as an OC, I can spend an hour or so, to redo my depth chart, putting in my worst player at KR/PR, then set up an offense with a OT, at RB just so we actually have offensive plays that don't score TD's every time our starters touch the ball. However, the problem with this approach, is that a significant number of playoff positions come down to a 3 way tie, and the tiebreaker is points scored. So to neuter your team so that your players can get 20 plays in significantly lowers the score that you rack up and is essentially shooting your team in the foot.
The Max Exp proposed, is only for players who are already capped at 100 exp per game for 20 plays. I don't really have a solution for players under this level except perhaps lower the max exp that lower level players get for 40+ plays per game to a sliding scale per level. There really isn't a good reason that lower level players can get anywhere from 300 - 500 exp per game for playing 30 -50 plays per game. All this does is encourage farm teams to get players max exp by overplaying just a few players and not fielding a competitive team because of it.