User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
We_Rule
offline
Link
 
No offense to Randam's guy, but tell me how the hell Milk Man didn't get the MVP.........
 
razor9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by We_Rule
No offense to Randam's guy, but tell me how the hell Milk Man didn't get the MVP.........


Agreed. Stats were better and your team finished ahead of his. This is what people are always bitching about in the main forums about how the formula is broken. Randam Axe didn't deserve to have the offensive and defensive MVP. Their defensive player was crazy, so I agree with that one, but the Milk Man is #1.

Similar vein, my QB was in the top ten for MVP and he wasn't even my best player. He had kind of a sub par season, so I just don't know how this thing works.
 
Arles
offline
Link
 
I'll throw Diesel's name into the ring as well. He had one game all season when he didn't score (24 for 97 and 4 ypc against Defiance). Against seeds 1 through 6, he had these numbers:

Def: 24 for 97 and 0 TDs
Philly: 22 for 84 and 1 TD
Was: 32 for 166 and 2 TDs
Axe: 25 for 128 and 1 TD
Fort: 24 for 98 and 2 TDs

You can add in 137 against the Red Bulls in our scrimmage as well (even though the game isn't an official league game).

Still, I think Troy is the right choice. Troy (500, 16 TDs) and Diesel (750, 26) didn't benefit nearly as much from the 200+ games as Milkman (1400 yards and 37 TDs). You subtract off those games and it's:

Troy: 2566, 58 TDs
Diesel Cruiser: 2560, 51 TDs
Milkman: 1951, 56 TDs

Add in neither Troy or Diesel had the under 50 yard stinkers the Milkman had twice and I can buy Troy winning.
 
Homer
offline
Link
 
I didn't loook to see if it applies here, but it usually does.
People always forget that a large part of the eqation is the % of your teams yards and scores. That's why it seems like awards players on bad teams. A great team usually has more than just one player getting yards and scoring.
 
Arles
offline
Link
 
That's a good point. Lost City ended up with 4 1,000 yard rushers. Obviously, anyone of them could have put up insane stats, but we wanted to be more balanced.
 
We_Rule
offline
Link
 
TBH, I think I would be a little less disappointed if Diesel got it instead..... he was in the top two all season up until the last two games battling with Milk (remind everyone too that Milk & Troy actually played against each other in the second to last game, and Troy had 20 carries for 74 yards where Milk had 37 for 233 at 6.7 ypc.....just saying) . I'm not dissing Troy in any way...... one great HB without question. Just hard NOT to get behind the dude who led in yards, TDs, was #2 in ypc (when all three had the same number of carries basically, and all three played against the same competition..... all three OOC games were against similar competition as well). We all definitely have other weapons too, and all three teams run fairly balanced schemes...... if I would've known it would be this close I would've probably had our OC run Milk a little more TBH is all. You make a good case for Troy though too Arles...... just disappointed a little with the outcome is all. Congrats to Troy though!
 
Sabataged
offline
Link
 
I read somewhere thats stats against cupcake teams don't count towards mvp figuring. Don't know how that works out in this discussion
 
GoHooterGo
offline
Link
 
It's hard to deterimine, but looking at Milk's last game: 700 Yards - 24 TD's, in a Blowout Game.

Those Stats, you can more or less throw away because I don't think they have any effect on the Rankings.

So, lets go by the playoff teams:

vs Lost City Idols: (Winner: Troy Thunderstud)

THE MILK MAN: 11 Rushes - 47 Yards - 4.3 YPC - 0 TD's (Lost 0-63)
Troy Thunderstud: 39 Rushes - 190 Yards - 4.9 YPC - 1 TD's (Lost 16-30)

vs The Defiance: (Winner: None)

THE MILK MAN: 22 Rushes - 104 Yards - 4.7 YPC - 2 TD's (Lost 17-37)
Troy Thunderstud: 13 Rushes - 66 Yards - 5.1 YPC - 2 TD's (Lost 23-37)

vs Philly Franklins: (Winner: Troy Thunderstud)

THE MILK MAN: 15 Rushes - 51 Yards - 3.4 YPC - 0 TD's (Lost 19-24)
Troy Thunderstud: 19 Rushes - 91.5 Yards - 4.8 YPC - 1 TD's (Won 17-10)

vs Fort McMurray Mounted Police: (Winner: Troy Thunderstud)

THE MILK MAN: 21 Rushes - 132.5 Yards - 6.3 YPC - 1 TD's (Won 33-10)
Troy Thunderstud: 38 Rushes - 160 Yards - 4.2 YPC - 6 TD's (Won 66-10)

vs Stalingrad Blitzkrieg: (Winner: THE MILK MAN)

THE MILK MAN: 25 Rushes - 184 Yards - 7.4 YPC - 5 TD's (Won 66-0)
Troy Thunderstud: 32 Rushes - 205.5 Yards - 6.4 YPC - 4 TD's (Won 62-0)

vs Rochelle Hubs: (WInner: Troy Thunderstud)

THE MILK MAN: 19 Rushes - 112 Yards - 5.9 YPC - 4 TD's (Won 71-10)
Troy Thunderstud: 46 Rushes - 294 Yards - 6.4 YPC - 6 TD's (Won 56-0)

vs Each Other: (Winner: THE MILK MAN)

THE MILK MAN: 37 Rushes - 233.5 Yards - 6.3 YPC - 4 TD's (Won 28-10)
Troy Thunderstud: 20 Rushes - 74.5 Yards - 3.7 YPC - 0 TD's (Lost 10-28)

TOTAL:


THE MILK MAN: 150 Rushes - 864 Yards - 5.76 YPC - 16 TD's
Troy Thunderstud: 207 Rushes - 1,081.5 Yards - 5.22 YPC - 20 TD's

I'd have to lean towards Troy Thunderstud with the above numbers. This is against all the playoff teams, so these are the real numbers and not inflated stats.
 
MikeJ
offline
Link
 
Troy is my player, and I was a bit surprised to see him win the MVP as well. I guess the yards and TDs from blowout games must count for very little in the formula. I would have been happy to see it go to either Milk Man or Diesel, for what it's worth, both awesome RBs. BTW, thanks a lot guys for taking the time to do those stat comparisons from competitive games.

As for Maddy Bartlett jr., I think he was the clearcut DMVP... sick player. Glad he's on our team.

Edited by MikeJ on Nov 14, 2009 12:06:41
 
petevas
offline
Link
 
There is a discussion going on in the suggestion forum and I'm trying to push for a 5-4-3-2-1 system which will produce a fair winner. Don't think that anyone understands what I'm say though
 
GoHooterGo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by petevas
There is a discussion going on in the suggestion forum and I'm trying to push for a 5-4-3-2-1 system which will produce a fair winner. Don't think that anyone understands what I'm say though


Care to explain more?
 
petevas
offline
Link
 
It a system thats used in Australia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brownlow_Medal#Voting_Procedure
http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/brownlow_medal

Basically, the player that is best on ground for a particular match will get 5 points and the second best player gets 4 points and so on. This happens in every round and for every match. After 16 rounds, The player that has the most points wins MVP. This makes sure that a good player will win the MVP award. There is no way that a player that has not done well enough consistantly will win the award if GLB gets the formula right for picking the best 5 players. This can work for both offense and defense but not for STs.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.