User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Ball lobbed and not even attempted to catch
Page:
 
Wes-Welker
offline
Link
 
My wr just stood as a lob came up that was very catchable. 3 in ball hawk. the way i see it, it could have gone for a long gain thats why i ask. After the play it shows the pass was to the TE but why shouldn't the Wr use common sense that he can catch it and go for it.

MY vision is 63 without equip and 65 with equip. 3 in ball hawk. 109 speed (+25), 74.28 (+3) agility. The ball is less than 5 yards away and traveling really slow.

The throw was a bad throw to the tight end but a decent throw for my wr.

Bug: Blind WRs?
or
Suggestion: Let the receiver that is closest to the ball do some kind of vision check to see if he can make it to the ball or not or let the receiver that is closest be the intended receiver.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=823173&pbp_id=12197809
Edited by Wes-Welker on Nov 7, 2009 11:00:05
Edited by Wes-Welker on Nov 5, 2009 14:24:50
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
link to replay
 
Wes-Welker
offline
Link
 
was saving it for last and forgot
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
All of the receivers continue running their routes (except for the intended receiver, the TE), which is stupid.
Edited by TrevJo on Nov 5, 2009 17:51:33
 
KJDCanefan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Wes-Welker
My wr just stood as a lob came up that was very catchable. 3 in ball hawk. the way i see it, it could have gone for a long gain thats why i ask. After the play it shows the pass was to the TE but why shouldn't the Wr use common sense that he can catch it and go for it.

MY vision is 63 without equip and 65 with equip. 3 in ball hawk. 109 speed (+25), 74.28 (+3) agility. The ball is less than 5 yards away and traveling really slow.

Bug: Blind WRs?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=823173&pbp_id=12197809


It is a natural reaction...If a person sees a high ball going over their head they usually deem it uncatchable and don't try for it. Has been done millions of times in the NFL and CFB. Bort DOES want the game to be real...Good pressure by the DE though..
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by KJDCanefan
It is a natural reaction...If a person sees a high ball going over their head they usually deem it uncatchable and don't try for it. Has been done millions of times in the NFL and CFB. Bort DOES want the game to be real...Good pressure by the DE though..


wat

The ball was clearly catchable. Also:

Originally posted by TrevJo
All of the receivers continue running their routes (except for the intended receiver, the TE), which is stupid.
 
Wes-Welker
offline
Link
 
yeah I'd say by the time the ball reached my wide it was right in his face if not to his outside shoulder.
 
Sprocket
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Wes-Welker
yeah I'd say by the time the ball reached my wide it was right in his face if not to his outside shoulder.


Seriously? How can you tell what the altitude of the ball is, in relation to your receiver? Where is your dot face? Or shoulder?
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by KJDCanefan
It is a natural reaction...If a person sees a high ball going over their head they usually deem it uncatchable and don't try for it. Has been done millions of times in the NFL and CFB. Bort DOES want the game to be real...


Yeah, but that one didn't land all that far from the receiver either.

If I was a head coach in real life and saw a WR stand there and make no effort to get to that ball, I'd bench him. Would've been a difficult catch for sure, but you try anyway. And if you're not gonna try, you're not gonna play as far as I'm concerned.

I'd say this is a bug, because I seriously doubt Bort programmed WRs to stand there and watch passes go over their heads.
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
i'm calling it a bug just because no one can point to another example of this
 
Tobysmith6922
offline
Link
 
Only intended receiver goes for the ball...
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tobysmith6922
Only intended receiver goes for the ball...


This exactly. Receivers are omniscient too, and they know who the ball was thrown too. Even if it's closer to them, they won't go for it at all. This is just a blatent case of that due to the bad throw.
WRs should probably get to make some sort of vision check/decision on what to do once they see the ball in the air, based on if they think they can get it or if someone else has it etc. Perhaps they'll keep running the route in order to try to keep the defender on them, whatever.
Probably a minor difference in actual gameplay results, though
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiborRis
Originally posted by Tobysmith6922

Only intended receiver goes for the ball...


This exactly. Receivers are omniscient too, and they know who the ball was thrown too. Even if it's closer to them, they won't go for it at all. This is just a blatent case of that due to the bad throw.
WRs should probably get to make some sort of vision check/decision on what to do once they see the ball in the air, based on if they think they can get it or if someone else has it etc. Perhaps they'll keep running the route in order to try to keep the defender on them, whatever.
Probably a minor difference in actual gameplay results, though


+1
Edited by TrevJo on Nov 6, 2009 11:47:21
 
jaredcope90
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sprocket
Seriously? How can you tell what the altitude of the ball is, in relation to your receiver? Where is your dot face? Or shoulder?


seriously to you sir. the Wr is running a route that appears to be a button up. No it is a button up so its facing somewhere on his frontside, and by that time the ball is near him its common sense that its at least at a catcheable "altitude" going by where it hits the ground.My guess that its is anywhere from the knees to the shoulders.
Edited by jaredcope90 on Nov 6, 2009 14:31:19
 
Sprocket
offline
Link
 
The problem is, these dots dont have 'common sense'. They are just dots. They dont think.

Now, I can see where this could be a useful/fun addition to the game, if it could be coded.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.