User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Coverage Closing from a distance 'Pauses'
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
I posted this before and it was locked becuase the player was blamed. Problem is I continue to see this from other players, and other builds in other situations and there seems to be a problem with coverage _closing_ on their m2m targets.

Some tried to claim it was a difference in speed being too great but in the example I will post the Coverage has twice the speed as the intended receiver but they still 'hold off' and allow the catch instead of closing.

It happens most frequently on backs coming out of the backfield but this example:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=821602&pbp_id=11614335

I believe it may be tied to being set for 'Semi-Aggressive' for coverage type as that appears to be the unifying factor of the players involved.

But tis is not 'Semi-Aggressive' its frikken stupid coverage. Players should not be pausing to allow the catch and then try to make the tackle. FS in this example has Ball Hawk and Zone Specialist as well. There is no good reason for them to slow down to near a stop to allow the catch.
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
He probably doesn't slow down TBH. Bort's mapping of sim output to dot movement probably just put's that jump in there. The actual sim is fine it's just the translation to visual dots isn't exact.
 
TheBear
Roll Tide
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hikariu
He probably doesn't slow down TBH. Bort's mapping of sim output to dot movement probably just put's that jump in there. The actual sim is fine it's just the translation to visual dots isn't exact.


Would that also explain why the SS in this play waited for the HB to come block him?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=856619&pbp_id=11453017
 
Skoll Wolfrun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
I posted this before and it was locked becuase the player was blamed. Problem is I continue to see this from other players, and other builds in other situations and there seems to be a problem with coverage _closing_ on their m2m targets.

Some tried to claim it was a difference in speed being too great but in the example I will post the Coverage has twice the speed as the intended receiver but they still 'hold off' and allow the catch instead of closing.

It happens most frequently on backs coming out of the backfield but this example:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=821602&pbp_id=11614335

I believe it may be tied to being set for 'Semi-Aggressive' for coverage type as that appears to be the unifying factor of the players involved.

But tis is not 'Semi-Aggressive' its frikken stupid coverage. Players should not be pausing to allow the catch and then try to make the tackle. FS in this example has Ball Hawk and Zone Specialist as well. There is no good reason for them to slow down to near a stop to allow the catch.


Hm, that example has the FS lined up on the other side of the field. If he is set to m2m, I would figure he should line up across from the TE unless you are not using the Def Play Creator.
 
Skoll Wolfrun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheBear
Would that also explain why the SS in this play waited for the HB to come block him?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=856619&pbp_id=11453017


That is just messed up. Only thing I would ask is if the players Stamina is 9...because it looks like he was moving slower than a snail.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Yeah the example in the original post just looks like Cover 1, no? If so, the FS isn't even in m2m against the TE. I think Coverage distance has no bearing on what happens in a zone.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
I wonder if it has anything to do with zone spec being deactivated?
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skoll Wolfrun
Hm, that example has the FS lined up on the other side of the field. If he is set to m2m, I would figure he should line up across from the TE unless you are not using the Def Play Creator.


???

Set to cover man w/o move and that's easy enough to accomplish in DPC...

 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Yeah, there are a variety of ways you can accomplish what the FS was doing. I can guaranty it was NOT a cover one.

I have variations of plays where I may have the player on Cover Man w/o move and leave them on their normal place on the fielsd and do it for a reason. They'll be in a good spot if the run goes to their starting position, but they also have more than enough speed to move to where the majority of TE passes are caught (like in this circumstance) except in Season 12 they STOP or SLOW DOWN and allow the player to make the easy catch and then close.

Its new Behaviour.

You can ALSO accomplish that sort of motion by setting a specific zone and the player will begin their move to that zone at the start of a pass play.

There are multiple things you can do to create motion in the defensize secondary and make it harder for offenses to know exactly what your defense is doing.

In this specific case, the FS was set to cover the TE without a move. As you can see from the speed script/scouting utility the FS got over 30 speed while the TE only had 15. You can also see from the speed graph, the FS dips severely while the ball is in the air and then once the ball is caught accelerates sharply and makes the play. By watching the dots frame by frame, you can see the same. When using the dottrails you can see them _compress_ as the FS WIATS FOR THE CATCH before closing.

This is new behaviour for Season 12, at least the frequency is, and I have a hard time justifying it as 'players aren't perfect and sometimes they fail' as stated by Cryptio last time I posted this and he locked it.

Its very frequent behaviour and if you look at that teams history (Sea Monkeys) we're not a bunch of scrubs with rotten builds. Until last season where we were promoted above our levels and were regularly playing teams with 5-10 more levels AND good builds, we had a 55 game winning streak. We are again playing teams who average more levels than ourselves and we've not lost yet this season.

This is just something I am seeing on coverage, mostly on the Backs and TE's coming out of the backfield or off the LoS. They are granted a cushion in coverage still. One that shold not exist. This may also be related to how CB's will move backwards when the ball is in the air, away from their coverage, and then once the ball is caught, close and tackle.

Semi-Aggressive coverage model sems to be part of the issue, and if it is, then its not coded well/properly.
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98

This is just something I am seeing on coverage, mostly on the Backs and TE's coming out of the backfield or off the LoS. They are granted a cushion in coverage still. One that shold not exist. This may also be related to how CB's will move backwards when the ball is in the air, away from their coverage, and then once the ball is caught, close and tackle.

Semi-Aggressive coverage model sems to be part of the issue, and if it is, then its not coded well/properly.


I agree that it's happening a whole lot more this season and makes trying to cover the TE/Backs a chore. Even happens when you throw a CB on them. It's like they wait for the catch then pounce. Maybe the sim code already has the catch being made and the graphic representation is just off. I don't know, but it is annoying to watch. Just as annoying as watching a CB on a WR go backwards a few steps when a ball is thrown to the WR they're covering, letting him get a catch, and then moving forward to make a play. Just shouldn't happen like that. Be nice if it were fixed.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
I posted this before and it was locked becuase the player was blamed. Problem is I continue to see this from other players, and other builds in other situations and there seems to be a problem with coverage _closing_ on their m2m targets.

...

But tis is not 'Semi-Aggressive' its frikken stupid coverage. Players should not be pausing to allow the catch and then try to make the tackle. FS in this example has Ball Hawk and Zone Specialist as well. There is no good reason for them to slow down to near a stop to allow the catch.


Looks to me like....

1. FS is moving to cover the TE
2. FS sees the pass moves to try and deflect it at optimal spot, can definitely see BH kick in
3. FS realizes he can't deflect, moves to intercept TE at optimal angle
4. TE slows down to catch the ball, throwing off FS angle
5. FS adjusts and makes the tackle.

The problem is that 3,4,5 all happen within a few ticks making him very herky jerky as he makes cuts and looks to recover.
 
bccomstock
offline
Link
 
Does he have the Jackhammer VA? Could that trigger and cause him to try to wait for the TE to make the catch and then knock it loose?
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
He's got a few points in Jackhammer, but that shouldn't cause a pause, and if it is, then it needs to be fixed.

My own guess is semi-agressive coverage. If its this, Bort needs to look at the behavious of semi-aggressive because its too soft at present.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.