Edited by jktooley on Nov 1, 2009 00:29:18
jktooley
offline
offline
Dpride59
offline
offline
Neither are an exploit are they? They overloaded the right side, both times, you didn't have enough guys to pick them up....
If they didn't get a sack, it would be bugged as hell, that is how teams get sacks in the NFL, they overload a side, and go for it. How should the oline block 4, and 5 guys coming from one side?
If they didn't get a sack, it would be bugged as hell, that is how teams get sacks in the NFL, they overload a side, and go for it. How should the oline block 4, and 5 guys coming from one side?
jktooley
offline
offline
tthe LDE pinches inside only gauging the NT as a threat and lets the LDE/SS run free... how's that not an exploit... If you're assuming that line/defender reaction is NFL like, than yeah, I can see you not thinking it's an exploit. In current GLB where blocker/defender interaction is nowhere near lifelike, than it's an exploit... because there's no way to train your blockers to make the hot read...
Sik Wit It
offline
offline
Well the 1st and the 3rd one have the bug where the RT blocks the NT instead of the LDE right in front of him. Post it in bugs imo.
In the 1st one they might've gotten the sack anyways. The 2nd one is just a legit sack.
In the 1st one they might've gotten the sack anyways. The 2nd one is just a legit sack.
sjmay
offline
offline
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Well the 1st and the 3rd one have the bug where the RT blocks the NT instead of the LDE right in front of him. Post it in bugs imo.
In the 1st one they might've gotten the sack anyways. The 2nd one is just a legit sack.
The 1st one isn't a bug, if the RT takes the LE, that opens up that gap for the SS and MLB, if the RT takes the middle, it opens up the outside for the LE and SS, how is having to make a choice a bug?
Well the 1st and the 3rd one have the bug where the RT blocks the NT instead of the LDE right in front of him. Post it in bugs imo.
In the 1st one they might've gotten the sack anyways. The 2nd one is just a legit sack.
The 1st one isn't a bug, if the RT takes the LE, that opens up that gap for the SS and MLB, if the RT takes the middle, it opens up the outside for the LE and SS, how is having to make a choice a bug?
TrevJo
offline
offline
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Well the 1st and the 3rd one have the bug where the RT blocks the NT instead of the LDE right in front of him. Post it in bugs imo.
In the 1st one they might've gotten the sack anyways. The 2nd one is just a legit sack.
+1. That QB appears to be quite slow which hurt him on the 2nd one imo.
Well the 1st and the 3rd one have the bug where the RT blocks the NT instead of the LDE right in front of him. Post it in bugs imo.
In the 1st one they might've gotten the sack anyways. The 2nd one is just a legit sack.
+1. That QB appears to be quite slow which hurt him on the 2nd one imo.
sjmay
offline
offline
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Well the 1st and the 3rd one have the bug where the RT blocks the NT instead of the LDE right in front of him. Post it in bugs imo.
In the 1st one they might've gotten the sack anyways. The 2nd one is just a legit sack.
If you watch the 1st one again, 5 blockers, 7 blitzers, 2 should probably have a free lane, and to my surprise, 2 did, the LE and the SS, the LE was not right in front of him, it was a bit more staggered than you are saying, but regardless, that was a pick your poison like I mentioned above.
Well the 1st and the 3rd one have the bug where the RT blocks the NT instead of the LDE right in front of him. Post it in bugs imo.
In the 1st one they might've gotten the sack anyways. The 2nd one is just a legit sack.
If you watch the 1st one again, 5 blockers, 7 blitzers, 2 should probably have a free lane, and to my surprise, 2 did, the LE and the SS, the LE was not right in front of him, it was a bit more staggered than you are saying, but regardless, that was a pick your poison like I mentioned above.
TrevJo
offline
offline
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Well the 1st and the 3rd one have the bug where the RT blocks the NT instead of the LDE right in front of him. Post it in bugs imo.
In the 1st one they might've gotten the sack anyways. The 2nd one is just a legit sack.
The 1st one isn't a bug, if the RT takes the LE, that opens up that gap for the SS and MLB, if the RT takes the middle, it opens up the outside for the LE and SS, how is having to make a choice a bug?
Perhaps. There are three guys on the inside (DT, NT, MLB) and two on the outside (SS and LE). The C, RG, and RT combine to block all the inside guys. That makes sense from an inside-outside perspective, and it even looks like the RT is dropping back until the point at which the MLB starts to blitz. The SS does gets to the party a lot quicker than the MLB, so at best it's a poor choice to try to block the MLB instead of the SS.
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Well the 1st and the 3rd one have the bug where the RT blocks the NT instead of the LDE right in front of him. Post it in bugs imo.
In the 1st one they might've gotten the sack anyways. The 2nd one is just a legit sack.
The 1st one isn't a bug, if the RT takes the LE, that opens up that gap for the SS and MLB, if the RT takes the middle, it opens up the outside for the LE and SS, how is having to make a choice a bug?
Perhaps. There are three guys on the inside (DT, NT, MLB) and two on the outside (SS and LE). The C, RG, and RT combine to block all the inside guys. That makes sense from an inside-outside perspective, and it even looks like the RT is dropping back until the point at which the MLB starts to blitz. The SS does gets to the party a lot quicker than the MLB, so at best it's a poor choice to try to block the MLB instead of the SS.
sjmay
offline
offline
Originally posted by TrevJo
Perhaps. There are three guys on the inside (DT, NT, MLB) and two on the outside (SS and LE). The C, RG, and RT combine to block all the inside guys. That makes sense from an inside-outside perspective, and it even looks like the RT is dropping back until the point at which the MLB starts to blitz. The SS does gets to the party a lot quicker than the MLB, so at best it's a poor choice to try to block the MLB instead of the SS.
Yep, the better argument is the 3rd one, and even then, that LE must have hit all the SA at once, because he was past that RT before the RT knew the ball was snapped, and once that happened, the RT went the LI who was blitzing, but again, that is a meh at best, could it a be a bug, perhaps, could it a be a really poor roll by the RT, perhaps,
Perhaps. There are three guys on the inside (DT, NT, MLB) and two on the outside (SS and LE). The C, RG, and RT combine to block all the inside guys. That makes sense from an inside-outside perspective, and it even looks like the RT is dropping back until the point at which the MLB starts to blitz. The SS does gets to the party a lot quicker than the MLB, so at best it's a poor choice to try to block the MLB instead of the SS.
Yep, the better argument is the 3rd one, and even then, that LE must have hit all the SA at once, because he was past that RT before the RT knew the ball was snapped, and once that happened, the RT went the LI who was blitzing, but again, that is a meh at best, could it a be a bug, perhaps, could it a be a really poor roll by the RT, perhaps,
Forbin
offline
offline
On the 1st and 3rd, all you have to do is look at that side of the line. More rushers are coming than there are blockers. The 2nd one is the classic exploit that teams have been using all season - works with both NT and DT, if they're quick enough.
Edit: Even then, the SS would have come free, if they picked up the MLB. Would have given the QB a tiny bit more time, though.
Edit: Even then, the SS would have come free, if they picked up the MLB. Would have given the QB a tiny bit more time, though.
Edited by Forbin on Nov 1, 2009 01:08:02
sjmay
offline
offline
Originally posted by Forbin
On the 1st and 3rd, all you have to do is look at that side of the line. More rushers are coming than there are blockers. The 2nd one is the classic exploit that teams have been using all season - works with both NT and DT, if they're quick enough.
Wait, the 2nd one is an exploit because the SS and MB blitzed?
Unless you mean the exploit is by putting them on the 2nd level staggered with the RE and NT, then blitzing, and even then, why would you consider that an exploit? With a 5 man WR, that is a 4 man front trying to block six, where's the exploit?
On the 1st and 3rd, all you have to do is look at that side of the line. More rushers are coming than there are blockers. The 2nd one is the classic exploit that teams have been using all season - works with both NT and DT, if they're quick enough.
Wait, the 2nd one is an exploit because the SS and MB blitzed?
Unless you mean the exploit is by putting them on the 2nd level staggered with the RE and NT, then blitzing, and even then, why would you consider that an exploit? With a 5 man WR, that is a 4 man front trying to block six, where's the exploit?
Forbin
offline
offline
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Forbin
On the 1st and 3rd, all you have to do is look at that side of the line. More rushers are coming than there are blockers. The 2nd one is the classic exploit that teams have been using all season - works with both NT and DT, if they're quick enough.
Wait, the 2nd one is an exploit because the SS and MB blitzed?
Unless you mean the exploit is by putting them on the 2nd level staggered with the RE and NT, then blitzing, and even then, why would you consider that an exploit? With a 5 man WR, that is a 4 man front trying to block six, where's the exploit?
It happens no matter how many are blitzing. The G on either side will ignore the DT if you have someone coming from the 2nd level.
Originally posted by Forbin
On the 1st and 3rd, all you have to do is look at that side of the line. More rushers are coming than there are blockers. The 2nd one is the classic exploit that teams have been using all season - works with both NT and DT, if they're quick enough.
Wait, the 2nd one is an exploit because the SS and MB blitzed?
Unless you mean the exploit is by putting them on the 2nd level staggered with the RE and NT, then blitzing, and even then, why would you consider that an exploit? With a 5 man WR, that is a 4 man front trying to block six, where's the exploit?
It happens no matter how many are blitzing. The G on either side will ignore the DT if you have someone coming from the 2nd level.
Sik Wit It
offline
offline
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Well the 1st and the 3rd one have the bug where the RT blocks the NT instead of the LDE right in front of him. Post it in bugs imo.
In the 1st one they might've gotten the sack anyways. The 2nd one is just a legit sack.
The 1st one isn't a bug, if the RT takes the LE, that opens up that gap for the SS and MLB, if the RT takes the middle, it opens up the outside for the LE and SS, how is having to make a choice a bug?
Ok fair enough.
It just looks like it all stems from the same faulty logic though that I've seen being posted in bugs.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=818513&pbp_id=9852134
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=818513&pbp_id=9848256
On these two it looks like the LOT is trying to pick up the blitz from the MLB?
This is the best example I have:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=881863&pbp_id=9570327
No blitz on the strong side, yet my RT leaves the LDE untouched to double team the NT.
It could be a failed vision check, but I've seen it happen in situations where the OT shouldn't even have to make a decision.
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Well the 1st and the 3rd one have the bug where the RT blocks the NT instead of the LDE right in front of him. Post it in bugs imo.
In the 1st one they might've gotten the sack anyways. The 2nd one is just a legit sack.
The 1st one isn't a bug, if the RT takes the LE, that opens up that gap for the SS and MLB, if the RT takes the middle, it opens up the outside for the LE and SS, how is having to make a choice a bug?
Ok fair enough.
It just looks like it all stems from the same faulty logic though that I've seen being posted in bugs.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=818513&pbp_id=9852134
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=818513&pbp_id=9848256
On these two it looks like the LOT is trying to pick up the blitz from the MLB?
This is the best example I have:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=881863&pbp_id=9570327
No blitz on the strong side, yet my RT leaves the LDE untouched to double team the NT.
It could be a failed vision check, but I've seen it happen in situations where the OT shouldn't even have to make a decision.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























