User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Gongadan
offline
Link
 
When you scout a team and look at the offensive passing data, some of the results are...well, ambiguous, misleading, or just plain nutty all come to mind.

It appears that it shows the yards gained on passing play calls. Which makes sense. What's odd is that it includes rushing yards gained when the QB had to run for it.

In a recent pee wee game (http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=870242), I see that the STARS threw 2/11 for 11 yards.

From the scouting page (http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=6895&m=offense&for_team_id=0), I see that the STARS called 10 passes, 6 of which resulted in gains of a total of 56 yards.

That means that on four passing play calls (6-2), the QB must have scrambled or audibled into a run and gained 45 yards. So let's do the math:

2/11 means 2 complete passes, 9 incomplete passes. That's 11 plays. Four other gains means there must have been 4 scrambles. That's 15 plays. But the scouting page says 10 plays. So, uh, ? Something is wrong here.

Ignoring the phantom plays, it's still misleading to show that my team had gains on 6/10 passing plays, when 4 of those gains came in the form of QB scrambles or audibles. I'm not sure how best to represent this, possibly putting an extra section in there for QB scrambles/run audibles to make it clear which plays ended with someone running across the LoS instead of a pass. Unless a scout is really careful, it's going to look like this team is a pretty good passing team, when clearly it is not.

I considered the possibility that it was counting defensive penalties during a passing play as gains, but there were no pass interference calls, and the gains were 5.5, 5.5 (the two passes), 6, 7, 16, and 16 (the four probable runs).

I guess it's possible that five run plays got audibled into passes (which went incomplete), which would explain the 11 passing attempts even if 4 of the 10 passing calls turned into runs.

Or there's a bug somewhere.
Edited by Gongadan on Oct 18, 2009 22:36:24
 
Gongadan
offline
Link
 
Oh yeah, and upon further review of the game, I couldn't find two plays that went for 16 yards each (which the scouting report says happened on a Slot In N Up and a WR Screen). So, er, what gives? Is data from the wrong game creeping into the scouting report?
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Scouting thingy is pretty fucked up, tbh. It never shows accurate data.
 
Link
 
or you aren't using it right
 
bamaplaya1
offline
Link
 
requesting that this be moved to bugs
 
blankspace
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bamaplaya1
requesting that this be moved to bugs


Request = Accepted
 
PING72
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by happylittletrees
or you aren't using it right


I've seen what he is saying as well. You go to scout a single game and it says a play was run 1 time for 37 yards. I went through the whole play-by-play and there was never a play that went for 37 yards.
 
BansheeTime
offline
Link
 
Apparently I duplicated this thread, even though my bug was a visual bug, and not a statistical one. I can't see the percentage bars properly. Anybody else have this problem?
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BansheeTime
Apparently I duplicated this thread, even though my bug was a visual bug, and not a statistical one. I can't see the percentage bars properly. Anybody else have this problem?


Are you zoomed in or out without realizing it. Hold control and press '0' and see if that fixes it. The reason I locked as a duplicate is because technically we could have a different thread for each little problem with the scouting page. It makes it easier to keep them all together on one thread.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
There are some known Issues with the Scouting reports dealing with dropped balls.

To tell the Truth, scouting reports can not be trusted at this time.

I will get back to this when there is a fix.
 
BansheeTime
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cwisler
Originally posted by BansheeTime

Apparently I duplicated this thread, even though my bug was a visual bug, and not a statistical one. I can't see the percentage bars properly. Anybody else have this problem?


Are you zoomed in or out without realizing it. Hold control and press '0' and see if that fixes it. The reason I locked as a duplicate is because technically we could have a different thread for each little problem with the scouting page. It makes it easier to keep them all together on one thread.


I'm at the same view I'm always at. It's at 100% like always.
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BansheeTime
Originally posted by cwisler

Originally posted by BansheeTime


Apparently I duplicated this thread, even though my bug was a visual bug, and not a statistical one. I can't see the percentage bars properly. Anybody else have this problem?


Are you zoomed in or out without realizing it. Hold control and press '0' and see if that fixes it. The reason I locked as a duplicate is because technically we could have a different thread for each little problem with the scouting page. It makes it easier to keep them all together on one thread.


I'm at the same view I'm always at. It's at 100% like always.


Did you try Control + '0'? There's nothing that shows what % you're zoomed in on your browser.
 
BansheeTime
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cwisler
Originally posted by BansheeTime

Originally posted by cwisler


Originally posted by BansheeTime



Apparently I duplicated this thread, even though my bug was a visual bug, and not a statistical one. I can't see the percentage bars properly. Anybody else have this problem?


Are you zoomed in or out without realizing it. Hold control and press '0' and see if that fixes it. The reason I locked as a duplicate is because technically we could have a different thread for each little problem with the scouting page. It makes it easier to keep them all together on one thread.


I'm at the same view I'm always at. It's at 100% like always.


Did you try Control + '0'? There's nothing that shows what % you're zoomed in on your browser.


I use IE. There's a drop box at the bottom right that lets me pick from different zoom percentages ranging from 50% to 400%.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
I will repeat this.

There are some known Issues with the Scouting reports dealing with dropped balls.

To tell the Truth, scouting reports can not be trusted at this time.

I will get back to this when there is a fix.
 
crazy454
what
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
I will repeat this.

There are some known Issues with the Scouting reports dealing with dropped balls.

To tell the Truth, scouting reports can not be trusted at this time.

I will get back to this when there is a fix.


I bet is is the caught/knocked loose which we should do away with all together.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.