User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Ok, so here's a positive reinforcement idea instead of level caps, to "encourage" parity instead of force it. This has been brought up before, but I'm posting it here for further review:

(note this is in "suggestions," not "announcements")

Power gamers and those looking for loopholes to pwning n00bs care about one thing: XP. They want to be uber player, gain the max XP possible, and look at their pretty attributes.

1) For every game you play, the experience an individual player gains is modified based on the levels of your opponents (or of the league) compared to your own, with say, up to a 15% modifier.

2) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's around the same level as you, you get the same XP as you get now.

3) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's better than you, you get an XP bonus.

4) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's worse than you, you get less XP.

Levels could be based on:
1) The average level of the other team, weighted toward starters. A "better" team would be one that was, say, 3 levels higher than you on average. And worse, would be say, 3 levels lower (could be 4/5, dunno).
2) Or, the average level of the league, weighted towards the top. You get a bonus for being below the avg, or a penalty for being over.

Shoot holes in it! What are the exploits?
Last edited Jun 9, 2008 12:53:55
 
Dukester100
offline
Link
 
The obvious 'losing on purpose to get more XP'

Make your team bad so you always face better teams and get more XP.

Great idea thuogh, I love it.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
I dont like 5 or 6....just becasue you win big doesn't mean you should gain less. I dont like rewarding teams for not winning games. You could "throw" games to try to screw with teams.

1-4 all seem fairly legit though.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
6) If you lose by a blowout, you get more XP.

Shoot holes in it! What are the exploits (besides the possible game throwing with 5/6)?




Exploit for #6 should be obvious. I envision a handful of 0-16 teams losing by a hundred points every game. Blowouts should be reduced experience for both sides - realistically, there's not much to be learned from games that aren't competitive anyway.
 
HustonJ
offline
Link
 
How would the comparative levels work out?

Would it be your individual level against the average of specific opposing players you interacted with during the play?

Would it be your individual level against the opposing team's average level?

Would it be your team's average level against the opposing team's average level?

Would it be based on the entire roster, or on the players on the field?

There are advantages and disadvantages to each of the above. The most accurate ones would, of course, require more code and processing time.

Honestly, though, I'm just curious about what you have in mind. I don't particularly desire this be added to the system.
 
amo368
offline
Link
 
I like it. It seems more realistic. 5 and 6 are a no go though... ;-)
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Bort

6) If you lose by a blowout, you get more XP.

Shoot holes in it! What are the exploits (besides the possible game throwing with 5/6)?




Exploit for #6 should be obvious. I envision a handful of 0-16 teams losing by a hundred points every game. Blowouts should be reduced experience for both sides - realistically, there's not much to be learned from games that aren't competitive anyway.


Could take away 5/6, I guess. I was just thinking it would be nice to help those blowout teams catch up a little. But you're probably right about the 'sploits.
 
naraic
offline
Link
 
I like but don't punish a one or two level gap harshly, also provide options for a league to call for accelerated relegation of teams that don't belong on a case by case basis. Look at USA pro, some of the best and the worst teams in GLB
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HustonJ
How would the comparative levels work out?

Would it be your individual level against the average of specific opposing players you interacted with during the play?

Would it be your individual level against the opposing team's average level?

Would it be your team's average level against the opposing team's average level?

Would it be based on the entire roster, or on the players on the field?

There are advantages and disadvantages to each of the above. The most accurate ones would, of course, require more code and processing time.

Honestly, though, I'm just curious about what you have in mind. I don't particularly desire this be added to the system.


I was thinking something like average levels, weighted toward starters, or something along those lines. I agree that it might be more realistic if it was based on the guy you were facing, but it might be hard to deal with, especially for a position like K or P or QB who doesn't have a set opponent.
 
scarletmbb
offline
Link
 
I like it, except for 5/6. I can be done without that to prevent exploitation. Why don't you just use a ratio as a multiplier, like (avg opp lvl)/(your avg lvl) and adjust it with starters?
Last edited Jun 6, 2008 17:01:43
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
I'd almost prefer just a small boost of XP for players playing against players who are higher level and no penalty otherwise
 
justafish2002
offline
Link
 
I like it, but a bad team could screw over people in an entire league.

If an owner brings in a bunch of lvl 1s, they'll get max XP while the other teams will get min XP.
 
Colorful
offline
Link
 
Don't like 5 because scoring points should be a teams objective not trying to win by the minimum amount of points possible. Don't like 6 since it's unrealistic, for example, I've played DE before, but if you put me in against a NFL OT I'd spend the entire game getting run over and I wouldn't learn anything except that I'm clearly not good enough to play in the NFL.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Again, this punishes good teams that stay together. Why?

If a BBB team wins back-to-back championships, they could STILL find themselves in a league where they are being punished for leveling wisely.

There are already SOOOOOOOOO many aspects of this game that balance things for lower-leveled players:

1. XP gets harder to earn.
2. Training is more expensive and yields lower results.
3. SP cost become less valuable as stats increase.

As the game advances everyone is already going to end up at EXACTLY THE SAME skill level, why add even more?
 
madet0rder
offline
Link
 
Yeah i definitely like those, except 5 and 6. I think for doing that, it should be based on the individual you are facing. However, if you are someone that doesnt have a set opponent, then base it on the average of the guys that you are going against.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.