So, I'm working all the coach stuff out, getting code written, interface finished up, etc, etc and I realize:
We really have nothing exciting for these coaches to spend money on.
Obviously, we want the coach to require the team to pay him. He needs some reason to have a salary.
We can just do training and coach equipment like players, but it might be nice to have something else as well, if there's any ideas out there.
Any ideas?
Some answers about coaching: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3229435
Some coaching ideas:
Originally posted by Time Trial
Seriously... there's enough arguments about the ability to boost and use custom EQ, I'd like some sort of guarentee that the winner of Pee Wee Golold isn't going to be the team with 10 coaches.
Originally posted by aceinthehouse
Head Coach=1000 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
The Highest title in the game.Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improves the whole team.
Offensive Coordinator=750 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improves all players on the Offense side of the ball.Defense and Special teams are NOT included.
Defensive Coordinator=750 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and All upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all players on the Defense side of the ball.Offense and Special Teams are NOT included.
Team Scout=500 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
All players and coaches can use the default scouting option that is available. However,having a hired Scout allows for this position to look at all opposing teams skills and attribute distributions and other cool scouting options for this postion as well.
QB Coach=300 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all QB's on team roster.
RB Coach(& FB's)=300 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this coach,improve all RB's on team roster.
WR Coach(& TE's)=300 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all WR's on team roster.
Defensive Line Coach=200 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all WR's on team roster.
Linebackers Coach=200 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this coach,improve all LB's on team roster.
Secondary Coach=200 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all Secondary on team roster.
Offensive Line Coach=100 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all Offensive Line on team roster.
Special Teams Coach=100 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all Special teams players on team roster or Depth Chart.
Equipment Manager 50 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements with equipment is for only 1 player at a time.But an equipment manager can get equipment that the other Coaches don't have access too.
Note...the "any and all upgrades" I have listed in particular Coaching positions refer to equipment,% upgrades and anything that said coach would improve.
So if you are a WR coach and you have available equipment to share to the team,then you can only share that equipment to WR core.
Off coor...the whole offense only...
Head coach..everyone and so on.
Any player that retires after the required 440 days of age can choose to pay whatever Flex for whatever Coaching position he desires.
HOWEVER...Any player that chooses to Coach the position for which he retired from, gets bonuses that a regular retired player/different position coach would NOT recieve.
Haven't quite decided on whether I would want to allow a player to move up in the coaching ranks/position by paying additional flex like from equipment manager to head coach if you pay the additional 950 flex....or to make it a "set in stone" once you decide decision.
Anyways...this is what I would like to see personally. More individuality,more coaching positions and options for teams to hire instead of a guy that just does everything...lol and of course difference salaries for these coaches,so teams can actually hire a coach they can afford,one they specifically need but enough restriction to add a bit of realism.
Originally posted by jmarter
Give each team owner a "stipend" to hire coaches, creating a separate salary fund. Coaching salaries are set and the stipend is dependent on the league. For instance:
Head Coach - 200K per season
Coordinators (offensive, defensive, ST) - 100K per season
Position coaches (Oline, Backfield, Receivers, DLine, LBs, Secondary) - 50K per season
Pro Level - 800K stipend
AAA - 500K
AA - 200K
Lastly put in prerequisites that Position coaches cannot be hired without coordinators and coordinators cannot be hired without a head coach.
Originally posted by James1985
What about giving the coach bonuses based on career achievments?
Like Trophys earned, Championships won,Indorsments given. That sort of thing.
What the bonus will be will have to be based off the achievment of course but Ill leave that up to Bort. Anyone else like the Idea or just me.
Originally posted by crazy454
Make the Coaches that are 440 days old start with more Pts and XP
Make the younger coaches start with less.
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
We are yet to give the rl coaches the controls they need and we're gonna make a whole nother class of player to screw with the sim even more. Vet points were still causing problems last season, how many seasons are going to get jacked up by all the crazy bonuses coaches are putting on?
Coaches are a cute Idea, but totally unnecessary, and this implementation is ridiculous.
It's just a bad Idea.
Is there a thread for campaigning against this abomination somewhere?
Originally posted by jbleich
So I think it's pretty much a go and on the outset I do think the coaching thing is a good idea and adds another fun element to the game, but here is what I see the problem to be.
Team owners already have a tough enough time keeping 55 players on the team and now you are telling them they have to recruit 10 coaches on top of that. It makes it much much harder and more time consuming to run a team. Also we will have to pay them salary. We are already not able to pay for equipment and now you add on additional salary. Sure the Media revenue helped, but it sureley did not fix the equip problem. Not only that, on Season 12 Day 1, how many coaches are even going to be available if they have to be 440 days old? I'm guessing not enough to have every team be able to gram 10 of them.
My suggestion....
Cap the number of coaches a team can have to like 2-4. It lessens the recruiting burden, but not only that it brings in a strategic part of the game on deciding which positions are of most need for your team. Less salary to pay as well..
Thoughts?
Originally posted by yello1
COACH CREATION
Coaches would be created in one of two ways, either by initial creation the way an agent creates any player, or by the conversion of a retired player character into a coach.
FROM SCRATCH Coaches created from scratch would start as one of several archtypes with a skewing of their starting skill ranges to fit that archtype. Coaches of any archtype, however, would be able to fill any coaching slot without out of position like penalties. The archetypes would just allow agents to steer their Coach to the type of skills he would like him to have.
CONVERSION Coaches converted from retired players would also be created as a chosen archetype with a similar rolling process for his coaching attributes. However after creation the accomplishments and football skills and player attributes of the Player would modify some attributes and abilities of the Coach he becomes (for example, a player’s Football Skills and Physical Attributes will all transfer 1:1, replacing whatever was rolled).
COACH QUALITIES
Coaches would have the following qualities, Level (starts at 1 for both Scratch creations and rolls, goes up with experience and boosting), Physical Attributes (exactly the same as those for Players, which may modify some coaching abilities), Football Skills (exactly the same as those for Players, which may modify some coaching abilities), Personality Attributes (new set of attributes, such as Adaptability, Appearance, Charisma, Voice, Scowl) Coaching Skills (Offensive Strategist, Defensive Strategist, Special Teams Strategist, Offensive Tactician, Defensive Tactician, Special Teams Tactician, Player Scouting, Analyst, Intuition, Haggling, Smooth Talk, Intimidate, Inspire, Speaking, Teaching, Leadership, Physical Training, People Skills) and Coaching Tricks (Veteran Ability kind of stuff) and Coaching Tools (like Equipment).
COACHING ARCHTYPES
General Manager: Off Field Suit that effects various aspects of Franchise operations: Owner, General Manager, Assistant General Manager for Financial Operations, Assistant General Manager for Public Relations
Play Calling Coaches: On Field Play Calling Coaches, who make game plans and run practices effecting various aspects of player performance: Head Coach, Offensive Coordinator, Defensive Coordinator, Special Teams Coach. Primary Skills: Leadership, Offensive Strategist, Defensive Strategist, Special Teams Strategist, Secondary Skills Offensive Tactician, Defensive Tactician, Special Teams Tactician
Training Coaches: Practice Field and Gymn Coaches, who provide bonuses to player performance: Position Coaches (QB, O&D Line, Receivers, Running Backs, Secondary, Linebackers, Kickers), Team Physical Trainers, Team Equipment Coaches, Personal Trainers.
Scouts: Behind the scenes personnel who scout out opposing players and breakdown game films, giving bonuses to their team in play against those teams: Scout, Film Analyst
Media: Non Coaching Personnel whose reporting on games influences fan base loyalty, ticket sales and fame and player and coach confidence etc, with some being employed by teams for local coverage, others competing for League Wide Coverage slots (optionally awarded kinda like Endorsement deals to top media types with only the best of the best getting a shot at World League coverage etc). Media types not only inherently boost these things, but can focus their coverage. Who they focus on and how well those players/coaches/teams do (or don’t do) and their skills will determine their success each week: Beat Reporter (Team Print), Team Play by Play Caller (Radio&TV), Team Color Analyst, Local Sports Radio Host, Local TV Sports Commentator, League slots for same (for Play by Play and Color Analyst - 6 pairs for each League with 3 per conference, call a game of their choice further boosting ticket sales fame etc for those games) for each League. (More on this later perhaps)
More later
Originally posted by gherman
I would like to do the same thing EXCEPT we instead create the coaches from birth and train him like a player good idea imo same rules apply u will be able to upgrade ur coaching abilities and so on...you get xp like a player from games or day to day u can also instead of train "Create plays" or something like training needs a lot of work but I think this idea gives everyone a fair shot think of the newbies
List of other stuff people want to see other than coaching: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3231880
We really have nothing exciting for these coaches to spend money on.
Obviously, we want the coach to require the team to pay him. He needs some reason to have a salary.
We can just do training and coach equipment like players, but it might be nice to have something else as well, if there's any ideas out there.
Any ideas?
Some answers about coaching: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3229435
Some coaching ideas:
Originally posted by Time Trial
Seriously... there's enough arguments about the ability to boost and use custom EQ, I'd like some sort of guarentee that the winner of Pee Wee Golold isn't going to be the team with 10 coaches.
Originally posted by aceinthehouse
Head Coach=1000 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
The Highest title in the game.Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improves the whole team.
Offensive Coordinator=750 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improves all players on the Offense side of the ball.Defense and Special teams are NOT included.
Defensive Coordinator=750 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and All upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all players on the Defense side of the ball.Offense and Special Teams are NOT included.
Team Scout=500 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
All players and coaches can use the default scouting option that is available. However,having a hired Scout allows for this position to look at all opposing teams skills and attribute distributions and other cool scouting options for this postion as well.
QB Coach=300 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all QB's on team roster.
RB Coach(& FB's)=300 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this coach,improve all RB's on team roster.
WR Coach(& TE's)=300 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all WR's on team roster.
Defensive Line Coach=200 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all WR's on team roster.
Linebackers Coach=200 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this coach,improve all LB's on team roster.
Secondary Coach=200 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all Secondary on team roster.
Offensive Line Coach=100 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all Offensive Line on team roster.
Special Teams Coach=100 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all Special teams players on team roster or Depth Chart.
Equipment Manager 50 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements with equipment is for only 1 player at a time.But an equipment manager can get equipment that the other Coaches don't have access too.
Note...the "any and all upgrades" I have listed in particular Coaching positions refer to equipment,% upgrades and anything that said coach would improve.
So if you are a WR coach and you have available equipment to share to the team,then you can only share that equipment to WR core.
Off coor...the whole offense only...
Head coach..everyone and so on.
Any player that retires after the required 440 days of age can choose to pay whatever Flex for whatever Coaching position he desires.
HOWEVER...Any player that chooses to Coach the position for which he retired from, gets bonuses that a regular retired player/different position coach would NOT recieve.
Haven't quite decided on whether I would want to allow a player to move up in the coaching ranks/position by paying additional flex like from equipment manager to head coach if you pay the additional 950 flex....or to make it a "set in stone" once you decide decision.
Anyways...this is what I would like to see personally. More individuality,more coaching positions and options for teams to hire instead of a guy that just does everything...lol and of course difference salaries for these coaches,so teams can actually hire a coach they can afford,one they specifically need but enough restriction to add a bit of realism.
Originally posted by jmarter
Give each team owner a "stipend" to hire coaches, creating a separate salary fund. Coaching salaries are set and the stipend is dependent on the league. For instance:
Head Coach - 200K per season
Coordinators (offensive, defensive, ST) - 100K per season
Position coaches (Oline, Backfield, Receivers, DLine, LBs, Secondary) - 50K per season
Pro Level - 800K stipend
AAA - 500K
AA - 200K
Lastly put in prerequisites that Position coaches cannot be hired without coordinators and coordinators cannot be hired without a head coach.
Originally posted by James1985
What about giving the coach bonuses based on career achievments?
Like Trophys earned, Championships won,Indorsments given. That sort of thing.
What the bonus will be will have to be based off the achievment of course but Ill leave that up to Bort. Anyone else like the Idea or just me.
Originally posted by crazy454
Make the Coaches that are 440 days old start with more Pts and XP
Make the younger coaches start with less.
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
We are yet to give the rl coaches the controls they need and we're gonna make a whole nother class of player to screw with the sim even more. Vet points were still causing problems last season, how many seasons are going to get jacked up by all the crazy bonuses coaches are putting on?
Coaches are a cute Idea, but totally unnecessary, and this implementation is ridiculous.
It's just a bad Idea.
Is there a thread for campaigning against this abomination somewhere?
Originally posted by jbleich
So I think it's pretty much a go and on the outset I do think the coaching thing is a good idea and adds another fun element to the game, but here is what I see the problem to be.
Team owners already have a tough enough time keeping 55 players on the team and now you are telling them they have to recruit 10 coaches on top of that. It makes it much much harder and more time consuming to run a team. Also we will have to pay them salary. We are already not able to pay for equipment and now you add on additional salary. Sure the Media revenue helped, but it sureley did not fix the equip problem. Not only that, on Season 12 Day 1, how many coaches are even going to be available if they have to be 440 days old? I'm guessing not enough to have every team be able to gram 10 of them.
My suggestion....
Cap the number of coaches a team can have to like 2-4. It lessens the recruiting burden, but not only that it brings in a strategic part of the game on deciding which positions are of most need for your team. Less salary to pay as well..
Thoughts?
Originally posted by yello1
COACH CREATION
Coaches would be created in one of two ways, either by initial creation the way an agent creates any player, or by the conversion of a retired player character into a coach.
FROM SCRATCH Coaches created from scratch would start as one of several archtypes with a skewing of their starting skill ranges to fit that archtype. Coaches of any archtype, however, would be able to fill any coaching slot without out of position like penalties. The archetypes would just allow agents to steer their Coach to the type of skills he would like him to have.
CONVERSION Coaches converted from retired players would also be created as a chosen archetype with a similar rolling process for his coaching attributes. However after creation the accomplishments and football skills and player attributes of the Player would modify some attributes and abilities of the Coach he becomes (for example, a player’s Football Skills and Physical Attributes will all transfer 1:1, replacing whatever was rolled).
COACH QUALITIES
Coaches would have the following qualities, Level (starts at 1 for both Scratch creations and rolls, goes up with experience and boosting), Physical Attributes (exactly the same as those for Players, which may modify some coaching abilities), Football Skills (exactly the same as those for Players, which may modify some coaching abilities), Personality Attributes (new set of attributes, such as Adaptability, Appearance, Charisma, Voice, Scowl) Coaching Skills (Offensive Strategist, Defensive Strategist, Special Teams Strategist, Offensive Tactician, Defensive Tactician, Special Teams Tactician, Player Scouting, Analyst, Intuition, Haggling, Smooth Talk, Intimidate, Inspire, Speaking, Teaching, Leadership, Physical Training, People Skills) and Coaching Tricks (Veteran Ability kind of stuff) and Coaching Tools (like Equipment).
COACHING ARCHTYPES
General Manager: Off Field Suit that effects various aspects of Franchise operations: Owner, General Manager, Assistant General Manager for Financial Operations, Assistant General Manager for Public Relations
Play Calling Coaches: On Field Play Calling Coaches, who make game plans and run practices effecting various aspects of player performance: Head Coach, Offensive Coordinator, Defensive Coordinator, Special Teams Coach. Primary Skills: Leadership, Offensive Strategist, Defensive Strategist, Special Teams Strategist, Secondary Skills Offensive Tactician, Defensive Tactician, Special Teams Tactician
Training Coaches: Practice Field and Gymn Coaches, who provide bonuses to player performance: Position Coaches (QB, O&D Line, Receivers, Running Backs, Secondary, Linebackers, Kickers), Team Physical Trainers, Team Equipment Coaches, Personal Trainers.
Scouts: Behind the scenes personnel who scout out opposing players and breakdown game films, giving bonuses to their team in play against those teams: Scout, Film Analyst
Media: Non Coaching Personnel whose reporting on games influences fan base loyalty, ticket sales and fame and player and coach confidence etc, with some being employed by teams for local coverage, others competing for League Wide Coverage slots (optionally awarded kinda like Endorsement deals to top media types with only the best of the best getting a shot at World League coverage etc). Media types not only inherently boost these things, but can focus their coverage. Who they focus on and how well those players/coaches/teams do (or don’t do) and their skills will determine their success each week: Beat Reporter (Team Print), Team Play by Play Caller (Radio&TV), Team Color Analyst, Local Sports Radio Host, Local TV Sports Commentator, League slots for same (for Play by Play and Color Analyst - 6 pairs for each League with 3 per conference, call a game of their choice further boosting ticket sales fame etc for those games) for each League. (More on this later perhaps)
More later
Originally posted by gherman
I would like to do the same thing EXCEPT we instead create the coaches from birth and train him like a player good idea imo same rules apply u will be able to upgrade ur coaching abilities and so on...you get xp like a player from games or day to day u can also instead of train "Create plays" or something like training needs a lot of work but I think this idea gives everyone a fair shot think of the newbies
List of other stuff people want to see other than coaching: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3231880
Edited by JcWildcat on Sep 8, 2009 17:51:03
Edited by JcWildcat on Sep 7, 2009 19:08:15
Edited by JcWildcat on Sep 7, 2009 13:24:48
Edited by JcWildcat on Sep 7, 2009 11:49:39
Edited by JcWildcat on Sep 7, 2009 11:48:48






























