User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
On this play: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=750299&pbp_id=6428007

Using my Test Offensive AI I get:
Matching Input
Input Named: 1d

Possible Outputs
8% Outside HB Right, I-Form (run/pass)
4% Inside HB Right, SBack (run/pass)
4% Inside HB Right, I-Form (run/pass)
3% Long WR, WR2 (run/pass)
7% Meduim TE, One Back (run/pass)
7% Medium WR, WR2 (run/pass)
4% Outside HB Left, One Back (run/pass)
4% Inside HB Left, I-Form (run/pass)
5% Medium WR, WR3 (run/pass)
7% Medium WR, WR1 (run/pass)
6% Long WR, WR3 (run/pass)
3% Long TE, I-Form (run/pass)
3% Meduim TE, Two Backs (run/pass)
5% Outside HB Left, I-Form (run/pass)
3% Long TE, One Back (run/pass)
8% Outside HB Right, Pro Set (run/pass)
16% Outside HB Right, SBack (run/pass)
3% Long WR, WR1 (run/pass)

Not a single one of those is an inside FB run.
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
EDIT: LEGIT BUG!!! See my analysis on Page 2.







Go through and double-check all of those outputs, especially the HB runs. Just because you named it "HB run" doesn't mean it's actually set up as an HB run. You may have accidentally selected FB instead of HB as the runner for one of those plays.
Edited by Novus on Aug 24, 2009 02:04:02
Edited by Novus on Aug 24, 2009 02:03:47
 
Kirghiz
offline
Link
 
By the thread title I thought this thread was going to be about the signals to call the play in to the QB being vulgar.

One can assume that you have the AI set to "Exact", auto adjust is turned "off" and your AI overlaps I suppose.......

I have seen the offensive AI doing some strange things a lot this season. Plays being called for players that aren't on the depth chart for that play, sub rates not being followed, plays that aren't in that input, say nothing for bugs with packages, and on, and on. The entire offensive side of the ball has been screwy as hell tbh.
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Yeah I did that. The outputs share the same exact name as the packages used in the output (this input is 100% package based). None of the packages listed have an FB run where it doesn't belong.
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kirghiz
By the thread title I thought this thread was going to be about the signals to call the play in to the QB being vulgar.

One can assume that you have the AI set to "Exact", auto adjust is turned "off" and your AI overlaps I suppose.......

I have seen the offensive AI doing some strange things a lot this season. Plays being called for players that aren't on the depth chart for that play, sub rates not being followed, plays that aren't in that input, say nothing for bugs with packages, and on, and on. The entire offensive side of the ball has been screwy as hell tbh.


My offense has been working as intended. I know, because I scout all of my plays on offense and defense after every game. I've caught several of my own defensive AI errors that way, but my offense has been working perfectly.

I suspect the problems people may be having on offense are due to errors they made to their own AI while trying to get their new Packages up and running. There's room all over the place for tiny little errors to be made when you're re-building your entire offensive AI like that.

But of course it's easier for people to blame some mysterious programming bug than to admit that they may have made one crucial mis-click while setting up a complicated set of offensive instructions.
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whitewolf
Yeah I did that. The outputs share the same exact name as the packages used in the output (this input is 100% package based). None of the packages listed have an FB run where it doesn't belong.


Okay, you may want to double-check your Packages then. You know you're looking for an I-formation run, so that narrows it down. You may have simply mis-selected the wrong I-formation run somewhere in one of those packages and accidentally selected the FB run instead of the HB run.

If you want to give me temporary OC access, I can take a look through myself.
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
No I meant I went into every package and checked to make sure the name of the package matched the contents. Since the AI Tester matched the input perfectly I'm assuming that the listed outputs and packages are the only ones that should have been called.

Oh and I meant to say that I have auto-adjust off. And temp access isn't up to me, I'm not the owner. The owner is aware of this thread, he'll chime in if he feels the need I'm sure.
Edited by whitewolf on Aug 24, 2009 00:28:54
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whitewolf
No I meant I went into every package and checked to make sure the name of the package matched the contents.


So, there aren't any accidentally-selected FB runs anywhere in any of your Packages? You're 100% sure at this point? Bet-your-life-on-it sure? Bet-the-championship-on-it sure?

Think about the number of mouse-clicks you had to do to set up your Packages. Dozens, hundreds, maybe thousands.

Now think about the fact that all it would take is a single incorrect mouse-click, just one time out of all of those mouse clicks, and boom, you have an FB run in your offense.

Doesn't make you a bad OC. It just makes you human.

What WOULD make you a bad OC, however, is to stop here and assume it's a bug on Bort's part. Take a few minutes, go through all of your Packages, and make sure you don't have an accidentally-selected FB run in there somewhere. As I pointed out before, you're looking for an I-formation run, so that will help you narrow down what to look out for. Should take you a half-hour, tops.
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Jesus christ, don't be an asshole in the guise of someone trying to help. Yes I checked.
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Geez, don't be an asshole in the guise of someone asking for help.

If you're so offended by someone raising the possibility that you may have mis-clicked your mouse at some point, you need to get a new offend-o-meter.



Anyone else want to try helping this guy? I'm done.
 
Bogleg
offline
Link
 
I (the owner) already went through every aspect of this -- AI tester says 1d, each output name matches the package name that's selected, and each package only has plays that match its name.

EDIT: wow, fireworks while i was clicking through the whole damn AI...

I think Whitewolf considered your assumption that he didn't already check his work as condescending. He's a coder, too; he wouldn't call bug somewhere w/o doing his research first.
Edited by Bogleg on Aug 24, 2009 01:05:16
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bogleg
I (the owner) already went through every aspect of this -- AI tester says 1d, each output name matches the package name that's selected, and each package only has plays that match its name.


You want a second set of eyes to double-check for you?
 
Bogleg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
Originally posted by Bogleg

I (the owner) already went through every aspect of this -- AI tester says 1d, each output name matches the package name that's selected, and each package only has plays that match its name.


You want a second set of eyes to double-check for you?


Sure, why not.. I'd like to get this put to bed.
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
Geez, don't be an asshole in the guise of someone asking for help.

If you're so offended by someone raising the possibility that you may have mis-clicked your mouse at some point, you need to get a new offend-o-meter.



Anyone else want to try helping this guy? I'm done.


What offends me is you saying not once, twice, or even three times but FOUR times that a) I made a mistake (not an offensive statement) but that b) I'm blaming Bort rather than considering the possibility that I made a mistake, and despite me saying twice that I double-checked the outputs, including explicitly saying I went into the packages and double checked you are still insisting that I made the error and are, essentially, calling me a liar. I find that very assholish and offensive.
 
Cornish Rhino
offline
Link
 
Have you got Auto Adjust on? You are winning the game in the third quarter and have been successfully running the ball up to this point.

Do you have any FB running in the Basic Settings?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.