can you tell me how this works for each postition
Forum > FAQ's, Player Guides and Newbie Help > Out Of Postition Penalty, how much
kb2120
offline
offline
all we have ever gotten from Bort are vague things like "not too big" or "that would be a pretty big penalty"
Basically if the player is playing at a 'logical' position that differs from his natural position, then the penalty will be small. For example, TE playing at FB would be small penalty where as DT playing at K would be large penalty.
The out of position penalties are obviously purposefully vague, but you can treat any kind of reasonable position swap as a small penalty.
Just don't try to play your WR at OG or anything silly. Likewise some of the out of position penalties for QB are steep to deter 'Wildcat' type offenses. Both WRs and RBs don't work well as rushing QBs as there is a fairly steep penalty for each respective position.
The out of position penalties are obviously purposefully vague, but you can treat any kind of reasonable position swap as a small penalty.
Just don't try to play your WR at OG or anything silly. Likewise some of the out of position penalties for QB are steep to deter 'Wildcat' type offenses. Both WRs and RBs don't work well as rushing QBs as there is a fairly steep penalty for each respective position.
Joe Buck
offline
offline
Originally posted by kb2120
all we have ever gotten from Bort are vague things like "not too big" or "that would be a pretty big penalty"
actually he has given out the exact numbers for at least some of them, in an indirect way.
Mentioning that QB is the only position that can play QB without a 40% penalty, FS to CB is pretty small like 5%. Good luck finding the posts though!
all we have ever gotten from Bort are vague things like "not too big" or "that would be a pretty big penalty"
actually he has given out the exact numbers for at least some of them, in an indirect way.
Mentioning that QB is the only position that can play QB without a 40% penalty, FS to CB is pretty small like 5%. Good luck finding the posts though!
Joe Buck
offline
offline
From a private forum, where I've archived some of this stuff.
Originally posted by sbuck143
Archiving for future generations......from a thread in November.
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GG
I mean right now, I could transfer all my EQT into one of my RBs throwing, and with their high vision and throwing up to about 30 now, that would do them well enough to throw when needed (short/med passes) and just run the ball all game from QB rush plays. That kind of thing is too cheesey but will be done by some GMs out there.
OOP penalty is fairly high for HB -> QB tho. QB is really the only position that can play QB without at least a 30-40% OOP penalty.
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Bort
OOP penalty is fairly high for HB -> QB tho. QB is really the only position that can play QB without at least a 30-40% OOP penalty.
Um...wow?
I thought OOP topped out at like 15-20%, and most positions were like 5-10%.
Oh no. You really think a DT playing K would only get a 20% penalty? 5% penalties are for the easy position movements like CB -> FS or LB -> DE or something like that.
Originally posted by sbuck143
Archiving for future generations......from a thread in November.
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GG
I mean right now, I could transfer all my EQT into one of my RBs throwing, and with their high vision and throwing up to about 30 now, that would do them well enough to throw when needed (short/med passes) and just run the ball all game from QB rush plays. That kind of thing is too cheesey but will be done by some GMs out there.
OOP penalty is fairly high for HB -> QB tho. QB is really the only position that can play QB without at least a 30-40% OOP penalty.
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Bort
OOP penalty is fairly high for HB -> QB tho. QB is really the only position that can play QB without at least a 30-40% OOP penalty.
Um...wow?
I thought OOP topped out at like 15-20%, and most positions were like 5-10%.
Oh no. You really think a DT playing K would only get a 20% penalty? 5% penalties are for the easy position movements like CB -> FS or LB -> DE or something like that.
Joe Buck
offline
offline
Originally posted by Robbnva
nice pull sbuck, I gues the pee wee team we are doing this season where O-Line is playing every position is gonna suck
we still have slots over in the pee wee recruiting forum if you are interested
no .......what it is, is fvcking sad that I have to do this, squirreling away Bort nuggets to archive them myself, instead of having an OFFICIAL easily accessible source of this information.
FWIW that was from a Nov 2008 post so I bet the OOP's have changed multiple times since then.
nice pull sbuck, I gues the pee wee team we are doing this season where O-Line is playing every position is gonna suck

we still have slots over in the pee wee recruiting forum if you are interested

no .......what it is, is fvcking sad that I have to do this, squirreling away Bort nuggets to archive them myself, instead of having an OFFICIAL easily accessible source of this information.
FWIW that was from a Nov 2008 post so I bet the OOP's have changed multiple times since then.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























