User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
im317
offline
Link
 
so, i wanted to share a little conversation i had with support about the East special teams MVP, which went to Prime Time Sayers of the Keystone State Puppies. now those of you who played us(Tulsa) undoubtedly know we have our own special teams MVP candidate Jeff Green, he finished in second place.

now i looked at the numbers(can be seen below) and this baffled me. so i contacted support to see if it was a mistake. below is a copy of our conversation so far. let me know your feeling on the issue.

"From: im317
Date: Jul 27, 2009 18:03:41
Subject: minors uncapped #25 east special teams MVP
To: EllisBell

http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=1342544&playoffs=0

http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=332232&playoffs=0

the first player is the leader in the standings with 276 KRs for 6,627 a average of 24 yards per return with 0 TDs. he had 23 PRs for 599.5 yards and average of 26.1 yards per return with 2 TDs. he had 0 STs tackling stats and 11 fumbles, 10 of which he lost.

the second player is second in the standings with 37 KRs for 1,430.5 yards an average of 38.7 yards per return with 4 TDs. he also has 185 PRs for 7,002 yards(in 15 games, let someone else take PRs 1 game) an average of 37.8 yards per return with 79 PR TDs. he had 0 fumbles and 60 special teams tackles with only 2 missed tackles.

all STs tackle stats collected via greesmonkey script

how can you possible justify the first player winning the STs MVP award over the second player? note that the second player had a KR TD in the last game of the regular season a match up of 15-0 teams.

respectfully im317, co-owner of the team the second guy plays on."




"---------- Original message ----------
From: EllisBell
Date: Jul 30, 2009 00:41:49
Subject: Re: minors uncapped #25 east special teams MVP
To: im317


im -

Thank you for reaching out to us.

The MVP race is determined by more than just a player's stats, it is also determined by their overall contribution to the team's total offense. In this case the first player listed must have defeated your player though I am sure it was a close call.

Regards.
EB"



"---------- Original message ----------
From: im317
Date: Jul 30, 2009 08:47:44
Subject: Re: minors uncapped #25 east special teams MVP
To: EllisBell

so, being the KR/PR man on a very bad team will win you the STs MVP, got it. the fact that we actually needed our guy to win close games means nothing."


now admittedly that was a tad out of line but look at what im dealing with here, anyways lets move on.


"---------- Original message ----------
From: EllisBell
Date: Jul 30, 2009 13:28:12
Subject: Re: minors uncapped #25 east special teams MVP
To: im317

It doesn't mean nothing, and it doesn't always work out this way, it just happened to in this situation."


now i responded with my latest message just a few minutes ago and have yet to receive a reply.

"our team compiled a total of 16,525.5 yards, passing+rushing+return yards. our return man had a total of 8,432.5 yards or ~51% of our total yardage.
there team compiled a total of 11,433.5 yards passing+rushing+return yards. there return man had a total of 7,226.5 yards or ~63.2% of there total yardage.
so there player accounted for 11.3% more or there total yardage then ours did.
however our team scored a total of 1,874 points and our guy accounted for 498 of them or ~26.5% of our total points.
there team scored a total of 315 points and there guy accounted for 12 of them or ~3.8% of there total points
so our guy accounted for 22.7% more of our total points then theirs did.

so 22.7% of points is not better then 11.3% of yards?"
 
mark4041
offline
Link
 
Good luck with that.. looks to me like you have a legitimate beef, but I doubt you'll ever get anyone to admit it.
 
im317
offline
Link
 
just got another reply.

"Were all the TD's you counted on special teams?"

of course they were, however i noticed that he also had a fumble recovery TD on a kickoff. so he actually accounted for 6 more of our points then i thought.
 
grossman
offline
Link
 
It's not that their equation is broken that annoys me. It's that they won't fix it when the proof is so obviously handed to them via the method they requested.
 
comicfanman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by grossman
It's not that their equation is broken that annoys me. It's that they won't fix it when the proof is so obviously handed to them via the method they requested.


They should also take in account quality teams played
I mean no harm to either guy - but PR TD in a Championship Game against the Saipan Sin-Eaters

Green Deserves it
 
im317
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by comicfanman
Originally posted by grossman

It's not that their equation is broken that annoys me. It's that they won't fix it when the proof is so obviously handed to them via the method they requested.


They should also take in account quality teams played
I mean no harm to either guy - but PR TD in a Championship Game against the Saipan Sin-Eaters

Green Deserves it


he also had a KR TD in the match up of 15-0 teams in the season finally, which helps more since they don't count the post season. we also used someone else on PRs for 1 game because we were having issues getting everyone on offense max xp against the worst teams. we needed someone not as good to get the plays. if that was the difference i will be very pissed, i mean it would have been 10 PR TDs and 750 PR yards easy.
 
comicfanman
offline
Link
 
GL with it - fighting a losing battle in the end I think, but way to go to bat with for your players
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.