User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Recaps > This was a TD.
Page:
 
Brett Snyder
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=684056&pbp_id=18222267

No Sir.
 
SPYFELLOW
offline
Link
 
lol that is one of the most ridiculous plays i have ever seen
 
Kitna
offline
Link
 
lol Fail
 
bigfatguy64
offline
Link
 
loldots ftl
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Isn't it supposed to be a safety if he recovers it out of the endzone, and then returns it for -.5 yds for a "touchback"?

Funny play though.
 
Rodion
offline
Link
 
We don't know for sure if he recovered it out of the endzone. The game counts yardage inside the endzone too (as you can see by 100+ yard INT returns), meaning he could have gotten the ball in the endzone already and then lost 0.5 yard.
 
IloveDefense
offline
Link
 
text>dots
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Seeing as I'm from SK, two Moose Jaw Teams playing each other is funny to me, because I'm not sure that there are that many people living in Moose Jaw that can even play football, let alone support two teams... Most of them are going to drive to Regina to watch the Saskatchewan Roughriders.

But I digress...

Awesome replay imo!
 
Link
 
wait.... if the fumble went backwards and when the defender recovered it and it was a touchback, wouldnt that mean he was already in the endzone?
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rodion
We don't know for sure if he recovered it out of the endzone. The game counts yardage inside the endzone too (as you can see by 100+ yard INT returns), meaning he could have gotten the ball in the endzone already and then lost 0.5 yard.


Oh

Good point.
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
HB fumbled/tackled before the ball broke the plain, so no TD. Ball continues forward mometum and lands in endzone. Under Bort rules, this is a safety. Remember, Bort doesn't claim to use NFL rules.
 
Kitna
offline
Link
 
ok for all the people that dont know basic football

if you recover a fumble in the endzone it counts as a touchback
if you recover the fumble in the endzone and go backwards but not out of the back of the endzone its a touchback
if you recover the fumble in the endzone and go backwards though the back of the endzone thats a safety
if you recover the fumble outside of the endzone (say the 2 yard line) then go back into the endzone and get tackled thats a safety
Edited by 19JMAN19 on Jul 25, 2009 12:38:18
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 19JMAN19
ok for all the people that dont know basic football

if you recover a fumble in the endzone it counts as a touchback
if you recover the fumble in the endzone and go backwards but not out of the back of the endzone its a touchback
if you recover the fumble in the endzone and go backwards though the back of the endzone thats a safety
if you recover the fumble outside of the endzone (say the 2 yard line) then go back into the endzone and get tackled thats a safety


Yeah I know the rules. I assumed he recovered it out of the endzone, and the (-.5 yd return) brought him into the endzone, then he got tackled. Which would be a safety.

I forgot it counted yardage in the endzone as well, so he probably recovered it in there.
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 19JMAN19
ok for all the people that dont know basic football

if you recover a fumble in the endzone it counts as a touchback
if you recover the fumble in the endzone and go backwards but not out of the back of the endzone its a touchback
if you recover the fumble in the endzone and go backwards though the back of the endzone thats a safety
if you recover the fumble outside of the endzone (say the 2 yard line) then go back into the endzone and get tackled thats a safety


This isn't basic football. Look at the play AFTER the safety... Bortball doesn't do a free kick, it does a kickoff.
 
bigfatguy64
offline
Link
 
i never knew if you ran out of the back of the endzone it was a safety
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.