User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Change Tiebreaker System from single "walkthrough" of the steps to as many times as are needed
Linkzmax
offline
Link
 
Currently, this is the only information from the Wiki on breaking ties for seeding:
"When two or more teams have the same regular season record, seeding comes down to the following tiebreakers.

To determine the winner of a tie within a Conference the following Tiebreakers go into effect:

1. If there are only 2 teams tied (same record), higher seed is the winner of the head-to-head match up.
2. If there are more than 2 teams tied (same record), then it's based upon these factor in this order:
1. Number of head-to-head wins against the other tied teams with the same record.
2. Number of total points scored.
3. Number of total points allowed. "

I mostly agree with the factors and the order, (though in the case of two tied teams that tied when facing each other during the regular season additional steps are needed) but it seems that in the case of 3 or more teams the factors are only calculated once. I understand this is probably done because it was easier to code, but to be truer to the NFL it should be done multiple times.
From http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?page=tiebreakers
"OTHER TIE-BREAKING PROCEDURES
1. Only one club advances to the playoffs in any tie-breaking step. Remaining tied clubs revert to the first step of the applicable division or Wild-Card tie breakers. As an example, if two clubs remain tied in any tie-breaker step after all other clubs have been eliminated, the procedure reverts to step one of the two-club format to determine the winner. When one club wins the tie breaker, all other clubs revert to step 1 of the applicable two-club or three-club format."

As an example, here's a quote from the Canada AA#1 forums under the current system where 5 teams were tied at 7-9 and fighting over th 7th through 11th seeds:

Originally posted by Novus
Wow, 5-way tie at 7-9?

Okay, multi-team ties are broken by the number of victories each team has over the other teams involved in the tie.

Oregon: 3-1
PQ: 2-2
Charlestown: 2-2
Yukon: 2-2
SWO: 2-2

Oh. Hmm... Oregon wins the overall tie-breaker with 3 wins, which locks them in at #7.

For the remaining teams, since they're all tied up at 2-2 each, it would go to points-scored as the next tie-breaker.

PQ: 933
Charlestown: 681
Yukon: 588
SWO: 534

For the record, Oregon only had 653 points. But since they won the most head-to-head games against the other 7-9 teams, they got to skip the points-scored tie-breaker. That's why they're #7 even though they scored fewer points than both PQ and Charlestown.

Make sense?

Now I'm in total agreement that Oregon should have the #7 spot due to their head-to-head record. However, now that the #7 spot is decided, a new tiebreaker would begin for the remaining 4 teams fighting over 8-11. So they should have their head-to-heads recalculated, which would result in:
CC: 2-1
Yukon: 2-1
PQ: 1-2
SWO: 1-2
At this point, PQ and SWO would be eliminated from the running, and as with NFL procedures, CC and Yukon would revert to step 1 of the 2-team tiebreakers. CC had won their head-to-head, which would give them #8 spot.

Although it wouldn't matter for playoffs, head-to-head would be recalculated once again for the remaining three teams:
Yukon: 2-0
SWO: 1-1
PQ: 0-2
Here Yukon would earn the #9 spot. Then SWO's head-to-head win over PQ would give them #10, leaving PQ at #11.


So in summary, the tiebreaking procedures should be changed to restart from Step 1 for all remaining teams anytime that a single team wins a seed to be more like the NFL which is what GLB is based off of.
 
bamaplaya1
offline
Link
 
http://goldenboat.files.wordpress.com/2009/06/seal-of-approval.jpg
 
bamaplaya1
offline
Link
 
up
 
northstar09
fist flint
offline
Link
 
+1
 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
So are you saying in a 3 way tie, all went 1-1, that first spot goes to most points scored, and second spot goes to winner of the head to head of the other two teams? I guess that makes more sense
 
gossimer626
offline
Link
 
I'd sign this petition....
 
Linkzmax
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
So are you saying in a 3 way tie, all went 1-1, that first spot goes to most points scored, and second spot goes to winner of the head to head of the other two teams? I guess that makes more sense

Exactly
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.