User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Is This Play Broken?
Page:
 
Liquidlex
offline
Link
 
This play seems undefendable:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=691414

5WR offense. Dime Defense. 4 WR run 'go' routes. The WR who breaks underneath is open every single time.

I have seen this play over a dozen times on several different teams and in several different games.

Has anyone ever seen this play defended differently where the 5th WR was covered? Otherwize it seems like a broken play.
 
Favre4Ever
offline
Link
 
LOL.. this EXACT play happened with my GMed team today. I was hoping the PC would starting calling more 5 WR sets...
 
Randy03Texags
offline
Link
 
They are playing Cover-2 Man there, I see no problem with now that was defended given the defensive scheme that was called. There are zone defenses that would have shut that down. Also it seems that "cover long" was the defensive playcall there, so again the defense was doing as programmed, had a shorter or even medium playcall been called it would have been stopped.
 
ptompkins
offline
Link
 
Sounds like your players need more 'vision'
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
I saw that play too, same result. The above guy says it's cover-2, which is maybe true, but it looks to me like they are planing man with the SS assigned to the WR who does the out route. (In a true cover 2 zone, the CB should stay down with the WR who does the out route.) If it's man to man, the SS needs to play up tighter. Not sure if that is a problem with the way defense is programmed, or maybe the SS needs to adjust tactics to play tighter man to man.
 
Randy03Texags
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
I saw that play too, same result. The above guy says it's cover-2, which is maybe true, but it looks to me like they are planing man with the SS assigned to the WR who does the out route. (In a true cover 2 zone, the CB should stay down with the WR who does the out route.) If it's man to man, the SS needs to play up tighter. Not sure if that is a problem with the way defense is programmed, or maybe the SS needs to adjust tactics to play tighter man to man.


Not correct, in a cover 2 the safties are in the "umbrellas" to give support over top, he is right where he should be.

http://www.footballtimes.org/Article.asp?ID=167

There are some illustrations for the Tampa-2, the pictures are for max cover of course, but its clear that if you went to man and the (2) was still there where the safties would be, overtop right where they are at.
 
ptompkins
offline
Link
 
First off that line backer was not coving anyone in the backfield. He was just sitting in the middle, zoning. Trips on that left side, the SS should have rolled up into pressed coverage or the LB should have rolled over.

The FS was coving the top 1/2 zone, SS was coving the other top 1/2 zone.

I just don't understand why the LB did not go man. All about vision in this case and Hans Padgett (LB) needs more of it. Then again, he's only a level 2 LB, probably the reason for this totally botched 'D' play. The SS is also only level 2 so that's probably why he didn't see it coming and go grab the WR that was all alone with no one covering him.

Good job on the QB for spotting the open man. That wide that was open was also level 7 and the highest level CB on the field was level 3. Probably another reason for the blown coverage.
 
Randy03Texags
offline
Link
 
Ha I didnt even look at the levels on there man, I just was looking at the response, yeah a bunch of level 2s arent going to execute ANY play that well.

Be happy it wasnt a TD.
 
Leksington
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Randy03Texags
They are playing Cover-2 Man there, I see no problem with now that was defended given the defensive scheme that was called. There are zone defenses that would have shut that down. Also it seems that "cover long" was the defensive playcall there, so again the defense was doing as programmed, had a shorter or even medium playcall been called it would have been stopped.

Can you show me an example?

I understand how and why the play unfolded the way it did. I can think of atleast 5 ways to effectively address that play in real life(the simplest is to come out in a quarter package). However, in the 10+ times I have seen that play, the defense has covered it the exact same way (cover 2 with 4 CBs in man).

I am worried is that a defenses always covers that offensive play that way. Can you show me an example where it is covered properly? I can show you over 10 where it isn't.
 
Randy03Texags
offline
Link
 
I have never seen that play against my team. I examine every play of every game twice (once for fun and once for note taking) and I have never seen that play against my team.

Maybe I am fortunate, or maybe I dont have my defensive settings to whatever yall do.

I know that the last game my defense held the other team to less than 150 yards and 0 points, so we didnt have any passes like that against us.
 
Leksington
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ptompkins
First off that line backer was not coving anyone in the backfield. He was just sitting in the middle, zoning. Trips on that left side, the SS should have rolled up into pressed coverage or the LB should have rolled over.

The FS was coving the top 1/2 zone, SS was coving the other top 1/2 zone.

I just don't understand why the LB did not go man. All about vision in this case and Hans Padgett (LB) needs more of it. Then again, he's only a level 2 LB, probably the reason for this totally botched 'D' play. The SS is also only level 2 so that's probably why he didn't see it coming and go grab the WR that was all alone with no one covering him.

Good job on the QB for spotting the open man. That wide that was open was also level 7 and the highest level CB on the field was level 3. Probably another reason for the blown coverage.

First,
everyone played their position the way they were supposed to. The LB is there to spy the QB. With only 4 linemen pass rushing(versus the 5 o-linemen) the QB could easil run for 10 yards with everyone else covering a go route. The Safeties are obviously playing cover 2 so it isn't their job to drop underneath.

Second, don't look at the levels of the players. I am sure you remember that I said I had seen this play several different places. That was just 1 example of it. The levels of the players in that particular example are irrelevant. I have seen many other teams cover it this same broken way.

You say the defense sucks? Fine. But show me an example of a defense propperly covering that play. I have seen over a dozen times where the WR is open. I have never seen that WR covered when an offense runs that play. All I want is for you to show me 1 example of it being propperly covered and I will be satisfied that it isn't a broken play.

Last edited Apr 3, 2008 23:41:43
 
ptompkins
offline
Link
 
I didn't say that the 'D' sucks, I just said that coverage was blown. How can you play man up on 4 out of 5 wides and then expect zone to cover the 5th guy.

I understand your position, I personally don't look at every play. I see your point about the LB spying the QB I didn't think about that, since that was the case then the D should have switched to cover 1 and pulled the Safety up to man up. It was clearly a 'D' to protect the deep pass which it successfully did.

It's just odd that you would go man up with everyone but their best WR.
 
Leksington
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ptompkins
How can you play man up on 4 out of 5 wides and then expect zone to cover the 5th guy.

Thats the very problem. You can't expect 4 CBs to cover 5 WRs in man.

Maybe there was a miscommunication. I am not saying that the defensive play called should have covered it. I am suggesting that the defense never calls a play that adequately defends it. I am suggesting that a team always responds to that offensive play with that defense call. If defenses never adequately covers that play, then it is broken, hence why I am looking for just 1 example where that offensive play is propperly covered.
 
ptompkins
offline
Link
 
We'll, I guess that's like asking
"What the heck is this FS doing signing autographs in the end zone"

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=640914

But your point is well taken. I'm still thinking if the players in your example had more vision they would have been able to stop the play.
 
Leksington
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ptompkins
We'll, I guess that's like asking
"What the heck is this FS doing signing autographs in the end zone"

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=640914

But your point is well taken. I'm still thinking if the players in your example had more vision they would have been able to stop the play.

To be fair, it is nothing like your FS (who is flirting with the cheerleaders because he knows his CB has the play covered )

In my example, everyone is playing their position the way the play was designed. The problem is not in play execution. It is in the play call.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.