User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > A BETTER fix to Head Fake and Juke
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Bort's fix, to be frank, is not a good sounding one as there are times when a head fake or juke should make multiple guys miss. But something that needs to be fixed is the angle at which a head fake or juke effects a guy and I think that would be a better fix to this problem. A guy chasing a player down will NEVER fall for a head fake so that happening in GLB is screwed up. I think if Bort made it so that certain guys are certain angles to the ballcarrier didn't fall for the fake, it would be better. That way, the ballcarrier could still make 2 guys in front of him miss(like some can) but if a guy was on one side and another is in front, he wouldn't make the guy on the side miss or if a guy is trying to run him down from behind, he wouldn't make that guy stumble. It seems like this would fix multiple problems, thus killing 2 birds with 1 stone instead of just making a bad and unrealistic fix.

Originally posted by Adderfist
If not a cone, Do a proximity check on the dot thats (going to) get faked out. Then if there's anything in that area, have them do a vision check as well.
Edited by jrry32 on Jul 5, 2009 13:42:31
Edited by jrry32 on Jul 3, 2009 20:55:38
 
DL24
offline
Link
 
Finally, a real suggestion instead of just some whining. For that I'll give you a +1. As for the angles-I agree with your reasoning. But we don't even know how the new changes are going to affect games yet. One tick isn't all that long, so who knows what will change yet.
 
B-Raz
offline
Link
 
+1 i like it
 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
I like this suggestion.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DL24
Finally, a real suggestion instead of just some whining. For that I'll give you a +1. As for the angles-I agree with your reasoning. But we don't even know how the new changes are going to affect games yet. One tick isn't all that long, so who knows what will change yet.


I just don't like the sound of it, we haven't seen it yet so maybe I shouldn't be saying it's bad...but it's bad sounding and this would actually fix 2 problems. It seems that GLB really has a poor concept of angles in their sim which is one of the biggest keys to football.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Bort doesn't care what we have to say.

If he did, he wouldn't have ran to make such a violent change, without interacting with the userbase.

Remember how long he had to test the Stun effect for DEs? Why wasn't this tested as thoroughly as that?

I don't get it.

I love your idea Jrry, and I fully agree. But it's just going to be hard for me to believe that he's going to change this, especially with how quickly he jumped into this decision.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
i question i've never quite had definitively answered is whether each player's vision is a circle or a cone.

unless it's the latter, i don't see how bort will be able to easily code this suggestion.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
i question i've never quite had definitively answered is whether each player's vision is a circle or a cone.

unless it's the latter, i don't see how bort will be able to easily code this suggestion.


I honestly don't know. I'd hope it was a cone but it probably is a circle.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Catullus 16
i question i've never quite had definitively answered is whether each player's vision is a circle or a cone.
unless it's the latter, i don't see how bort will be able to easily code this suggestion.

I honestly don't know. I'd hope it was a cone but it probably is a circle.


i've heard so many different answers from people that know a lot more than me that i don't even have a guess.

looking at the o-line, it often seems like OTs have eyes in the back of their heads... so if absolutely forced, i'd say the dots have 360-degree vision.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by Catullus 16

i question i've never quite had definitively answered is whether each player's vision is a circle or a cone.
unless it's the latter, i don't see how bort will be able to easily code this suggestion.

I honestly don't know. I'd hope it was a cone but it probably is a circle.


i've heard so many different answers from people that know a lot more than me that i don't even have a guess.

looking at the o-line, it often seems like OTs have eyes in the back of their heads... so if absolutely forced, i'd say the dots have 360-degree vision.


And I'd totally agree, they have 360 degree everything, I've seen 1 OT engaged with a DT in front of him, disengage the DT and immediately engage the DE behind him.

 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
i question i've never quite had definitively answered is whether each player's vision is a circle or a cone. unless it's the latter, i don't see how bort will be able to easily code this suggestion.

Based on Bort's comments a while back about QBs being able to see a pass rush coming from any direction (suggesting that it's something he might like to fix one day), I'd say that it's definitely a circle. I also agree that changing to a cone would be a difficult coding challenge.

Moreover, jrry32's suggestion wouldn't do anything to solve the current problem of having 3-4 defenders boxing in a RB only to see them all blink repeatedly as he flies right through them. Bort's solution is a good one because it still punishes defenses that don't have enough people playing containment, but doesn't allow juke HBs to remain superhuman and beat entire defenses by themselves.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Catullus 16

i question i've never quite had definitively answered is whether each player's vision is a circle or a cone. unless it's the latter, i don't see how bort will be able to easily code this suggestion.

Based on Bort's comments a while back about QBs being able to see a pass rush coming from any direction (suggesting that it's something he might like to fix one day), I'd say that it's definitely a circle. I also agree that changing to a cone would be a difficult coding challenge.

Moreover, jrry32's suggestion wouldn't do anything to solve the current problem of having 3-4 defenders boxing in a RB only to see them all blink repeatedly as he flies right through them. Bort's solution is a good one because it still punishes defenses that don't have enough people playing containment, but doesn't allow juke HBs to remain superhuman and beat entire defenses by themselves.


And how exactly would it not solve it? Unless all 3-4 players are standing directly in front of the runner, he wouldn't fake them. That's the key to angles. If you have him boxed him, he'll only juke the guys in front of him.
 
kdalton
offline
Link
 
I've seen real life players Juke 3-4 defenders at a time.

The key is to make sure the HBcanonly Juke defenders that are in front of him. i've always thought it seemed odd to see the blinking light when a defender is chasing from behind....Where else might he run? It isn't like the defender will think a left turn might happen.

Just change the code so a defender must be between the ballcarrier and the endzone.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kdalton
I've seen real life players Juke 3-4 defenders at a time.

The key is to make sure the HBcanonly Juke defenders that are in front of him. i've always thought it seemed odd to see the blinking light when a defender is chasing from behind....Where else might he run? It isn't like the defender will think a left turn might happen.

Just change the code so a defender must be between the ballcarrier and the endzone.


Yep or in a certain angle to the ballcarrier. It would be hard to code but it's needed.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
And how exactly would it not solve it? Unless all 3-4 players are standing directly in front of the runner, he wouldn't fake them. That's the key to angles. If you have him boxed him, he'll only juke the guys in front of him.

Because most of those defenders would be in the proposed cone, unless you wanted it extremely small. I'm talking about replays we've seen where the HB is approaching the line of scrimmage and there are 1-2 defenders straight ahead, one ahead and slightly to the left, and another slightly ahead and to the right.


Originally posted by kdalton
I've seen real life players Juke 3-4 defenders at a time.

Really? I watch a lot of football and I can't recall seeing that. In fact, it seems like true "jukes" only happen when a defender is slowing and "breaking down" to engage the ball carrier, then the RB feints in one direction before moving off in the other. HBs certainly are capable of beating 3-4 defenders, but that's usually by cutting back against the grain while the defenders overpursue.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.