Originally posted by Bort
If it didn't attempt the FG, it's because the kick was outside of the kicker's calculated range. The computer knows exactly how far your kicker's max range is based on a formula.
Maybe he was tired from previous kickoffs, or had low morale, and his range diminished by the end of the game.
That sounds like the reason my team's kicker was doing bad for a few games -- he was having 90 energy going into a game. He got back to 100 and it was fixed.
So yeah, OP, that's probably your problem.