User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > GLB Evolution - Decline, Coaching, etc
Page:
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Admin/Mods...

Please see the "10 year decline" thread for the full debate.

But quickly, this suggestion comes from a bunch of suggestions...

1. IF you guys are adamant about forced retirements or player decline, it shouldn't happen at season 10. Too short a time. 12 mnths. Players peak not long enough. So, decline could start around 20 seasons. That's 2 full years of playing.

2. At that time, players are not retired as such, but evolve into coaches that specialize in certain things depending on the kinds of player that got 'retired'. A kicker/punter becomes special teams coach. Etc. If you have multiple players that retire, all it means is you earn more stripes as a coach. Your resume becomes bigger. This will coerce users to create more players so that they can open up different coaching categories for them. So all these coaches become Free Agent coaches. Teams around GLB would try to sign them on to be their coach. The coaches literally bring with them a bonus to certain areas of a team. If you're a defensive LB type of coach, then the team hiring you as DC will bring all their LBs a boost to their play.

3. MMORPG's that succeed continue to find ways to evolve the game for core users, having more things to buy, to do etc, and not seeing an "END" to a character as such. So a player who reaches season 20, HOF type of thing, EVOLVES into a coach. So the core user will now have on his page a bunch of evolved characters---some still active players that he boosts up, skills up, some recently evolved into coaches, who require boosting up, skilling up etc. That character they created can CONTINUE a career in GLB.

4. When they become a coach, they can buy FPs to buy a playbook creator. They can now create their very own offensive and defensive plays and save it as a playbook. They could buy more FPs and buy more 'playbooks'. You can also include buying ready-made playbooks as well.

5. So what you do is replace having multiple players on a user's userpage, to having multiple coaches w/playbooks that can 'play' on various teams.

So now, core users will continue to play GLB beyond season 10. Where a character you create goes thru a career as player (20 seasons), with continued development/boosting and leveling up in that character. And they can now EVOLVE that character to a coach who can be signed to teams on the market. So the userpage continues and evolves, you dont retire away characters to an "END" or have them play on meaninglessly in a CPU-driven old-agers league.

 
Bigdawg_56
offline
Link
 
^bump

Very well thought out and a great idea. You could even add a trophy to an agents homepage for "HOF" players.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
The thing I would stress again because I didnt clarify it well enough is...

A player who 'retires' after 20 seasons, evolves into a coach. So that player is a coach, not YOU. So in fact, if your player is a HB, then you become a RB/OC type of coach. You start off as a RB coach. That character itself starts all over now as a noob coaching character and over another 20 seasons has to boost, level up, buy things that enhance that particular characters coaching resume.

A person like me with 30 players, when they all 'retire' then, they all become coaches specializing in different areas because I have DEs, LBs, K, QBs, HB, WRs, CBs, etc.

So now my GLB userpage still has the same names there. Douglas MacArthur the OT evolves into Douglas MacArthur the OL coach. He starts a new career as level 1 coach. He buys things, plays, playbooks, 'equipment', etc that make him level up. Meanwhile, my George C Marshall WR character evolves into a WR Coach/OC. So my userpage now has 30 different types of coaches there all looking for jobs on teams and needing leveling up. I can always still go out and create a player, and start that whole 20 season process again WHILST having these evolved characters as coaches all on my one userpage.

The whole coaching thing would mean that ALL current teams would eventually have to have a section in the team profile where there are coaching vacancies.

What this would mean is that a team runs the usual default GLB playbook until they can start to hire coaches who bring their own playbooks with them. So it forces teams out there to actively go out and sign coaches --- a HC, DC, OC, maybe even RB, QB, OL, DL, LB coaches. Those assistant coaches bring with them a boost to players in those positions, but do not own any playbooks. While the HC/DC/OC are higher level coaches who have got their own playbooks.

So noob coaches bring a boost to areas of the team.
Elite coaches bring with them their own playbooks they created.
Teams who havent signed any HC/DC/OC have vacancies there and therefore run the GLB default playbook (the one used today).
So it is to a team's interest to go out and actively hire coaches from the FA coaching market.
Last edited May 27, 2008 21:42:50
 
zack661199
offline
Link
 

wont happen dude, might but chances are low as %#!+
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I think it will happen because it's a great solution to what to do with all those thousands of players when they cease developing as players.

And, it creates on-going challenges and options to users to continue playing and buying FPs for 40 seasons at the very least.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Alternatively....

There will still be people who want to continue playing with their players beyond season 20. Who may not want to evolve into a coach.

So...either make it a choice that a user can make with his players. He can "RETIRE" which completely ends their existence and they get a FP refund. He can choose "COACHING" where his character now evolves into a level 1 coach, no turning back, where he will have to spend FPs on etc. He can choose "HOF" which is the same as 'retire' except they dont get a FP refund or they get a smaller refund, and they gain entry into the HOF where the players name is forever reserved. And lastly, he can choose "PLAY ON", where he enters a G-League where he can play forever, or, players who "play on" dont decline for a longer time. Instead of 10 seasons decline, it could be like 40 seasons, where the decline is very minimal or something.

This alternate idea is just to give all those people choices what to do. Because many may not want to have coaches, may just want their players to continue playing. So this whole suggestion thread is a way to make GLB itself a choice-laden game, with a lot of evolution and on-going challenges.
Last edited May 27, 2008 22:02:24
 
Bengals89
offline
Link
 
I like all these ideas. Nice job explaining them.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Alternatively....

There will still be people who want to continue playing with their players beyond season 20. Who may not want to evolve into a coach.

So...either make it a choice that a user can make with his players. He can "RETIRE" which completely ends their existence and they get a FP refund. He can choose "COACHING" where his character now evolves into a level 1 coach, no turning back, where he will have to spend FPs on etc. He can choose "HOF" which is the same as 'retire' except they dont get a FP refund or they get a smaller refund, and they gain entry into the HOF where the players name is forever reserved. And lastly, he can choose "PLAY ON", where he enters a G-League where he can play forever, or, players who "play on" dont decline for a longer time. Instead of 10 seasons decline, it could be like 40 seasons, where the decline is very minimal or something.

This alternate idea is just to give all those people choices what to do. Because many may not want to have coaches, may just want their players to continue playing. So this whole suggestion thread is a way to make GLB itself a choice-laden game, with a lot of evolution and on-going challenges.


I agree with much of this, but not the 20 season part. I think 10 plus a plateau season (little if any decline, but no growth) in Season 11 is fine. I could accept 12 seasons of growth and then a plateau season as well...but no more than 12 plus one plateau season. A season is 45 days, so 12 seasons is truly a year and a half. Then the plateau season he's almost as good as the season before.

And you don't buy your way into the HoF or into having the name reserved. You get that, no matter what you do, on merit if your career is good enough. And you can always (as you can now even with a level 1 newbie retiring) choose to reserve the name for no extra charge.

What I agree with are the options: Coaching, Senior League, or Full Retirement. Whichever you choose, if whatever method is used deems you worthy of the HoF, you get in; but as you say, Full Retirement you get the most FP's back, Senior League/G-League less, and Coaching you give up the FP's you spent.
 
VikesRule
offline
Link
 
I like the idea but the only thing is, you only need one coach per position per team, which means job openings will be very limited for alot of people.

But having it be an alternative to simply retiring and getting a refund is a great idea and would work well.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
The coaching position limit...

As explained. Every team would have positional coaching vacanies where the coach brings with him a boost to the players in that position. An OL coach would bring a boost or specialty of some kind to their OL. I dunno exactly what that OL coach would do as part of his job, but that's something that can be discussed and ideas brought forward.

But the idea would be that there WOULD be jobs for many coaches on the one team. HC, DC, OC, ST, LB, OL, DL, WR, TE, RB, QB, DB coaches. That's 12 coaches. All those positional coaches, would bring a boost/specialty to those positions, but again, not sure exactly how to make those coaches have something to do as part of their job.

Meanwhile, the HC/OC/DC/ST would bring plays/playbooks they created to the team. So collectively they all end up being one playbook that the HC/GM/Owner gets to choose and call when the advanced tactics/playbook upgrades come in.
Last edited May 27, 2008 22:46:25
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I like it...I have thought of trying to introduce a "coach" class into the game at some point, somehow based on existing or retiring players.

If you could basically "re-class" your player into a Lv1 coach and level him up over time to give bonuses to training, morale/chemistry bonuses, etc, it would be cool. The coach's initial stats could even be based on the player's career length and quality.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I also like the playbook idea. That an owner hires coaches who bring with them their own variety and/or tailor-made plays, which then collectively becomes a playbook for that team. Which the Owner/GM can now select stuff from when the advanced tactics updates that Bort is doing come into play.

So teams who dont hire coaches, get a dumbed down default playbook. Forcing them to actively hire coaches.

I like the idea of creating your own plays not just a playbook where you add pre-designed plays into it. But truly free so coaches can literally design almost anything. Trick plays, formations, etc.

To me, that would be to die-for. When I played Madden in the past, I seldom went online, just sat there creating plays and running them in the scrimmage. That's all I ever did lol.
 
BullFrogOnNet
offline
Link
 
awsome ideas...i love this game.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I also think tho that there's still a touchy area around player decline and retirement. Many people may not want to retire or evolve into a coach, but play on as players. So some choice in deciding these things can only be good.
 
Big Brain
offline
Link
 
for the love of H.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.