User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
CTGuyton
offline
Link
 
OK due to popular demand I am releasing the list of those voted onto the probowl team. I put the numbers next to the names and gave them in order of who replied first so some were given there alternate numbers. If there is a ## either they didnt give me a choice or asked me to pick for them so it will be released when I have the rest filled out. if there is no number then I havn't recieved information from them yet.

If you are on this list I have sent PMs to you asking for information to customize the look of you player as well as your attributes by today. If you havn't sent me your attributes yet please do today. Also if you are one of the few who has asked me for another way to get your players built w/o releasing to me the attribute please save your attributes from today and PM me tonight or tomorrow so we can finalize arrangements. And finally if you are the owner of a team that has one of the players that hasn't sent me info yet I would appreciate you to contact me and arrange some way for me to get the attributes of those players also.

Starters are listed at the top and backups below them but no order other than that.

http://www.freewebs.com/flafootball/GLB/ProBowl%20Roster.JPG

edit:
I updated the roster. The Black highlights have sent me info but no attributes and the green highlights have made no contact at all. There is currently 89 players that I have no attributes for and while 111 players have sent them I can't do the sim as is. if anyone has contact with those highlighted or has acess to the attributes I would appreciate any help you can give me. thanks.
Last edited May 28, 2008 02:27:24
 
Link
 
Great Job!

I wish I submitted more of our players (But we were 2 for 2)
 
CTGuyton
offline
Link
 
I was thinking of having every team nominate 10 players. I will weed out to 4 per roster position(50) so there will be a total of 200 players on the ballot. (120 nominated but weeded out for what ever reason) this will help to make sure everyone is represented and we have a good ammount of choice.
 
Link
 
The kicker from AA #1 who made the team is 14/22, 2/5 beyond 40 and 36/42 on extra points. Maybe next year we can have a more realistic and deserving way of selecting the players?

There were 24 other kickers in the conference who made more field goals than Adam Vinateiri.
Last edited May 27, 2008 07:00:12
 
CTGuyton
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GoldenHorseshoe
Maybe next year we can have a more realistic and deserving way of selecting the players?


Originally posted by CTGuyton
I was thinking of having every team nominate 10 players. I will weed out to 4 per roster position(50) so there will be a total of 200 players on the ballot. (120 nominated but weeded out for what ever reason) this will help to make sure everyone is represented and we have a good ammount of choice.


 
Link
 
That's a great idea and you did an awesome job on this. I mean in the actual voting process. I took the voting seriously and picked the players who I thought deserved to be on the team and only voted once. Obviously some other teams decided against doing it that way. I'm not sure how to change it but maybe weigh the voting so that the owners get 50% of the vote and the players get the other 50%?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GoldenHorseshoe
That's a great idea and you did an awesome job on this. I mean in the actual voting process. I took the voting seriously and picked the players who I thought deserved to be on the team and only voted once. Obviously some other teams decided against doing it that way. I'm not sure how to change it but maybe weigh the voting so that the owners get 50% of the vote and the players get the other 50%?


What about the owner who has five players? Do they get to vote 6 times?

 
Link
 
No... what I mean is each owner gets 1 vote but the collective votes are weighted 50% of the outcome. Owners would only get to vote as owners.

Another example of a player who shouldn't be there (from the same team as the kicker) is the WR David Washburn. There are about 26 other receivers who caught for more yards (including 2 CPU players). He's the #2 Wr selected to the Pro Bowl.

My idea might suck but Im just looking for a way that teams like Prison Riot can't get mediocre players voted in.
 
anfiach
offline
Link
 
The problem was more that there weren't enough owners that submitted their guys so some of the better choices didn't even make the ballot. CT said he went thru and removed multiple votes (or tried to) then you have to account for players that didn't bother to vote in the final selection. Obviously nothing is perfect, you can look at the roster and tell but then, hey he is doing this on his own in his own time so it doesn't really matter. He could punch in false data for all we know and most people won't give up their real attributes if any at all so may as well relax and enjoy it for what it is, entertainment.
 
Link
 
I'm totally with you. I don't even know the first thing about organizing something like this so the only thing I can contribute is my suggestions.

CT did a great job and it's totally fun.
 
Rawk02
offline
Link
 
In all honesty the Kicker position should be re-looked at, something was up there:

With players with as many attempts as him (19) he is 3rd from last in percentage

Dead last in XP made %

Less points with xp and fg added together than the top 5 in just xp alone


In fairness to the real kickers in the league, please look at this
 
Meryk
offline
Link
 
Rawk, I forgot to nominate Clark, or chances are he would be up there. He led the league in FGM, and was almost perfect from inside 40.
 
Leprechanus
offline
Link
 
I do appreciate you taking all the time and effort into making this. It's quite a bit of an undertaking.

The only problem I see is there are definately some teams that got left out. Not a one from my team is on there and I know I submitted 6 people.

Also I told people on my team to give a very honest vote and try not to be biased. I'm sure not many others followed the same principle. I just feel bad for those I submitted than anything else, there are some GREAT players on the Turncoats.
 
FBGBullDozier
offline
Link
 
First, this is obviously a learning experience for doing something like this. I think people sharing their ideas constructively would only improve the process next season.

I know it has been debated back and forth, but I think every team should be represented. In a way, it would make things more difficult, but I think one of the things it would help prevent are the players getting left off. I know in the nomination process, I would have liked to have been able to give my nominations with the caveat "if none of these players are voted in, player X really deserves to get recognized." That way, the team owner can ensure that his most deserving player is given a spot on the team. With only 16 teams in each conference, there should be enough spots on a football team for each team to get one player.
 
etchedchaos
offline
Link
 
Goldenhorseshoe to further add irony to the votes from Riot, the #3 Cb in the league (i say #3 as Most think McNally is the better CB and Anfiach is outright the best), got ignored whilst those mediocre players got submitted. I've spoken with my owner over that and am somewhat fine now, but still it makes a interesting thought.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.