User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > Politics and Religion > Something about the Bible I honestly want to know
Page:
 
rams78110
ROIT
offline
Link
 
Anyone who is not a Christian, or who is named Steelers Insider please refrain from posting here.

There are things that are indisputably wrong in the bible. Why do you insist on following it to whatever extent you do, when it has been proven wrong before? Couldnt there be other fallacies in the bible?
 
Sureal
offline
Link
 
Ambiguous question...

What things are indisputably wrong?
What has been proven wrong before?
Who proved them? Links? References?




 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sureal
Ambiguous question...
What things are indisputably wrong?


Many things in the bible are indisputably wrong. For example, Matthew and Luke each claim a different history (and father) for Joseph. One of them is indisputably wrong.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by rams78110
Anyone who is not a Christian, or who is named Steelers Insider please refrain from posting here.

There are things that are indisputably wrong in the bible. Why do you insist on following it to whatever extent you do, when it has been proven wrong before? Couldnt there be other fallacies in the bible?


how does the way people choose to follow their faith effect you?
 
Sureal
offline
Link
 
Are you talking about Joseph being a descendent of David and his father being Jacob?

Well I'm a descendent of my great grandfather but my father has a different name...
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RonaldusMagnus


how does the way people choose to follow their faith effect you?


Gee, I dunno. Perhaps because important people like the president make it a point of being public about their religion? Being Christian is basically saying "I choose to ignore reason and logic and follow a superstition that can be proven false".
 
Thunderoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
Originally posted by RonaldusMagnus

how does the way people choose to follow their faith effect you?


Gee, I dunno. Perhaps because important people like the president make it a point of being public about their religion? Being Christian is basically saying "I choose to ignore reason and logic and follow a superstition that can be proven false".


You seen a certain Southpark episode about Cartman waiting for a wii?
 
Sureal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy


Gee, I dunno. Perhaps because important people like the president make it a point of being public about their religion? Being Christian is basically saying "I choose to ignore reason and logic and follow a superstition that can be proven false".


How is that so? Reasonable as in helping the helpless?

It seems to be reasonable to reform prisons (Wesley) no?
How about the Red Cross (Barton)?
Civil Rights (MLK)?
Hospitals? Many more reasonable situations...

Are you talking about doctrines? If so how are they not reasonable? Any evidenced superstition?
Ad hominems and zingers don't make arguments correct.
Edited by Sureal on Jun 9, 2009 08:14:04
 
NObodyn0se
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sureal
Originally posted by Krunchy



Gee, I dunno. Perhaps because important people like the president make it a point of being public about their religion? Being Christian is basically saying "I choose to ignore reason and logic and follow a superstition that can be proven false".


How is that so? Reasonable as in helping the helpless?

It seems to be reasonable to reform prisons (Wesley) no?
How about the Red Cross (Barton)?
Civil Rights (MLK)?
Hospitals? Many more reasonable situations...

Are you talking about doctrines? If so how are they not reasonable? Any evidenced superstition?
Ad hominems and zingers don't make arguments correct.


Paraphrasing here, but:

Good people would do good things without religion. Bad people wouldn't have NEARLY the power they have without religion.
 
Sureal
offline
Link
 
Then we will have to define religion...

I'll submit to you that the few of many that I have listed adopted to true religion. While the bad (Klan, Nazi, Christian Identity) have not adopted to the true religion that they have claimed but rather encouraged their evil desire to wrong while appealing to an authority that they have misrepresented. Every ideaology has an extreme faction. No matter how you slice it.

Ex:
Can we say that all Americans are xenophobic because a few are? Americans that adhere to the true basis of our national platform would not. But those who are xenophobic and appeal to the Constitution to further their claim would be representing ideal "Americanism" would be in the wrong.
Edited by Sureal on Jun 9, 2009 08:30:52
 
NObodyn0se
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sureal
Then we will have to define true religion...

I'll submit to you that the few of many that I have listed adopted to true religion. While the bad (Klan, Nazi, Christian Identity) have not adopted to the true religion that they have claimed but rather encouraged their evil desire to wrong while appealing to an authority that they have misrepresented. Every ideaology has an extreme faction. No matter how you slice it.


Ah, it's good to see the "No True Scotsman" fallacy is alive and well.
 
jmsne
offline
Link
 
Would one of your groups to find true religion be the catholic church?

Because if so your list of the bad could add up all the bad shit they have done and not even be close to the roman catholic church.. they could add up all the senseless murders and tortures and stealing and corruption and they wouldn't have a prayers chance of being nearly as bad as your favorite catholic organization.
 
Sureal
offline
Link
 
"In situations where the subject's status is previously determined by specific behaviors, the fallacy does not apply. For example, it is perfectly justified to say, "No true vegetarian eats meat," because not eating meat is the single thing that precisely defines a person as a vegetarian."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman
 
Sureal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jmsne
Would one of your groups to find true religion be the catholic church?

Because if so your list of the bad could add up all the bad shit they have done and not even be close to the roman catholic church.. they could add up all the senseless murders and tortures and stealing and corruption and they wouldn't have a prayers chance of being nearly as bad as your favorite catholic organization.


I don't disagree.

Still does not render the Gospel or Christianity unreasonable...
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sureal

Ex:
Can we say that all Americans are xenophobic because a few are? Americans that adhere to the true basis of our national platform would not. But those who are xenophobic and appeal to the Constitution to further their claim would be representing ideal "Americanism" would be in the wrong.


But any religion that uses the bible as its basis will be subject to the same criticisms that its a glorified superstition.
Edited by Krunchy on Jun 9, 2009 08:40:46
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.