User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
The Trade Analyzer does not come close to adequately measuring player values. I sold a Level 3 RB for $150k and a Level 5 SS for $250k last week, and had used CPUs that were on my roster to make the transaction.

Now that I do not have CPUs on the roster, people can only submit offers through PM, since the Analyzer has a cap to it. I have 8 guys on my team that teams are offering in excess of 200k+ and it makes it very difficult to finalize a trade. The only way we can execute the deal is for me to sign dummy CPUs and then make the trade the next day.

Thus it takes 2 days to complete one trade and takes money away from one team and gives it to CPU players in the process. And you cannot argue that the trade analyzer is fair, because I have PM after PM proof that the fair market value for all of these players are worth that much to myself and to the other teams.

When I put my SS5 on the block, I had a guy offering $250k within 5 minutes, I probably could have got a lot more than that too from other teams that were banging on my door.

Can something be done about this? Or at least in the short term if I reach an agreement to trade a player, can I PM Bort to make the swap manually?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by The Strategy Expert
The Trade Analyzer does not come close to adequately measuring player values. I sold a Level 3 RB for $150k and a Level 5 SS for $250k last week, and had used CPUs that were on my roster to make the transaction.

Now that I do not have CPUs on the roster, people can only submit offers through PM, since the Analyzer has a cap to it. I have 8 guys on my team that teams are offering in excess of 200k+ and it makes it very difficult to finalize a trade. The only way we can execute the deal is for me to sign dummy CPUs and then make the trade the next day.

Thus it takes 2 days to complete one trade and takes money away from one team and gives it to CPU players in the process. And you cannot argue that the trade analyzer is fair, because I have PM after PM proof that the fair market value for all of these players are worth that much to myself and to the other teams.

When I put my SS5 on the block, I had a guy offering $250k within 5 minutes, I probably could have got a lot more than that too from other teams that were banging on my door.

Can something be done about this? Or at least in the short term if I reach an agreement to trade a player, can I PM Bort to make the swap manually?


Stop crying TSE
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
It sounds like people are over-valuing players. How is a lv 5 player worth $250k? How much is a level 50 player going to be worth? $250M?
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
It sounds like people are over-valuing players. How is a lv 5 player worth $250k? How much is a level 50 player going to be worth? $250M?


LOL, seriously.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
It sounds like people are over-valuing players. How is a lv 5 player worth $250k? How much is a level 50 player going to be worth? $250M?


I think its the fact that level 5s are the best availble. Once there are guys in the teens or low 20s then there will probably be level 5s wandering all over the place. Seems to me that there are such few players availble (all high level are under contract of course) that any time one is its just a huge bidding match.
 
Link
 
Well I've analyzed the situation very thoroughly, and it seems to me that a lot of teams are severely undervaluing players.

The player is worth that amount because he may have boosting ability/custom equipment, good player build, and the fact that there aren't any Free Agent Level 5 guys out there very often.

So if you want one today, you pay the market price, and I have 8 guys on my team that i have like 8 different teams that all want these guys for 200k, i have some on my trade block I have been offered 300k and I've turned it down because the player is far more rare than the money is and more valuable than the 300k.

Take a level 6 OT for example. Best you can find is a level 4 OT, but that's not any good, because you want the good player now, you dont want to wait, and if you wait, then the OT6 becomes an OT8.

Bort, if you think 250k is a lot of money, I will gladly send you 250k of my money if you will boost my QB 2 levels? That's really what they are paying for. Would you rather have 250k, or the option to boost your players for 125k per level per pop. Teams would do that all day because the level boosts are more more important that the 100 or so whatever K.

But if you want to check my message history, look at all the PMs I received in the last 24 hours since I posted that block, also look at the 2 hours before i Traded the SS5, and you will see the market agrees with me that having a player 1-3 levels higher than the average is worth a HUGE price.

And I can prove it conversley, anybody out there that wants to sell me a Level 9 WR, I will give you a level 7 WR and 250k. That's like boosting my WR 2 levels for the money, its a great bargain for the teams that can afford it. I can't do it for all my players, but I'd like to do it for as many as I can so I can get more high leveled guys on my team.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
TSE just add the cpu's....once you get 2 or more players on each side the trade will let nearly anything go!!
 
Link
 
Somebody also tried to buy Marvin Harrison off my team, they offered 750k. I told him I wouldn't do it for a Million. But if he wanted to go over a Million I would consider it. He said 750k was the most he could do.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Strategy Expert
Somebody also tried to buy Marvin Harrison off my team, they offered 750k. I told him I wouldn't do it for a Million. But if he wanted to go over a Million I would consider it. He said 750k was the most he could do.


Teams will run their finances into the ground offering a million for a player!!
 
Link
 
Most teams cant afford 1M, but some can. It's not for everybody, it's for those that it makes sense.

My team values MH more than 1M, thus I'm one of those teams because you can shoot me an offer for 1M right now and I will say no thanks!

Is that a bad business decision? Maybe in somebody's opinion, maybe in most people's opinions, but definitely not mine. The player is worth more than that in the short term and the long term.

Look at it this way. MH is on a 10 year contract with my team and he is going to be just about the best WR in this whole game in my opinion.

So let's say you offered 1M. That's really 100k per year for service, plus his contract amount.

So if your team could pay only 100k as an annual tax, to be guaranteed to have the best WR on your team each year, that's chump change, considering after future stadium expansions, money is a much larger number system than the 1-2M bankrolls of today.

But in any event, I am sure MH is worth more than 1M and he's not going to be traded for that dollar amount it's going to take a LOT more than that.

Not every player is valued the same way. Let's say I have a Level 6 CB that is only on contract for 2 years and has said he wants to play on a friend's team after that, plus he doesnt boost. Well he's not worth as much because you only get him for 2 years, maybe i sell that guy for 150k, because he isn't a long term asset?

So one level 7 player can be worth 1.5M, while another level 6 player is only 150k. It depends on the situation and what the team's objectives are for that player short term and long term, and still across the board, I have 3 dozen teams in the last 2 weeks that have offered multiple hundreds of K's for players, because they look at it the same way I do, almost. I have turned down most of those offers because I think they are just shy of hitting the right price, and I know a larger offer is just around the corner when another team wakes up and realizes the value of high level active humans.
Last edited Apr 3, 2008 11:31:46
 
iglesis
offline
Link
 
Econ 101, the value of any good is determined by the market.

This is not an open market however, each transaction takes place "in secret".

Trade's need to be open for all to see.

Currently owners are wasting their money on players, rather than upgrading stadiums in order to pull in more revenue.

It is a marathon, not a sprint...
 
Cybershot
offline
Link
 
I sold 5 level ones for 600k. shhh

But seriously, that deal was worth it for both sides - which is ALL THAT SHOULD MATTER!
 
DigitalDaggers
Admin
offline
Link
 
lol. sounds like there are going to be lots of broke owners.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DigitalDaggers
lol. sounds like there are going to be lots of broke owners.


And this of course is correct. DD is always correct no doubt about it!!

Oh and you will renegotiate that 10 year deal. I can give a 99.5% gurantee!!
 
Brooks
offline
Link
 
I have a level 5 corner with building kick return abilities and only make in the $40,000 range. I am happy with my contract, it helps the team reach its goals.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.