User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
I made sure to changed the Offensive AI on yesterday for today's game. We used to run about 40% on first down. I wanted to run 100% on first down this game. I set the 4 inputs for run at 10, 40, 30, 20 respectively representing

1. Outside Pitch
2. Inside random
3. Outside Handoff
4. Big I left side run


We ran once...one time on first down. It's the very first setting in the AI. there's no quarter specifics to override it. We don't have a down by 7 so pass override either.

It makes no sense that the offensive AI did something totally different than what it was supposed to do.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=511030
Edited by mocfam10 on May 17, 2009 14:40:31
 
al0x
offline
Link
 
Auto adjust was off and follow AI exactly was on?
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Big-I does not exist.

Are the plays you specified in your playbook? Did you specify a formation? Rusher? There has to be an exact match for whatever criteria you specify, in your playbook.

The times that the Big-I got rolled, the sim used football logic, and called a play. The other instances, I don't know without seeing your playbook and AI.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alex2544
Auto adjust was off and follow AI exactly was on?


That's irrelevant.
 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
Yes, it is irrelevant. If I check the box that says, enable Offensive AI...then it should be enabled right? Meaning, it should use that to determine plays.

if you have random outside run as an output, then it should select at least one of the outside runs randomly correct? All 4 were set to randomly select the play. So, all I need is technically one play in each group in order to work. Not to mention, you HAVE to have at least one play per category in the playbook. That being said, the only run plays I removed were singleback runs. So, everything else SHOULD have been available to be selected.

As far as Big I goes....ok..maybe not. But even if Big I doesn't come up 20% of the time....what about the other 80% of the time? One 1st down run.....one. One, all game long. which mod wants AI access for proof?

Forbin,

as said above, I didn't specify a play. I made it random from the run group. So, Outside run....but randomly select the formation.
Edited by mocfam10 on May 17, 2009 14:59:50
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mocfam10
Yes, it is irrelevant. If I check the box that says, enable Offensive AI...then it should be enabled right? Meaning, it should use that to determine plays.

if you have random outside run as an output, then it should select at least one of the outside runs randomly correct? All 4 were set to randomly select the play. So, all I need is technically one play in each group in order to work. Not to mention, you HAVE to have at least one play per category in the playbook. That being said, the only run plays I removed were singleback runs. So, everything else SHOULD have been available to be selected.

As far as Big I goes....ok..maybe not. But even if Big I doesn't come up 20% of the time....what about the other 80% of the time? One 1st down run.....one. One, all game long. which mod wants AI access for proof?

Forbin,

as said above, I didn't specify a play. I made it random from the run group. So, Outside run....but randomly select the formation.


Alright. So, what are your run left/right percentages in basic settings, and how many runs to the left/right did you have in each category in the playbook?

If you had at least 1 run left and 1 run right in each category (inside, outside handoff, outside pitch), then you're absolutely right that it should have worked as you set it up.


Technically, it is possible that the 20% output got called close to 100% of the time. It's rather unlikely, but given enough games, it WILL happen. I've seen similar results occur, which is just how the odds work out.

If you flip a coin 1 million times, you're going to see a run of all heads or all tails for quite a few flips. Same theory here. Without seeing the AI & playbook, that's the only conclusion I can come to myself.
 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
The basic is set to 20/80. I sent you a PM
 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
Thanks Forbin for all your help. Much appreciated...
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
Originally posted by alex2544

Auto adjust was off and follow AI exactly was on?


That's irrelevant.


Actually it's not. If he falls behind early w/o follow my AI exactly checked, that clearly would explain more pass plays being called.
 
smittdog101
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Originally posted by Forbin

Originally posted by alex2544


Auto adjust was off and follow AI exactly was on?


That's irrelevant.


Actually it's not. If he falls behind early w/o follow my AI exactly checked, that clearly would explain more pass plays being called.


I don't think this is completely true. 100% run would still be 100% run. I have never used the "follow exactly" either. Just enable AI.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Originally posted by Forbin

Originally posted by alex2544


Auto adjust was off and follow AI exactly was on?


That's irrelevant.


Actually it's not. If he falls behind early w/o follow my AI exactly checked, that clearly would explain more pass plays being called.


This is wrong. I've never used "Follow my AI exactly", and I do not have any problems. Considering my offensive AI design is in use on multiple top teams in various leagues, I'd say it works fine without checking that box.


If you have an input covering any given specific situation, auto adjust will not kick in.
 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Originally posted by Forbin

Originally posted by alex2544


Auto adjust was off and follow AI exactly was on?


That's irrelevant.


Actually it's not. If he falls behind early w/o follow my AI exactly checked, that clearly would explain more pass plays being called.




Actually, it is. If being tied, then down by 7 is considered down by a LOT, then everyone's AI is out the door after the first TD. To get exactly one run on offense on 1st down isn't explained by this. A LOT of teams don't check the follow my AI exactly. it's already been known to cause problems. I'd say more than 60% don't use it. And I've never had to use it before. Yet, the sim decides to do the exact opposite. Interesting... Forbin did shed some light on the subject though. I'll just simply the AI from now on.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.