Does anyone know how they work? On the Garuda ST MVP there are 2 punters, OK, we are a big part of special teams. However, 1 of the punters averages 39 yards per kick. What's so special about that?
Himewad
offline
offline
Supposedly, the strength of schedule plays a large part. I'm a little skeptical, though. When we played the team with the #1 offensive MVP in Garuda (Xavier Banks), we shut him down and he remained at #1. We held the MVP halfback to 4 yards on 2 carries and 27 yards on 3 catches, and the sim is impressed by that? Nothing against Mr. Banks, but he's not the conference MVP to this point.
I don't care if my guys aren't #1, but we should have played a big part in knocking down that guy, IMO. If you're really the MVP, you need to produce in the games against the highest level of competition.
I don't care if my guys aren't #1, but we should have played a big part in knocking down that guy, IMO. If you're really the MVP, you need to produce in the games against the highest level of competition.
nigbot4000
offline
offline
yeah, I wonder about the MVP setup myself. My RB leads in yards and TD's on the ground by a good margin but is behind Banks. Also, on the awards page he shows up as the #2 Off. player but the #3 RB.
I think SOS does have something to do with it, guess we will see how it all pans out
I think SOS does have something to do with it, guess we will see how it all pans out
Himewad
offline
offline
Kibbie deserves it A LOT more than Banks right now, you're absolutely right.
What awards page are you talking about?
What awards page are you talking about?
fliphusker
offline
offline
Banks put up 80 yards on us on ike 3 carries, glad he did not carry more, but he is not deserving to even being on the mvp page. As we are a passing team, our rb is still in top five for yareds and tds, he is still not mvp worthy though, unfortunately none of our players right now are either.
But to throw out the question as it is aways, can a mvp be from a bad team? Or is it someone who leads his team to ta tite?
Should a player on a bad team who lead them to thei victories be outshadowed by a guy who puts up big numbers against bad teams, while he is sorta a cog, be more important?
Ghere is a prime example. Barry Sanders rushes for 1800 yards, and a dozen tds, and Marshall Faulk rushes for 1500 and 8, but on a winning team
Like the n
NFL I am sure GLB adds some kind of crappy formula to the mix, thus skewing players performance on better teams, as opposed to the actual best player in the league. Thus, what exactly is the MVP, is it the player who makes the best difference to his team, or is the best player of the league?
But to throw out the question as it is aways, can a mvp be from a bad team? Or is it someone who leads his team to ta tite?
Should a player on a bad team who lead them to thei victories be outshadowed by a guy who puts up big numbers against bad teams, while he is sorta a cog, be more important?
Ghere is a prime example. Barry Sanders rushes for 1800 yards, and a dozen tds, and Marshall Faulk rushes for 1500 and 8, but on a winning team
Like the n
NFL I am sure GLB adds some kind of crappy formula to the mix, thus skewing players performance on better teams, as opposed to the actual best player in the league. Thus, what exactly is the MVP, is it the player who makes the best difference to his team, or is the best player of the league?
Himewad
offline
offline
Unless a player's stats are other-worldly on a mediocre team, I believe the league MVP should come from one of the top teams in the league. Just my opinion.
Himewad
offline
offline
Here is my pitch for my team's best offensive performers for MVP:
QB Sean Gunther ... 413-for 522 for 5,959 yards and 86 TD
HB Gale H. Sayers ... 108 rushes for 1,452 yards and 24 TD, 100 catches for 1,862 yards and 28 TD
Tearing it up, even against the top teams. We have handed the #2 and #3 teams in our conference their only losses of the season by a combined score of 115-to-50. Gunther was 48-for-64 (75.0% completion rate) for 858 yards (13.4 yards per attempt) and 6 TD in those two games, while Sayers had 13 rushes for 182 yards (14.0 per rush) and 3 TD, and 12 catches for 228 yards (19.0 per catch) and 2 TD.
QB Sean Gunther ... 413-for 522 for 5,959 yards and 86 TD
HB Gale H. Sayers ... 108 rushes for 1,452 yards and 24 TD, 100 catches for 1,862 yards and 28 TD
Tearing it up, even against the top teams. We have handed the #2 and #3 teams in our conference their only losses of the season by a combined score of 115-to-50. Gunther was 48-for-64 (75.0% completion rate) for 858 yards (13.4 yards per attempt) and 6 TD in those two games, while Sayers had 13 rushes for 182 yards (14.0 per rush) and 3 TD, and 12 catches for 228 yards (19.0 per catch) and 2 TD.
Hank Stram
offline
offline
HB Joe Kibbie of Myanmar. This season, he is the definitive best halfback in the league...and we don't overdo it with him. He has less than 18 carries per game.
The fact that Komodo has a dual rushing/passing MVP threat going above just underscores how much more valuable Kibbie is.
The fact that Komodo has a dual rushing/passing MVP threat going above just underscores how much more valuable Kibbie is.
Edited by Thul on May 20, 2009 18:23:19
Edited by Thul on May 20, 2009 18:22:59
Himewad
offline
offline
No doubt, Kibbie is having a monster season. I still like the fact that Kibbie had his worst rushing game of the season against the Komodo Dragon (104 yards), and it was also the game in which he had his highest number of rushes (27).
fliphusker
offline
offline
Think Jim Brown put up over 120 yards on that many carries on you guys. I liked the fact that you guys did not talk trash, buess that has ended.
Tony Griffin is best back I have seen so far. Not a slight to anyone, Gomez would have been the 2nd though.
Tony Griffin is best back I have seen so far. Not a slight to anyone, Gomez would have been the 2nd though.
Hank Stram
offline
offline
Griffin? Nice back, but he's often held to under four yards a carry...and is fed the ball a LOT more.
Himewad
offline
offline
Since when is talking trash saying that a guy is having a monster season, but had his worst day against us?
I'm just pointing out that opposing HBs aren't getting 13+ yards per carry against my team like is happening in so many games this season. And, yes, Jim Brown got 122 yards against us, but it took him 27 carries to do so. I'll take that average against a great team like yours any time. Same goes for Joe Kibbie and his team.
I'm just pointing out that opposing HBs aren't getting 13+ yards per carry against my team like is happening in so many games this season. And, yes, Jim Brown got 122 yards against us, but it took him 27 carries to do so. I'll take that average against a great team like yours any time. Same goes for Joe Kibbie and his team.
Himewad
offline
offline
Originally posted by Thul
Griffin? Nice back, but he's often held to under four yards a carry...and is fed the ball a LOT more.
Yeah, not sure where the Griffin plug is coming from. He's been under 4 yards per carry in 7 of his 13 games.
Griffin? Nice back, but he's often held to under four yards a carry...and is fed the ball a LOT more.
Yeah, not sure where the Griffin plug is coming from. He's been under 4 yards per carry in 7 of his 13 games.
Himewad
offline
offline
I didn't see that coming. Sayers just took the Garuda offensive MVP lead with a big game against Sault Ste Marie ... 14 rushes for 231 yards, 4 catches for 184 yards, 6 TD. I thought for sure he would just stay where he was.
#2 Xavier Banks still plays the punchless Riverhead Pride in game 16, which should pump his stats nicely, and #3 Joe Kibbie has a HUGE game against the Bangkok Bangers. If the level of competition really has something to do with the MVP race, then a monster performance in that game could still propel him to #1, I would think.
#2 Xavier Banks still plays the punchless Riverhead Pride in game 16, which should pump his stats nicely, and #3 Joe Kibbie has a HUGE game against the Bangkok Bangers. If the level of competition really has something to do with the MVP race, then a monster performance in that game could still propel him to #1, I would think.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























