User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Add a Special Teams Section to the Box Score of Games.
Page:
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Here's the elusive BORT post!

Originally posted by Bort
Noted, and I think it's a great idea to track special teams plays separately somehow (improves the MVP rankings too!). I don't know if I'll be able to get it in for this season, but I will think about how to accomplish it for season 10 at least.

It is now Season 11, and we've actually taken a step backwards. Please Bort...PLEASE!

Current Support/Not Support Tally for thread:
SUPPORT: 22
NOT SUPPORT: 1


This thread pissed me off quite a bit...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2571080

I know, I know, a pancake on Special Teams isn't that fabulous, and I even call Special Teams Special Needs Team, but that's ridiculous. For a statistic to be completely WIPED from the records like that, it needs to be collected elsewhere. You can't simply delete two pancakes from a guy and not put them somewhere else to be tracked. What's the point of any Special Teams play if you're not a returner, kicker, or punter in this case? I see none, if anything you do vanishes.

Here's a perfect example from my own team's game today:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=515876&pbp_id=4826853

This Punt Return for a TD (our only one of the game) is solely because Gonzo Chomsky, a DT, met two defenders just in front of the return man and threw them BOTH to the ground almost immediately. When they got back up, he threw them BOTH to teh ground again, but by that point, the returner was headed to the end zone.

Here's teh box score from that same game: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=515876
If you can find Gonzo Chomsky's name anywhere in the O Line section for a pancake (he should have at least 4 from that play alone) I'll give you a cookie.

I can tell you as a fact that if Gonzo had NOT pancaked the first man, and gotten to the second, the returner would have been tackled quickly, because I can see his build, he's nothing but speed so far, no agility, no carrying, no strength to break free of a tackler. If they would have gotten to him, that return never would have happened.

Just another example of why this is ridiculous.

I know, I know, tackles count...that's what makes no sense. You can't make one thing count, and not another.

|Personally, I would benefit from having a separate stat sheet for special teams play that listed all the guys who played even one down of special teams, |and what they did, because I run a voting system per game for Offensive, Defensive, and SPECIAL TEAMS MVPs, and hand out bonuses per the results of |voting on my team. I find it difficult right now, unless I write it down or somehow remember it through the entire game, how many tackles a guy got on |special teams, because it shows up in the Defense section. The Special Teams statistics area could simply have the following stats within:

Pancaked, Tackles, Missed Tackles, FF, FFR, Pancakes, TD

So, in closing, there are numerous reasons this should happen, and I've listed only three. I'm sure there are more, and I'm sure you guys will list them

Originally posted by Enkidu98
I posted this thread up originally. It was moved to the Sim/Interface forum.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2517204

This is where Bort said it was intended.

My belief is he was tired of seeing people complain about OT's and G's etc with hundreds of pancakes listed. I disagree with him. Players have 60+ TD seasons. Completely unheard of in most all football. All the stats aren;t 'realistic' and so it seems silly to discriminate just on Pancakes.

Also, its very hard to get people to accept special teams jobs. You would do ownersa a huge favour giving them a way to get players 'stats' so they can feel like the player they pay money to boost every season is getting 'props' for their work.

Its a positive feedback loop and a MMORPG shouldn;t be removing positive feedback loops. Instead it should be encouraging them.

So please returns stats to ST's players.


Originally posted by CONN CHRIS
Along with tracking touchbacks for kickers as well as inside 10, inside 5 and gross/net * punting yardage for punters, I agree.

* as opposed to the semi-gross average that has been tracked since season one and pointed out as inadequate since that same season.
Edited by G.O.D Turner on Aug 19, 2009 21:31:55
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Put them back or +1 to OP's suggestion!
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Yeah, taking them out was just incredibly stupid.
 
rocomo
offline
Link
 
If you don't boost most of your players end up on special teams. Now they lose on of their best stats!!!
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Thanks G.O.D
I kind of like the idea of separate stats for special teams. The NFL does it for tackles, assisted tackles, forced fumbles, etc. It's not a stretch to think about doing the same for pancakes too. (Although the NFL doesn't track pancake stats at all.)
http://www.nfl.com/liveupdate/gamecenter/29548/KC_Gamebook.pdf (look on page 5)

Right now the Special Teams MVP doesn't work at all. Last season on special teams only, my special teams OT Fulgenzio had 102 tackles, 46 FF, 155 pancakes, and 2 FR. Under the current system I don't think any of that would have registered toward the Special Teams MVP Race at all.
I bet he would have been top 10 for the Defensive MVP, though, without having played a single down of defense. ETA: In fact right now he has 4 FF in two games and sure enough you see an OT listed as #8 in the defensive MVP rankings. (And no, the answer is not to also stop tracking special teams tackles!)
Last edited Apr 28, 2009 12:51:10
 
gijosh
offline
Link
 
THE NFL Doesnt track tackles as an official stat either. The Teams' own coaches keep track and forward them to media.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Updated O.P with an example of a ST play where the returner broke one for a TD ONLY BECAUSE someone threw two coverage defenders to the turf right away, and added a support tally.
 
vladykins
offline
Link
 
+1 OP
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
support/non support tally to this point.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
I posted this thread up originally. It was moved to the Sim/Interface forum.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2517204

This is where Bort said it was intended.

My belief is he was tired of seeing people complain about OT's and G's etc with hundreds of pancakes listed. I disagree with him. Players have 60+ TD seasons. Completely unheard of in most all football. All the stats aren;t 'realistic' and so it seems silly to discriminate just on Pancakes.

Also, its very hard to get people to accept special teams jobs. You would do ownersa a huge favour giving them a way to get players 'stats' so they can feel like the player they pay money to boost every season is getting 'props' for their work.

Its a positive feedback loop and a MMORPG shouldn;t be removing positive feedback loops. Instead it should be encouraging them.

So please returns stats to ST's players.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
added this to the O.P since it's very relevant, and shows yet another thread about this
 
Link
 
+1. Great Argument made for implementation. Have no choice but to agree.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by edwardwscollins
+1. Great Argument made for implementation. Have no choice but to agree.


I just looked at your agent page and I'm gonna guess you're from NEBRASKA

haha...thanks for the support, added to tally.
 
Sling-n-Bling
offline
Link
 
+1

ST's Box Stats
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
To make this plug and play for Bort, and perhaps get this done quickly (by next season, or mid season 9?) what would be needed for stats on the special teams box score section?

You could leave K/P/R as-is, above, and simply ass in the following, I would think, somewhere in there:

Pancaked, Tackles, Missed Tackles, FF, FFR, Pancakes

Would that pretty much be it? If so, this would be a simple fix I would think...other than solving the issue with ST tackles showing up on the defensive section, too.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.