Kind of a slow time for GLB so I thought I'd give a topic for some fun banter...
My list of the Top 10 NFL QB's of All-Time. (MUST BE RETIRED, and Favre may still play)
#1 Johnny Unitas - The Gold Standard. He was a master tactician who played in the day when a QB called his own plays. Blessed with an uncanny feel for the game, he retired with all the major passing records from the era where bump and run coverage was the norm. He was a pretty good scrambler as well as an unbelievable touch passer. He could throw the bomb and made the technique of looking off the safties, an absolute art form. Was the winning QB in the "Greatest Game Ever Played", the 1958 NFL Championship!
#2 - Sammy Baugh - Before Unitas, Baugh was the first great passer. He led the league numerous times and held every major passing record at the time of his retirement. Baugh was also the greatest DB, and Greatest Punter of his day. From the day he stepped onto campus at SMU to the day of his retirement with the Redskins, Sammy stood alone as the man with the Golden Arm.
#3 - John Elway - Mr. Denver Bronco, he is the identity of the franchise. I know he got rolled in multiple Super Bowls but it was because he had no business being there to start with. The greatest QB at willing his team to victory, including Staubach; when Elway finally got a supporting cast he won the Prize twice!
#4 - Otto Graham - The greatest winner in the history of Pro Football. He ran Paul Brown's revolutionary offenses to perfection. A model of consistency, Otto had no weknesses and combined that with an amazing football IQ.
#5 - Roger Staubach - Captain Comeback. He, along with Elway, and Unitas were the masters of the 2-minute offense. Roger the Dodger missed the first four years of his pro career to a commitment to the US Navy and still became a legend of the game.
#6 - Joe Montana - Not the most physically gifted QB, an average arm, average mobility, on the small side physically. With all those shortcomings, Joe went on to become arguably the best clutch performer the game has ever known.
#7 - Dan Marino - The greatest QB to never win a title. Marino would stand in the pocket like Fouts, deliver with a quick release like Namath. His Dolphin teams were always anemic running teams but he still put up astronomical numbers. Dan's throwing style was a clinic in motion.
#8 - Bobby Layne - You know you're good if you can lead the Detroit Lions to the NFL's promised land. Bobby's Lions won TWO NFL Titles. A fearless gun-slinger, he played as hard off the field as he did on the field. The 2nd best QB of the 50's.
#9 - Steve Young - Best multi-threat QB who ever played. SF hardly missed a beat when Montana passed the baton to Steve. Ran a legit 4.5 40 with the moves to match, this lefty could throw on a rope. The greatest left-handed QB of All-time. Sorry Snake.
#10 - Sonny Jurgenson - He was so good that Vince Lombardi took the head coaching job in Washington just so he could coach Sonny. He was second, only to Unitas during his playing day's, but hey, who wouldn't be?
This is all my opinion of which I am an expert. Feel free to comment, critique, suggest others (give an explanation), etc.
My list of the Top 10 NFL QB's of All-Time. (MUST BE RETIRED, and Favre may still play)
#1 Johnny Unitas - The Gold Standard. He was a master tactician who played in the day when a QB called his own plays. Blessed with an uncanny feel for the game, he retired with all the major passing records from the era where bump and run coverage was the norm. He was a pretty good scrambler as well as an unbelievable touch passer. He could throw the bomb and made the technique of looking off the safties, an absolute art form. Was the winning QB in the "Greatest Game Ever Played", the 1958 NFL Championship!
#2 - Sammy Baugh - Before Unitas, Baugh was the first great passer. He led the league numerous times and held every major passing record at the time of his retirement. Baugh was also the greatest DB, and Greatest Punter of his day. From the day he stepped onto campus at SMU to the day of his retirement with the Redskins, Sammy stood alone as the man with the Golden Arm.
#3 - John Elway - Mr. Denver Bronco, he is the identity of the franchise. I know he got rolled in multiple Super Bowls but it was because he had no business being there to start with. The greatest QB at willing his team to victory, including Staubach; when Elway finally got a supporting cast he won the Prize twice!
#4 - Otto Graham - The greatest winner in the history of Pro Football. He ran Paul Brown's revolutionary offenses to perfection. A model of consistency, Otto had no weknesses and combined that with an amazing football IQ.
#5 - Roger Staubach - Captain Comeback. He, along with Elway, and Unitas were the masters of the 2-minute offense. Roger the Dodger missed the first four years of his pro career to a commitment to the US Navy and still became a legend of the game.
#6 - Joe Montana - Not the most physically gifted QB, an average arm, average mobility, on the small side physically. With all those shortcomings, Joe went on to become arguably the best clutch performer the game has ever known.
#7 - Dan Marino - The greatest QB to never win a title. Marino would stand in the pocket like Fouts, deliver with a quick release like Namath. His Dolphin teams were always anemic running teams but he still put up astronomical numbers. Dan's throwing style was a clinic in motion.
#8 - Bobby Layne - You know you're good if you can lead the Detroit Lions to the NFL's promised land. Bobby's Lions won TWO NFL Titles. A fearless gun-slinger, he played as hard off the field as he did on the field. The 2nd best QB of the 50's.
#9 - Steve Young - Best multi-threat QB who ever played. SF hardly missed a beat when Montana passed the baton to Steve. Ran a legit 4.5 40 with the moves to match, this lefty could throw on a rope. The greatest left-handed QB of All-time. Sorry Snake.
#10 - Sonny Jurgenson - He was so good that Vince Lombardi took the head coaching job in Washington just so he could coach Sonny. He was second, only to Unitas during his playing day's, but hey, who wouldn't be?
This is all my opinion of which I am an expert. Feel free to comment, critique, suggest others (give an explanation), etc.
Last edited Apr 13, 2009 20:15:23






























